Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

ChatGPT-5: Manhatta...
 
Notifications
Clear all

ChatGPT-5: Manhattan Project 2.0

Page 15 / 18
OneEyedUndertaker
(@oneeyedundertaker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@oneeyedundertaker 

I’ve had several discussions with my neuroradiologist friend about how AI impacts his field.  He said AI can spot anomalies and conditions in the brain when they are barely developed.  It finds conditions at a much earlier stage than a human can see.  In this sense, I think AI is like a telescope.  It allows humans to be more effective, but it doesn’t create knowledge or decide treatments. 

Not yet, but it will…

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 2:47 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @oneeyedundertaker
↑

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@oneeyedundertaker 

I’ve had several discussions with my neuroradiologist friend about how AI impacts his field.  He said AI can spot anomalies and conditions in the brain when they are barely developed.  It finds conditions at a much earlier stage than a human can see.  In this sense, I think AI is like a telescope.  It allows humans to be more effective, but it doesn’t create knowledge or decide treatments. 

Not yet, but it will…

Indubitably. Just as soon as Man figures out how to program it to be aware of being aware and think.


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/10/2025 9:08 pm
Bulk VH
(@bulk-vh)
Member Moderator
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

@bradstevens

Key quote:

“The bet, the hope is they know how to discover the remaining ideas to get to superintelligence—that there are going to be a handful of algorithmic ideas and, you know, medium-sized handful of people who can figure them out,” Altman replied.

—————

I don’t know what Altman conceives “superintelligence” exactly to be, to come anywhere close to human thought or creativity implies the assumption that human thought or creativity is algorithmic in nature or can captured through algorithmic approximation.

That assumption is the underlying bet.

Obviously it works for lots of problem solving. But can it solve, for example, the problem of insanity, one proof of which would be Man no longer fighting wars, no longer having nuclear arsenals, and so on? 

Not to say  psychology or cognitive “science” has made any progress in that direction so tasking AI to solve that is surely worth the attempt  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/11/2025 7:32 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

I think it will bleed everywhere, but I think there is something inherent about the AI revolution that might slow things down: namely that it will be easier to replace the elites than the drones.

Will the elites still need the drones?! Who’s to say the “world” on earth needs more than 100,000 people? 10,000 people? Inbreeding might no longer  be needed for reproduction. 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/11/2025 7:44 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

To the naturalist, God=Easter Bunny in ontological

I’m wondering why this term naturalist even arrived in this discussion.

Are you talking about modern-day empirical scientists? Or bloviating ivory-tower philosophers?

Empirical scientists, if pushed philosophically, would freely admit to being agnostic as scientists, even if atheist in their personal beliefs. In other words, they would admit  they are assuming that human beings are the brain. They know full well that’s merely an operating assumption that’s never been proved.

There’s no limit to the number of empirical experiments that could be conducted with the assumption that humans beings are  operating perpendicular to or independent of the physical universe, without viewing it as supernatural in your sense of the word.

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/11/2025 8:00 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@hhlurker 

I was struck by @bradstevens argument that the nature of the human mind is ( or could be ) a philosophical question instead of a scientific question.  I’ve never thought about the brain that way.  It’s interesting and might make some sense.  Either way, we start with certain assumptions.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/11/2025 11:53 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@hhlurker 

Hm. Can an AI built and developed in Iran see a solution to the human conflict problem the same way as an AI built and developed in Israel?  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/11/2025 12:01 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

Particularly interesting to me is that we can discuss what is in Dostoevsky’s mind as we read what he wrote.  This ability goes for all of humanity and in this sense, all minds are linked in varying ways.  Is that philosophy of the mind?  I don’t see it like that.  

Here's how our AI overlords describe it:

The ability of humans to communicate thoughts through writing is a topic explored extensively in the philosophy of mind, intertwining concepts of language, consciousness, and the very nature of human cognition. 
Here's how different philosophical perspectives on the mind approach this phenomenon:
1. Representational Theory of Mind (RTM)
  • Key Idea: RTM suggests that mental states, such as beliefs, desires, and thoughts, connect to mental representations within the brain.
  • Writing's Role: From this perspective, writing creates external representations, like written words and sentences, that match internal mental representations. Internal "language of thought" is translated into written symbols, enabling others to understand and recreate those thoughts.
  • Significance: Writing expands representational capacity beyond individual minds. It allows for a shared body of knowledge and supports complex thought that might not exist without externalizing ideas. 
2. Language of Thought Hypothesis (LOTH)
  • Key Idea: As a specific form of RTM, LOTH proposes that mental representations have a linguistic structure. Thoughts are "sentences in the head" made up of mental symbols that have syntax and semantics.
  • Writing's Role: Writing involves mapping internal "mentalese" sentences onto the structure of a natural language. This allows for written communication.
  • Significance: The link between the compositionality of thought and the compositionality of language, as seen in writing, highlights how complex expression is connected to complex thought. 
3. The Relationship Between Language and Thought
  • The Debate: A long-standing debate exists regarding whether language serves mainly for thought or for communication.
  • Writing's Role: Writing provides a clear example of how language fulfills both functions. It allows thoughts to be processed and refined while also offering a way to share those thoughts across time and distance.
  • Significance: Writing shows that expressing thoughts through language, whether spoken or written, can greatly influence and enhance both individual thought processes and the sharing of knowledge. 
4. The Impact of Writing Systems on Cognition
  • Evolutionary Perspective: The development of writing systems, from ancient hieroglyphs to modern alphabets, shows a gradual process of adapting external representations to cognitive abilities.
  • Cognitive Load Reduction: As writing systems became more standardized, the cognitive effort needed for writing decreased. This allowed individuals to focus more on the content of their thoughts rather than the mechanics of writing.
  • Significance: Writing systems show an interaction between cognitive architecture and created tools, highlighting how technology can shape and expand mental capacities. 
In short, the philosophy of mind views writing as more than just a mechanical act. It sees writing as a major extension of human thought and communication. It lets humans make their inner world real, share it with others, and take part in a continuous cultural effort that shapes individual and collective thinking. 
 
***********
 
Some of the links this article supplies are great. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy is the gold standard for reference guides (nothing can really be complete in this discipline, obviously).  Searle, too, has been linked and he's a top-notch thinker. 
 
A lot of top-notch thinkers--better than you and me--have spent their lives devoted to thinking and writing about these topics. Ignoring them just because you have some weird aversion to the word "philosophy" is arrogant or sour grapes or lazy or unserious or I-don't-know-what-but-something-not-good. 
 
Furthermore, to the extent political conservatives join you in that anti-intellectualism, they do themselves and their cause a great disservice. Good book on that topic and here's a review from an organization I assume you "trust"--the (Russell) Kirk Center:
 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/11/2025 5:55 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@bradstevens 

thanks for the thoughtful reply.

However, the point I’m exploring and trying to discuss is not about outputs and communication of our thoughts.  Instead I’m thinking about who we are based on all the inputs to our brain, and how those inputs, and experiences, are converted to memories, washed through our millions of connections, all to form our individuality.  Some people hang on to negative things and that affects who they are, others hang on to positive things leading to the opposite result.  Some people worry about the future and others are hopeful about it.  It’s all interesting and I never really thought of this as a philosophical exercise.  But I guess it could be.  

Along those lines, I do not have an aversion to philosophy and I willingly engage in a variety of philosophical discussions.  I also don’t reject elitism, although some elites are arrogant and fool themselves by faking it.

 

Regarding the link about conservatism. I agree that the concept was inchoate for years, between Burke and the middle of the 20th century.  Interesting that Burke never used the word “ conservative” yet he laid the foundation.  I credit Buckley for putting intellectual heft into conservative politics.  Of course there will be those who believe opposite things while both claiming to be conservative.  That’s an ongoing thing, but doesn’t diminish what we are.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/11/2025 9:35 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@hhlurker 

I was struck by @bradstevens argument that the nature of the human mind is ( or could be ) a philosophical question instead of a scientific question.  I’ve never thought about the brain that way.  It’s interesting and might make some sense.  Either way, we start with certain assumptions.  

In the grand scheme of things I don’t separate the two. As in, there nothing more practical than a good theory. Both ivory-tower philosophizing and empirical-science theorizing tend to precede actual experimentation or application, but the theory and practice remain joined to discover any semblance of scientific validity. 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/12/2025 6:29 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

@bradstevens Thanks!


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/12/2025 6:49 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

@co-hoosier I appreciate the angle you’re taking.

I’m taking the angle of a reductio ad absurdum deep dive into the cognitive science definition of memory, thought and such aspects of their theory. of course they’re placing all that stuff in the brain, so I’m examining what they say and especially what they omit. 

For example where is a particular memory located? Unable to pin down an exact location, they appear to be theorizing that it’s a network of locations. This immediately leads to the question, where is the information that connects that network located? (To say nothing of where is the location of the mastermind doing the connecting…) And if that information is a network then where is the information connecting that network? Reductio ad absurdum…

Then I get into more concrete information about the actual physical medium of storage capacity in the brain. Not necessarily easy to pin this theory down either, but it seems that much or most of it is considered to be in the synapses. This leads me to question if they are asking physical objects to perform two or more different functions simultaneously?

And in the @BradStevens post on the philosophy of the mind, where is the thought representation located…?

 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/12/2025 7:06 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

@co-hoosier @bradstevens 

One glaring omission (if I’m not mistaken) is precisely the location of … the Easter Bunny! By that I mean “abstract” or “imaginary” thoughts or ideas. 

We know they exist because we talk about them. So in “naturalist” theory, where are they located and what are they composed of? Matter, energy?

After all, if the naturalist brushes them off as “imaginary” isn’t he committing an act of believing in the supernatural? 

Purple apple. Voila! Purple apple now exists as a concept. Pure and simple. It either exists in the physical universe or it doesn’t. A naturalist can’t assert that a purple apple is imaginary prior to acknowledging that it exists as a concept. And if it exists, it exists. Whether conceptually or otherwise. It just flat-out exists. So where is it?


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/12/2025 7:20 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

@co-hoosier @bradstevens 

 

Perhaps the most basic philosophical irony for a naturalist philosopher is to posit an idea.


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/12/2025 7:24 am
Page 15 / 18
Share: