O Brother is loosely based in Odysseus.Did you care when the Cohen brothers made O Brother, where art thou?I thought it was a good movie and enjoyed it. To enjoy it, it does require you not to get hung up on the accuracy of how fictional characters are portrayed though.
The purpose of historical context matters in historical movies. I wouldn't want to watch Zulu with the Asians fighting Latinos. I wouldn't want to watch a movie about the Revolutionary War with Shermans and Mark VIs battling it out.
Never got into it and gave up a few times. What is the context?
Nolans work seems to be a bit more on the nose and not an homage.
@larsiu similarly, West Side Story is Romeo and Juliet. I suspect we will soon have arguments about that.
If we want realism, Odysseus would have been played by a Greek who believes in Zeus. Yet no one complains about the religious slight against Hellenism, which is still practiced today.
O Brother is loosely based in Odysseus.Did you care when the Cohen brothers made O Brother, where art thou?I thought it was a good movie and enjoyed it. To enjoy it, it does require you not to get hung up on the accuracy of how fictional characters are portrayed though.
The purpose of historical context matters in historical movies. I wouldn't want to watch Zulu with the Asians fighting Latinos. I wouldn't want to watch a movie about the Revolutionary War with Shermans and Mark VIs battling it out.
Never got into it and gave up a few times. What is the context?
Nolans work seems to be a bit more on the nose and not an homage.
One of the better soundtracks for a film.
I’m a sucker for Nolan’s films.
he's amazing.
Nolan Ryan? Like soccer, I'd struggle to name 10 actors. Let alone a director or producer or whatever he is. You know what I can do? Name 10 baseball players. For example Jackie Chan was at the White House recently for winning the World Series. Have yourself a day.
https://twitter.com/whitehouse/status/2080428593704800345?s=46
@snarlcakes i wouldn't either but after interstellar and oppenheimer i became aware. he has a style. there's a uniquely recognizable quality to what he does so that when you see it you immediately know it. no others are like him. the pace. how he weds the music so perfectly to the rising drama. it reminds me of la masia de can planes where when a kid comes out of the academy, an iniesta, a xavi hernandez, and busquets and so many of the current crop of professionals began their pro careers as little as 8 years old. you have to be inculcated by professionals at a tender age to do what they do.
it's hard for you to understand. being a baseball fan where kids from rural america play for the their local terrible high school then become pros. how can i explain it. oppenheimer is to the hawk with will ferrell as soccer is to baseball grasshopper
@bar-down the notion that you can identify a world class talent at 8 years old is an absurdity. It goes to show anyone can be a world class soccer player with the proper training.
A lot of the best basketball and baseball players I knew as a 12 year old, didn’t even make the High School team. The soccer players did though.
Meanwhile a truly great high school baseball player still has at least 5+ years of toiling away in college/ minors against grown ass men on the off chance he might make it up to the bigs for a cup of coffee.
No contest.
@carramrod first if they played high school they were already weeded out. the great players come from europe and south america. it's really no contest. with baseball youre dealing with a group of whites who couldn't make the football team from a tiny pool of athletes in a small part of the country vs the desire of every kid in the world to play for barcelona. it's why places like the dominican so quickly replace american baseball players. there's just not much to compete against. just a couple hundred thousand rednecks really. blacks don't care about baseball. whites are playing everything else
Kunte Kinte was real. Helen is not. Greece had made connections with African empires. It isn't like she was portrayed as an American, though that would have had less pushback.
You made some great points here. This idea of making an 'historically accurate' movie based on a 2700 year old mythological poem is silly. It's almost like arguing about the comic book accuracy of Superman's costume or the Hulk not being green enough.
And it's a movie. No one is mandated to go watch it. I honestly don't know why people are so threatened by it.
@bar-down have to take your word for it. I haven't see either movie and didn't even know one of them existed.
Nolan Ryan? Like soccer, I'd struggle to name 10 actors. Let alone a director or producer or whatever he is. You know what I can do? Name 10 baseball players. For example Jackie Chan was at the White House recently for winning the World Series. Have yourself a day.
If we're going to argue about appearances or how people and things should or shouldn't be publicly presented, I think we can all agree the Oval Office - and the White House in general - is currently tacky AF. Regardless of who wins the White House in '28, I hope some couth, class, common sense and decency is restored to the place.
I don't think about it often, but everytime I see a current photo or video clip from inside the Oval Office I get a little bit embarrassed.



