Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

TSP For All to repl...
 
Notifications
Clear all

TSP For All to replace Social Security.

Aloha Hoosier's avatar
(@aloha-hoosier)
Famed Member

My TSP account is over $600K and I haven't put anything into it in years (I also have investments in Schwab). Military wasn't eligible for TSP for over half my career so this is from only about 13 years of investments. Here's the latest newsletter:

Making the most of your TSP in retirement


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/07/2025 9:46 am
Noodle
(@noodle)
Reputable Member

I have always wondered what moving social security funds to equity investments, etc. would do to equity markets. Would be a huge influx of money. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/07/2025 10:02 am
👍
2
Aloha Hoosier's avatar
(@aloha-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @noodle
↑

I have always wondered what moving social security funds to equity investments, etc. would do to equity markets. Would be a huge influx of money. 

It would be and would have to be done in stages. At a certain age, they'd get regular SS. New workers would get some form of the TSP plan and it would take some planning to do those in between with a mix of old and new. I think it would be super popular. I took $100K from TSP for part of the down payment on our Arizona house. TSP has already recovered half of that.

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/07/2025 11:09 am
👍
3
NPT's avatar
 NPT
(@npt)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @noodle
↑

I have always wondered what moving social security funds to equity investments, etc. would do to equity markets. Would be a huge influx of money. 

Bush mentioned doing something like that and there was so much uproar that nothing was ever tried.

 


There are 10 types of people in this world, those who know binary and those who don't.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/07/2025 12:55 pm
👍
3
NPT's avatar
 NPT
(@npt)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @aloha-hoosier
↑

Posted by: @noodle
↑

I have always wondered what moving social security funds to equity investments, etc. would do to equity markets. Would be a huge influx of money. 

It would be and would have to be done in stages. At a certain age, they'd get regular SS. New workers would get some form of the TSP plan and it would take some planning to do those in between with a mix of old and new. I think it would be super popular. I took $100K from TSP for part of the down payment on our Arizona house. TSP has already recovered half of that.

 

A lot of companies have good savings plans and people don't get in.  Where I worked they initially offer 50 cents on the dollar on up to 6% of your salary but  normally matched dollar per dollar.  When I started working there there was a limited number of options in the plan but it quickly expanded to where you could have a self directed plan and invest as you saw fit.

 


There are 10 types of people in this world, those who know binary and those who don't.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/07/2025 1:01 pm
👍
2
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@npt 

Bush really got hammered for even suggesting a money purchase individual plan, like TSP, to help save Social Security.  

Obama pounded  nails in the individual ownership coffin by railing against “Darwin economics”.  I personally think that at least a partial money purchase plan tied into social security is a good idea.  I have zero confidence that half the members of Congress could even understand the differences between a money purchase plan and a defined benefit plan let alone understand the long term ramifications. If any plan doesn’t include provisions for the rich to pay a “fair share” most Democrats won’t be interested.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/07/2025 1:10 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@noodle 

Moving to outside equity markets is one issue.  Another, and perhaps larger issue, is moving towards individual ownership of a money purchase plan and away from government ownership of a defined benefit plan.  Even if the government money purchase plan required investments in instruments guaranteed by the U.S. government, the impact would be huge.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/07/2025 1:15 pm
👍
1
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @aloha-hoosier
↑

It would be and would have to be done in stages. At a certain age, they’d get regular SS. New workers would get some form of the TSP plan and it would take some planning to do those in between with a mix of old and new. I think it would be super popular. I took $100K from TSP for part of the down payment on our Arizona house. TSP has already recovered half of that.

Way too many people don't manage money worth a shit. That's why so many depend on SS for most or all of their retirement income. I'd be fine making a TSP-like program mandatory and requiring a minimum of 1% of wages be withheld and invested beginning day 1, but only in addition to SS. Also need to keep people from tapping into it before reaching retirement age. At some point, once the TSP investors near retirement age, you can begin "phasing out" SS simply by doing away with the COLA. Eventually SS would be inconsequential.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/07/2025 5:56 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Obama tried small-scale changes that true conservatives should have supported.  But it had problems. I think one solution is a govt held plan that is contributed to by employers and follows the employee rather than the employees have to enroll, roll over etc every time they switch jobs:

 

During the Obama administration, behavioral economics, particularly the concept of nudges, was explored as a way to improve retirement savings, especially through 401(k) plans

. 

Here's a breakdown of the key elements and results related to the Obama-era nudges and behavioral economics in 401(k) plans:
1. Automatic enrollment
  • A primary nudge involved promoting automatic enrollment in 401(k) and other retirement plans.
  • The idea was to counter inertia, as many people intend to save but don't actively take the steps to enroll.
  • Studies show automatic enrollment significantly boosts participation, with participation jumping from 70% (voluntary enrollment) to 90% (automatic enrollment with opt-out option).
  • This was particularly effective for lower-income workers, who saw participation rates triple when automatically enrolled. 
2. Automatic escalation
  • Another nudge involved automatic escalation, where contribution rates automatically increase over time unless the employee opts out.
  • The goal was to encourage individuals to increase their savings rate as their income grows. 
3. Auto-IRA proposal
  • The Obama administration proposed the Auto-IRA, a universal program requiring employers not offering retirement plans to auto-enroll employees in an IRA, with an opt-out option.
  • The goal was to expand retirement savings access to more workers. 
4. Overall effectiveness and challenges
  • Generally, these nudges, particularly automatic enrollment, were found to be effective in increasing plan participation and initial savings.
  • However, research during and after the Obama administration revealed a more nuanced picture of their long-term impact on net savings:
    • Modest long-term effect: Recent studies suggest that, after accounting for factors like job-switching and other savings behaviors, the net savings increase from automatic enrollment and escalation might be smaller than initially thought.
    • Impact of job-switching:Frequent job changes in the US mean nudges may not have enough time to significantly impact long-term savings.
    • Leakage: Workers with small automatically enrolled balances are more likely to cash out their 401(k) upon leaving a job, eroding some of the gains.
    • Overall financial health: Some research suggests that increased retirement savings due to nudges may come at the expense of increased credit card debt, highlighting the need to consider a person's overall financial picture, https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/do-nudges-help-americans-save-for-retirement-not-as-much-as-we-thought&ved=2ahUKEwjR5NrZtfuOAxXtN94AHfV_OdsQy_kOegQIChAG&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw0ksBrp3U3dq2JvH81XGXgV&ust=175474957445100 0" target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-processed="true">according to Yale Insights.
    • Wealthier workers benefit more:Evidence suggests wealthier workers may benefit disproportionately from retirement savings nudges. 
In conclusion, the Obama administration's emphasis on behavioral economics and nudges like automatic enrollment in 401(k) plans had a demonstrable positive impact on retirement plan participation, particularly for previously underserved groups. However, the long-term effects on net savings are complex and might be smaller than initially predicted, warranting further research and a holistic view of individuals' financial situations when designing and evaluating such policies. 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/08/2025 9:31 am
👍
2
sig
 sig
(@sig)
Reputable Member

If the govt. gave me all SS funds paid by myself and my employers at the todays value, I gladly take it and they would not have to give me a penny ever again.  So if it takes $2 to buy what $1 bought in 1980 then double the funds paid in 1980 and buy me out. Calcualte it year by year. SS is such a ponzi scheme. 

Jo Jorgensen has a great plan for phasing out SS but keeping it as an option if you would prefer using the govt.'s plan. Eventually you would be able to slash those govt departments expenses greatly once the majority have opted out. 

I think govt. needs to honor what has been contributed but certainly if given the choice to choose where to invest that money, no-one would choose the federal govt which consists of a bunch of idiots who can't even manage getting their heads out of their A much less someone's money unless they are stealing it.  Even when stealing it via federal taxes it is poorly managed. Who knows what the Feds do with the money they steal under the table.   


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/08/2025 10:01 am
Ohio Guy
(@ohio-guy)
Noble Member

@aloha-hoosier This thread is sort of motivating for me. I feel like I have a good, but not great amount in retirement. I turn 50 in a couple of weeks and both my kids will be out of college in '28...my plan is to be pretty aggressive soon. On my list of to dos is to look at how to do that over the next several months.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/08/2025 11:08 am
👍
1
Share: