Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

ChatGPT-5: Manhatta...
 
Notifications
Clear all

ChatGPT-5: Manhattan Project 2.0

Page 13 / 18
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @mcm666
↑

and circling back i’m not sure you’re right.  why would ai have boundaries.  why wouldn’t it bleed into literature art etc. why wouldn’t it replace authors.  musicians.   the deeply personal bit that attends all of our favorite works.  divorce.  being single.  raising kids single.  holidays.  growing older.  career angst.  all of those things that richard ford captures so beautifully that so many relate to AI could mimic in it’s arm’s length sterile way thereby depriving humanity of that connection.  knowing that another human thinks what you think and has this gift to be able to express and share it.  

I don't know the answer. But if humans are repulsed by AI generated art or stories, then we have to factor that in. Of course, they could probably figure out why and alter their output to match those feelings, too.  

We're doomed.  But hey, maybe we're birthing an entirely new and superior form of life.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 6:34 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@goat 

You see only absolutes. I see only arguments supporting differing points of view.  No absolutes.  It’s been like this for years. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 7:52 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@goat 

You see only absolutes. I see only arguments supporting differing points of view.  No absolutes.  It’s been like this for years. 

That makes no sense whatsoever.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 7:54 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@bradstevens 

Aint gonna happen.  Every two-bit bar on a beach or a ski area has live music even it it’s one guy singing with electronically- generated back up.  People aren’t gonna hang out with a box full of chips. Live art is live art.  It won’t make any difference if it is in a book, in earbuds, or on stage.  I don’t think there is any way a machine can satisfy.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 8:12 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @mcm666
↑

@bradstevens 

hoos.  always one step ahead.  

and circling back i'm not sure you're right.  why would ai have boundaries.  why wouldn't it bleed into literature art etc. why wouldn't it replace authors.  musicians.   the deeply personal bit that attends all of our favorite works.  divorce.  being single.  raising kids single.  holidays.  growing older.  career angst.  all of those things that richard ford captures so beautifully that so many relate to AI could mimic in it's arm's length sterile way thereby depriving humanity of that connection.  knowing that another human thinks what you think and has this gift to be able to express and share it.  

i hate ai already

I think it will bleed everywhere, but I think there is something inherent about the AI revolution that might slow things down: namely that it will be easier to replace the elites than the drones.

Think about your local Hooters (if Hooters even still exists; I'm not sure): AI can already do the job of the regional manager, upper level executives, probably even the CEO. But AI is nowhere close to replacing the Hooters waitress. AI can't wear a tiny tight outfit and flirt tableside with the guests. The day is coming, I'm sure, but it will be easier to replace the brains than it will be to replace the low-level front lines folks (and probably more cost-effective, too).

Well, history tells us when it's the other way around, when it's cost-effective to replace the lower level workers, it happens very quickly. But when it's the elites who are staring straight into obsolescence, I bet they come up with artificial barriers to the implementation of AI really quickly.

I joked above that AI can probably already do Congress' job, but replacing governing officials will be the last thing AI does simply because the governing officials have the political power to prevent it from happening. But now I think I accidentally hit upon some truth with that joke.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 9:11 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @mcm666
↑

@bradstevens 

hoos.  always one step ahead.  

and circling back i'm not sure you're right.  why would ai have boundaries.  why wouldn't it bleed into literature art etc. why wouldn't it replace authors.  musicians.   the deeply personal bit that attends all of our favorite works.  divorce.  being single.  raising kids single.  holidays.  growing older.  career angst.  all of those things that richard ford captures so beautifully that so many relate to AI could mimic in it's arm's length sterile way thereby depriving humanity of that connection.  knowing that another human thinks what you think and has this gift to be able to express and share it.  

i hate ai already

I think it will bleed everywhere, but I think there is something inherent about the AI revolution that might slow things down: namely that it will be easier to replace the elites than the drones.

Think about your local Hooters (if Hooters even still exists; I'm not sure): AI can already do the job of the regional manager, upper level executives, probably even the CEO. But AI is nowhere close to replacing the Hooters waitress. AI can't wear a tiny tight outfit and flirt tableside with the guests. The day is coming, I'm sure, but it will be easier to replace the brains than it will be to replace the low-level front lines folks (and probably more cost-effective, too).

Well, history tells us when it's the other way around, when it's cost-effective to replace the lower level workers, it happens very quickly. But when it's the elites who are staring straight into obsolescence, I bet they come up with artificial barriers to the implementation of AI really quickly.

I joked above that AI can probably already do Congress' job, but replacing governing officials will be the last thing AI does simply because the governing officials have the political power to prevent it from happening. But now I think I accidentally hit upon some truth with that joke.

 

It's going to--already is, actually--hollow out starter jobs for paper pushers and middle management. Elites will be using the AI to do this.  I see it as increasing the income/wealth gap tremendously.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 11:06 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @mcm666
↑

@bradstevens 

hoos.  always one step ahead.  

and circling back i'm not sure you're right.  why would ai have boundaries.  why wouldn't it bleed into literature art etc. why wouldn't it replace authors.  musicians.   the deeply personal bit that attends all of our favorite works.  divorce.  being single.  raising kids single.  holidays.  growing older.  career angst.  all of those things that richard ford captures so beautifully that so many relate to AI could mimic in it's arm's length sterile way thereby depriving humanity of that connection.  knowing that another human thinks what you think and has this gift to be able to express and share it.  

i hate ai already

I think it will bleed everywhere, but I think there is something inherent about the AI revolution that might slow things down: namely that it will be easier to replace the elites than the drones.

Think about your local Hooters (if Hooters even still exists; I'm not sure): AI can already do the job of the regional manager, upper level executives, probably even the CEO. But AI is nowhere close to replacing the Hooters waitress. AI can't wear a tiny tight outfit and flirt tableside with the guests. The day is coming, I'm sure, but it will be easier to replace the brains than it will be to replace the low-level front lines folks (and probably more cost-effective, too).

Well, history tells us when it's the other way around, when it's cost-effective to replace the lower level workers, it happens very quickly. But when it's the elites who are staring straight into obsolescence, I bet they come up with artificial barriers to the implementation of AI really quickly.

I joked above that AI can probably already do Congress' job, but replacing governing officials will be the last thing AI does simply because the governing officials have the political power to prevent it from happening. But now I think I accidentally hit upon some truth with that joke.

 

It's going to--already is, actually--hollow out starter jobs for paper pushers and middle management. Elites will be using the AI to do this.  I see it as increasing the income/wealth gap tremendously.  

 

I agree. @mcm666 hit on it with his ownership thing. Once the singularity hits, our positions in society will be set in stone: owners and non-owners. And the gap between them will only widen. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 11:10 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

I agree. @mcm666 hit on it with his ownership thing. Once the singularity hits, our positions in society will be set in stone: owners and non-owners. And the gap between them will only widen. 

Probably time to sell my bitcoin and buy lottery tickets. Don't tell snarl.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 11:20 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@bradstevens @goat @mcm666 

Maybe it’s a generational thing, but I just don’t see AI doing all the stuff you see.

Its heavy reliance on past stored data is a handicap.  Its limited ability to consider extrinsic factors is a huge handicap when making decisions.  Its ability to plan for the future in any thing but a sequential manner is a big handicap.  It has no ability to organize, plan, manage or motivate people to achieve things. It has very little ability to create meaningful new ideas or concepts, or project current ideas forward in a non- linear fashion.  And its power requirements are ginormous. AI never really learns.  It will use the same amount of power to do a task one time, or each of one million times.  Humans can perform repeated learned tasks without thinking about it.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 12:24 am
NPT's avatar
 NPT
(@npt)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @mcm666
↑

@co-hoosier what’s strange is that it gets parts of answers wrong.  It also seems vulnerable to leading questions

Yeah it gets stuff wrong.... I use CoPilot some and it gets stuff wrong and I'll reply "That's not correct" and it will give anoother more correct answer.

 


There are 10 types of people in this world, those who know binary and those who don't.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 5:49 am
👍
1
NPT's avatar
 NPT
(@npt)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @mcm666
↑

we’re effectively a country of unemployed people living off of guaranteed basic income

Where does the money come to pay a guaranteed basic income if no one is working and paying taxes?


There are 10 types of people in this world, those who know binary and those who don't.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 6:24 am
NPT's avatar
 NPT
(@npt)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @unclemark
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

If we have enough to live and consume books and ideas and time to spend with people connecting, sharing, and loving, what more do we need? I’ll accept that lot gladly. 

That's where I'm at. All my needs and most of my wants. Of course, my wants have been tempered over the years to the point where they differ little from my needs.

That's kinda funny.  When I was a lot younger and didn't have much mioney I wanted a lot of things but now that I'm a lot older and can afford about anything I wanted back then I don't want many things.  I'd rather spend money creating good memories like a vacation that was really memorialble.

 


There are 10 types of people in this world, those who know binary and those who don't.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 6:35 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@bradstevens @goat  

Maybe it’s a generational thing, but I just don’t see AI doing all the stuff you see.

Its heavy reliance on past stored data is a handicap.  Its limited ability to consider extrinsic factors is a huge handicap when making decisions.  Its ability to plan for the future in any thing but a sequential manner is a big handicap.  It has no ability to organize, plan, manage or motivate people to achieve things. It has very little ability to create meaningful new ideas or concepts, or project current ideas forward in a non- linear fashion.  And its power requirements are ginormous. AI never really learns.  It will use the same amount of power to do a task one time, or each of one million times.  Humans can perform repeated learned tasks without thinking about it.  

In short, AI has no inherent life or creative force, no inherent causation and no inherent ability.

It doesn’t create knowledge, it collects it. It doesn’t think, it doesn’t imagine, it has no conceptual understanding, it has no awareness or consciousness.

It has nothing that makes us human. It’s a souped-up hunk of ropey lava.

It may be best likened to a concatenation of programmed effects. Dominoes requiring a human finger. Its complexity is entirely a consequence of human imagination and creativity.

It’s not the AIs you fear, it’s the geniuses who create it. 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/10/2025 6:50 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@bradstevens @goat @mcm666 

Maybe it’s a generational thing, but I just don’t see AI doing all the stuff you see.

Its heavy reliance on past stored data is a handicap.  Its limited ability to consider extrinsic factors is a huge handicap when making decisions.  Its ability to plan for the future in any thing but a sequential manner is a big handicap.  It has no ability to organize, plan, manage or motivate people to achieve things. It has very little ability to create meaningful new ideas or concepts, or project current ideas forward in a non- linear fashion.  And its power requirements are ginormous. AI never really learns.  It will use the same amount of power to do a task one time, or each of one million times.  Humans can perform repeated learned tasks without thinking about it.  

I think your best argument is the energy requirement part. 

But on theoretical possibilities, I don't think you have a very strong grasp on how thinking, thought formation, etc. work in the human brain. I'm guessing that's because you think humans are some sui generis form of life in the universe and that our thinking comes from some supernatural source.

Current LLMs can't do some of the things you list. But we who are worried are looking past that, to what this will evolve into.  LLMs currently learn (it's called machine learning, look it up), it already creates new things--remember the songs and poems in iambic pentameter it wrote just from a suggestion?  And I disagree that it can't "motivate" people--it can do that now. 

But even if LLMs can't advance to become general AIs, they are still going to--and already are--disrupt the labor force in a dramatic way.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 7:02 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@hhlurker 

I don’t fear the geniuses who create AI.  We should all fear the rubes who will certainly misuse it.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/10/2025 7:43 am
Page 13 / 18
Share: