Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

ChatGPT-5: Manhatta...
 
Notifications
Clear all

ChatGPT-5: Manhattan Project 2.0

Page 10 / 18
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

They are by definition not the same thing.

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Correct

Begging the question.  

Supernatural is defined as stuff beyond scientific knowledge.  Scientific knowledge is not a constant.  It evolves.  

Supernatural:

(of a manifestation or event) attributed to some force beyond scientific understanding or the laws of nature.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 8:57 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Someone who thinks the natural realm is all there is and that all phenomena are explainable via natural laws and denies anything outside that—like magic, gods, hell, heaven, Easter bunnies, Santa Claus, etc. 

Don’t insult me with arguments about Easter bunnies.  There is a difference between the results  of human imagination and phenomena that defy laws of science.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 9:05 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

They are by definition not the same thing.

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Correct

Begging the question.  

Supernatural is defined as stuff beyond scientific knowledge.  Scientific knowledge is not a constant.  It evolves.  

Supernatural:

(of a manifestation or event) attributed to some force beyond scientific understanding or the laws of nature.

 

Using definitions is not the logical fallacy of begging the question.

You forgot to mention what's on the other side of the "or" conjunction.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 9:09 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Someone who thinks the natural realm is all there is and that all phenomena are explainable via natural laws and denies anything outside that—like magic, gods, hell, heaven, Easter bunnies, Santa Claus, etc. 

Don’t insult me with arguments about Easter bunnies.  There is a difference between the results  of human imagination and phenomena that defy laws of science.  

Please try to leave emotion out of a philosophical discussion.  

For a naturalist, there are no real phenomena that defy natural laws. To make that claim, you have to be a supernaturalist.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 9:11 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@bradstevens 

No.  What I said goes for both sides of the”or”.  The field of quantum physics is an example.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 9:42 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

For a naturalist, there are no real phenomena that defy natural laws.

unidentified anomalous phenomena 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 9:47 am
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

For a naturalist, there are no real phenomena that defy natural laws.

unidentified anomalous phenomena 

 

 

A naturalist would say they only appear anomalous, but that they still follow natural laws; we just don't have the information necessary to describe how.

A supernaturalist would say that it is at least possible the phenomena exist outside natural laws, and do not necessarily follow them.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 10:57 am
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@bradstevens 

No.  What I said goes for both sides of the”or”.  The field of quantum physics is an example.  

You didn't mention it. That's a fact. You can say it wouldn't matter, but you can't say you did something you did not:

"Supernatural is defined as stuff beyond scientific knowledge."

As you recognized, human knowledge of science evolves. As you would admit, human's ability to understand is limited. Thus, UAPs and mysterious quantum phenomena.  So a naturalist would admit that there might be phenomena currently outside our "scientific knowledge," but would not admit that those phenomena could ever be outside the realm of natural laws.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 11:15 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@bradstevens 

I posted the definition you claim I ignore.  

I think we essentially say the same thing.  Neither of us are talking about the Easter bunny.  I think the difference is that phenomenon that are not made up, but are dismissed because they violate natural law might not violate natural law. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 11:25 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 12:24 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

The first one is not the definition of a supernaturalist. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 12:28 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

There is a difference between the results  of human imagination and phenomena that defy laws of science.  

For a naturalist, there are no real phenomena that defy natural laws. To make that claim, you have to be a supernaturalist.
Psychologists deny the existence of a “human mind” distinct from the brain. The primary (and only) “evidence” that our mind is our brain is that human “awareness” is “located” in the brain. 

Psychologists or any other scientists have no empirical means for locating, identifying or measuring human “awareness” despite the “fact” we all “know” it’s right there in back of our forehead. Likewise, we all know that our mind is also in the same “place” as our awareness. Curiously, that location of our awareness is more pinpointed than spreading out across the entire brain matter. At least that’s our empirical experience of it. Even a hard-core naturalist ought to wonder why the awareness doesn’t encompass the entire brain.

Then there’s the matter of memory. Psychologists and other scientists have their theories about where memory is, but once again, absolutely no means whatsoever to establish the location of any memory.

Likewise with thought.

Then there’s the fascinating subject of imagery. Here we have empirical experiences that are observed by individuals, but wholly unexplained by psychologists or other scientists. Since the late 40s when cognitive psychologists broke from behavioralists, one of the  foundational arguments of their break was images in their mind/brain that they “knew” existed from personal experience. Then and now these purported images have never been measured or identified using physical devices. And yet, most astonishing of all, a subject routinely reports not only being able to create and observe the image of a black cat inside their head but also move said image left and right, forward and back, up and down and around the interior of their head.

Damn supernaturalists!

 

 

  

 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 12:57 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

The first one is not the definition of a supernaturalist. 

 

If not, then what were you attempting to dispute with CoH? he was clearly using the first definition. 

I Dont Know


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 1:08 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@bradstevens 

I posted the definition you claim I ignore.  

I think we essentially say the same thing.  Neither of us are talking about the Easter bunny.  I think the difference is that phenomenon that are not made up, but are dismissed because they violate natural law might not violate natural law. 

 

To the naturalist, God=Easter Bunny in ontological terms.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 1:13 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Speaking of AI deskilling people:

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 1:16 pm
👍
1
Page 10 / 18
Share: