Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

ChatGPT-5: Manhatta...
 
Notifications
Clear all

ChatGPT-5: Manhattan Project 2.0

Page 14 / 18
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

But on theoretical possibilities, I don’t think you have a very strong grasp on how thinking, thought formation, etc. work in the human brain. I’m guessing that’s because you think humans are some sui generis form of life in the universe and that our thinking comes from some supernatural source.

Wow. Would you be offended if I said this is the most primitive and naive comment I’ve seen from you in all the time we’ve interacted?  I hope not, cuz I just said it. 

The inner space of the human brain is as unknown as the expanse of the cosmos.  The inner reaches of our minds goes far beyond what we consciously experience.  The inner space is enormous.  We remain unaware of all that happens as we mindlessly decide what shoes to wear or what to grab from the refrigerator.  Merely teaching an AI robot to do either task takes huge human effort, huge apparatus, and the AI robot will never get better at it.  Contrast that with our minds.  How you act, how you decide, how you choose a TV show, how you recognize your dog, how you chose between good and bad, true and false, or real and fantasy, all takes place within a few pounds of mush between our ears.  And that happens before we figure out how to build an argument and persuade a three judge panel how to rule in our favor.  

All that we think and do is the product of unbelievably complex networks buried deep in our minds.  And I don’t think we have really scratched the surface about how it all works.  One thing I know for sure, I’m not very concerned about building a machine to do all of this.

 

finally, I think the question of a human soul, human consciousness, and who or what is driving the ship is fascinating and is beyond our reach at this time.  

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 8:07 am
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

@co-hoosier I’m not offended because I don’t think you’re very educated on the philosophy of mind, cognitive science, AI, or human development (ie early childhood learning and education). Proof is that you keep referencing building a duplicate human mind even though goat spelled it out for you.  And you hold out for a human soul—proving I was right, you are a supernaturalist. (Soul=Easter Bunny).

But I realize and admit that I could be wrong on AIs potential. Do you? Neither of us is an expert and even experts don’t talk in terms of certainty here. But those experts and the businesses developing AI sure think this is very very powerful—they’re currently offering $100 million signing bonuses on top of that same amount in an annual salary to land top talent.  

https://fortune.com/2025/08/09/sam-altman-ai-talent-war-pay-offers-superintelligence-discoveries-meta/

 

 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 8:31 am
snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @mcm666
↑

@bradstevens 

hoos.  always one step ahead.  

and circling back i'm not sure you're right.  why would ai have boundaries.  why wouldn't it bleed into literature art etc. why wouldn't it replace authors.  musicians.   the deeply personal bit that attends all of our favorite works.  divorce.  being single.  raising kids single.  holidays.  growing older.  career angst.  all of those things that richard ford captures so beautifully that so many relate to AI could mimic in it's arm's length sterile way thereby depriving humanity of that connection.  knowing that another human thinks what you think and has this gift to be able to express and share it.  

i hate ai already

I think it will bleed everywhere, but I think there is something inherent about the AI revolution that might slow things down: namely that it will be easier to replace the elites than the drones.

Think about your local Hooters (if Hooters even still exists; I'm not sure): AI can already do the job of the regional manager, upper level executives, probably even the CEO. But AI is nowhere close to replacing the Hooters waitress. AI can't wear a tiny tight outfit and flirt tableside with the guests. The day is coming, I'm sure, but it will be easier to replace the brains than it will be to replace the low-level front lines folks (and probably more cost-effective, too).

Well, history tells us when it's the other way around, when it's cost-effective to replace the lower level workers, it happens very quickly. But when it's the elites who are staring straight into obsolescence, I bet they come up with artificial barriers to the implementation of AI really quickly.

I joked above that AI can probably already do Congress' job, but replacing governing officials will be the last thing AI does simply because the governing officials have the political power to prevent it from happening. But now I think I accidentally hit upon some truth with that joke.

 

It's going to--already is, actually--hollow out starter jobs for paper pushers and middle management. Elites will be using the AI to do this.  I see it as increasing the income/wealth gap tremendously.  

 

The only way AI takes over is if it’s able to create goods and services cheaper. How does the wealth gap increase tremendously as the cost of everything is dropping to zero?  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 8:41 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

The only way AI takes over is if it’s able to create goods and services cheaper. How does the wealth gap increase tremendously as the cost of everything is dropping to zero?  

AI doesn't need to "take over" to increase the wealth gap.  Any big advance in technology, that allows one person to do the work of lower-level people is probably going to increase the wealth gap.  

But one example--take StollCPA, by all accounts (hehehe) a very hardworking, conscientious, and capable CPA.  AI will undoubtedly get to the point in the very near future that it can do a lot of the scutt work he would have done in his career or would have had to hire someone to do. It will also be able to double check his work at the level of a certain level of CPA.  Now, the 25-year-old future Stoll will be able to do more in far less time with far fewer mistakes and as a result take on more and more clients. But there are a limited # of clients, so he will be taking them away from the other lower-level CPAs.  Multiply that across the world, in many, many industries.  Sure, the prices might go down, too, but the wealth gap between the great CPAs and the mediocre will increase.  This is even more drastic if the AI does away with CPAs altogether, of course, which is entirely possible.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 9:06 am
snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

The only way AI takes over is if it’s able to create goods and services cheaper. How does the wealth gap increase tremendously as the cost of everything is dropping to zero?  

AI doesn't need to "take over" to increase the wealth gap.  Any big advance in technology, that allows one person to do the work of lower-level people is probably going to increase the wealth gap.  

But one example--take StollCPA, by all accounts (hehehe) a very hardworking, conscientious, and capable CPA.  AI will undoubtedly get to the point in the very near future that it can do a lot of the scutt work he would have done in his career or would have had to hire someone to do. It will also be able to double check his work at the level of a certain level of CPA.  Now, the 25-year-old future Stoll will be able to do more in far less time with far fewer mistakes and as a result take on more and more clients. But there are a limited # of clients, so he will be taking them away from the other lower-level CPAs.  Multiply that across the world, in many, many industries.  Sure, the prices might go down, too, but the wealth gap between the great CPAs and the mediocre will increase.  This is even more drastic if the AI does away with CPAs altogether, of course, which is entirely possible.  

 

That's already happened in endless job fields.  The young Stoll will choose a different job and end up getting his taxes done for less than what his Dad would have charged him😁  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 9:57 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@hhlurker 

I don’t fear the geniuses who create AI.  We should all fear the rubes who will certainly misuse it.  

Of course. Pandora’s box and all. Just ask the scientists who built the bomb. That was more rhetorical flourish. My basic point above is that AIs will never, can never compare to human potential. 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/10/2025 10:20 am
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

@snarlcakes That’s the hope. The concern is that AI is going to displace a lot/most of those jobs.  There are only so many plumbers and electricians we need.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 10:49 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

i’m not offended because I don’t think you’re very educated on the philosophy of mind, cognitive science, AI, or human development (ie early childhood learning and education). Proof is that you keep referencing building a duplicate human mind even though goat spelled it out for you.  And you hold out for a human soul—proving I was right, you are a supernaturalist. (Soul=Easter Bunny).

Hm.  Stating disagreement by belittling the education and knowledge of another does not show me a very high-functioning cognitive ability.  I won’t list my bona fides but I will add that if you want to discuss “philosophy of mind” I’ll have no clue what you are talking about. While I’m not surprised some academic types would embark on that journey, I don’t think it has any use in what we are talking about. 

If you don’t like the word soul because of its spiritual connotation, try consciousness.  My point is to describe the epicenter of who we are including thoughts, emotions etc.  That is as unique to each individual as a fingerprint. 

I don’t believe I discussed looking at AI as a duplicate brain.  I don’t believe that is or even can be the case.  But I do see AI as performing human tasks.  Some of my comments about AI is influenced by applying AI through robotics, which I believe I have above casual knowledge about.  Multi-tasking robots are  a big complex deal. 

I am well aware of the many comments and predictions about AI from Altman and others.  Unlike you, however, I haven’t seen or heard anything that gives me the angst you have posted about. 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 10:57 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

Hm.  Stating disagreement by belittling the education and knowledge of another does not show me a very high-functioning cognitive ability.  I won’t list my bona fides but I will add that if you want to discuss “philosophy of mind” I’ll have no clue what you are talking about. While I’m not surprised some academic types would embark on that journey, I don’t think it has any use in what we are talking about. 

Belitting a subject matter you know nothing about "does not show me a very high-functioning cognitive ability." It's especially ironic that you wrote that in the same paragraph that you say the philosophy of mind has no use in this area, and then in the very next sentence (in the next paragraph) bring up consciousness. Next level stuff, there.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 11:50 am
👍
1
Bulk VH
(@bulk-vh)
Member Moderator

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

The only way AI takes over is if it’s able to create goods and services cheaper. How does the wealth gap increase tremendously as the cost of everything is dropping to zero?  

AI doesn't need to "take over" to increase the wealth gap.  Any big advance in technology, that allows one person to do the work of lower-level people is probably going to increase the wealth gap.  

But one example--take StollCPA, by all accounts (hehehe) a very hardworking, conscientious, and capable CPA.  AI will undoubtedly get to the point in the very near future that it can do a lot of the scutt work he would have done in his career or would have had to hire someone to do. It will also be able to double check his work at the level of a certain level of CPA.  Now, the 25-year-old future Stoll will be able to do more in far less time with far fewer mistakes and as a result take on more and more clients. But there are a limited # of clients, so he will be taking them away from the other lower-level CPAs.  Multiply that across the world, in many, many industries.  Sure, the prices might go down, too, but the wealth gap between the great CPAs and the mediocre will increase.  This is even more drastic if the AI does away with CPAs altogether, of course, which is entirely possible.  

 

Scientist have already developed a machine capable of doing stoll's job.

 

 


.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 12:20 pm
👍
2
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

Hm.  Stating disagreement by belittling the education and knowledge of another does not show me a very high-functioning cognitive ability.  

Those who can’t say how say that.


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/10/2025 1:22 pm
OneEyedUndertaker
(@oneeyedundertaker)
Noble Member

Many of you are making the mistake of thinking only in terms of what AI can do now & limiting to what it might become to your imagination.  It will learn, it will begin to create knowledge, & it will surpass humans in most quantifiable fields such as math, science, medical fields, engineering, etc.  Will it be able to write beautiful music or write masterpiece novels?  I’m betting yes….


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 1:39 pm
👍
1
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Jimmy Carr on AI replacing people:

 

https://m.youtube.com/shorts/0rHJZE-HqpE


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/10/2025 1:54 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@bradstevens 

OK, you win, kinda.  I just Googled “philosophy of the mind” and the Google AI said it deals with questions that I’ve read about for decades, but I have never seen that term.  20 or so years ago, I took an OLI course about the brain and plasticity. I talked with the professor about what is the difference between the brain and the mind.  He talked about consciousness and how we struggle with understanding that, he never brought philosophical concepts into the discussion as I recall.  It was all about science of how the brain works.  

I don’t see how anybody can really believe the mind is separate from the body, unless, as you say, they are a supernaturalist.  I personally believe the body, particularly the senses, are built to serve the brain, to develop it, expand it, and cause it to evolve through time.  We hear, see, smell, touch, and feel with our brains, not with our eyes and ears etc. those are just things our brains use. Particularly interesting to me is that we can discuss what is in Dostoevsky’s mind as we read what he wrote.  This ability goes for all of humanity and in this sense, all minds are linked in varying ways.  Is that philosophy of the mind?  I don’t see it like that.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 2:11 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@oneeyedundertaker 

I’ve had several discussions with my neuroradiologist friend about how AI impacts his field.  He said AI can spot anomalies and conditions in the brain when they are barely developed.  It finds conditions at a much earlier stage than a human can see.  In this sense, I think AI is like a telescope.  It allows humans to be more effective, but it doesn’t create knowledge or decide treatments. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 2:22 pm
Page 14 / 18
Share: