Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Does the Constituti...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Does the Constitution require birth right citizenship?

Page 9 / 21
Mark Milton
(@mark-milton)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

What about the hypocrisy of the Democrat appointed judges becoming strict textualists in this case? 

There's no hypocrisy. The judges took a textualist approach because the controversy was a purely textual one. If the Government had argued legislative intent, and the judges had said, "No, we don't do that around these parts," then you would have a point, but that didn't happen. Both parties argued for their interpretation of the text, so the various rulings were based on interpreting the text.

Perhaps you meant something else when you said "textualist."

Carramrod isn't smart enough to know what a stict textualist means.  Everyone on the Supreme Court is a strict textualist when the words are so clear that there is no wiggle room.  Only by becoming what they hate the most, a proponent of the living constitution or loose constructionist, do you arrive at another conclusion other than the clear language of the 14th amendment- "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."  

 


This post was modified 8 months ago by Mark Milton

Shoving carrramrod into a locker since 2024.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 3:59 am
👍
1
HurryingHoosiers
(@hurryinghoosiers)
Noble Member

Posted by: @oneeyedundertaker
↑

https://twitter.com/jackunheard/status/2039450860506288205?s=61&t=1KiTJ7EYgX-uQgf4Wkb9sg

Our country has become a literal breeding ground for scammers…thanks Dems.

And those scammers are smarter and less dangerous to our country than immoral MAGAts

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 6:59 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@mark-milton 

What would a strict textualist say about “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof” means?  

Most  people argue that any person in the U.S. must be subject to the jurisdiction and the clause only covers diplomats with immunity.  Babies are not diplomats with immunity. I think this argument is hogwash.  Any textualist knows this part of the 14th was about Dredd Scott.  Taney had a lot to say about jurisdiction when he ruled that slaves we’re property and not people and courts and Congress had no jurisdiction to say otherwise. This was the law of the land when the 14th was drafted and ratified.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 7:43 am
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

@co-hoosier the US from founding has been jus soli, at least for Whites. You think they intended to overturn that? 

The writers knew how to write the words "former slaves" and they chose not to. They knew how to write "Negroes", and chose not to. 

The wording sure sounds identical to what you would write to codify jus soli. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 8:10 am
👍
1
Mark Milton
(@mark-milton)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@mark-milton 

What would a strict textualist say about “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof” means?  

Most  people argue that any person in the U.S. must be subject to the jurisdiction and the clause only covers diplomats with immunity.  Babies are not diplomats with immunity. I think this argument is hogwash.  Any textualist knows this part of the 14th was about Dredd Scott.  Taney had a lot to say about jurisdiction when he ruled that slaves we’re property and not people and courts and Congress had no jurisdiction to say otherwise. This was the law of the land when the 14th was drafted and ratified.  

 

The problem with your position is that isn't supported by any facts.  Senator Howard, who introduced the Fourteenth Amendment and defend it, wrote: 

"This amendment which I have offered, is simply declaratory of what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons.:

The first sentence is exactly what the law at the time of the 14th Amendment, an affirmation of the old English common law rule of jus soli that the United States inherited from England.  The second sentence describes the families of ambassadors as being foreigners and aliens--not three distinct groups of people who were not under the jurisdiction of the US government, namely, ambassadors and their US born children.  That was true then and true now and is the only "person" in the United States that the United States has no jurisdiction over.  All of this available to read online. 

Even before the Civil War, American courts affirmed the jus soli inheritance.  For example, the 1824 Supreme Court case of M'Creery's Lessee v Somerville where the court proceeded on the assumption that three girls born in the United States were citizens even though their father was an Irish citizen who never naturalized.  In 1844 in Lynch v Clarke, a NY court held that a young girl born to Irish sojourners in New York was a US citizen.  The court made the following quote which by no coincidence, is awful similar to the language in 14th Amendment: "I can entertain no doubt, but that by the law of the United States, every person born within the dominions and allegiance of the United States, whatever were the situation of his parents, is a natural born citizen".

You bring up Dred Scott a lot here, but that was already dealt with in the Civil Rights Act of 1865 that stated "That all persons born in the United States and not subject to any foreign power, excluding Indians not taxed, are hereby declared to be citizens of the United States; and such citizens, of every race and color"

 


Shoving carrramrod into a locker since 2024.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 8:13 am
👍
3
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@mark-milton @arthur-dent 

”This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, . . . .” 

This is why I think birth tourism and offspring of illegals are different. I also think this would be consistent with Ark.

I don’t have a quarrel with jus soli.  However, I think it was a way to encourage immigration.  Birth tourism is not immigration.  And illegal immigration would not be immigration under the law either.  

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 8:43 am
Mark Milton
(@mark-milton)
Estimable Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@mark-milton @arthur-dent 

”This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, . . . .” 

 

This is why I think birth tourism and offspring of illegals are different. I also think this would be consistent with Ark.

I don’t have a quarrel with jus soli.  However, I think it was a way to encourage immigration.  Birth tourism is not immigration.  And illegal immigration would not be immigration under the law either.  

 

 

You've basically added an "and" in that sentence when it didn't exist --the language was self-limiting to "This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States".  In other words, the 14th amendment didn't apply to foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors. You've implied an "and" after "foreigners, aliens [AND] ambassadors"

There is a statute already prohibiting people from coming to the US to give birth.  

 


Shoving carrramrod into a locker since 2024.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 8:54 am
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

I love how Birth Tourism is the newest biggest threat to all we hold dear. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 8:55 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @mark-milton
↑

There is a statute already prohibiting people from coming to the US to give birth.  

The kid is still a citizen.  Right? 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 9:16 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@unclemark 

Regardless, Birth tourism should be an easy non- controversial carve out from the 14t’s Constitutional protection of birth right citizenship. I don’t understand why the democrats oppose it.  As MM noted, it’s already against the law.   Offspring of illegals would be a little more difficult.  

https://www.fosterglobal.com/blog/born-in-the-usa-why-chinese-birth-tourism-is-booming-in-california/


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 9:28 am
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

Regardless, Birth tourism should be an easy non- controversial carve out from the 14t’s Constitutional protection of birth right citizenship. I don’t understand why the democrats oppose it.  As MM noted, it’s already against the law.   Offspring of illegals would be a little more difficult.  

So you want the court to carve out an exception for tourism? How have these carve-outs been treated on the 2nd?

I have an idea on how we can solve all these problems. Let's write a Constitutional Amendment on exactly how courts should interpret cases involving the Amendments. Be it plain text reading, be it Scalia's how the people at the time interpreted it, be it a living document interpreted in light of today. Let's apply it across the board. 

Honestly, I am a living document person. So if the court decides to carve out tourism, I don't have a real objection. I object that many of the same people who say the 2nd must be interpreted in plain language or according to Scalia now want a living document, but only in this case. Forget that, letting that group decide where the battle is being fought just isn't going to cut it. If I have to put up with Scalia on 2A, they have to on this. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 10:04 am
OneEyedUndertaker
(@oneeyedundertaker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @unclemark
↑

I love how Birth Tourism is the newest biggest threat to all we hold dear. 

 

How could someone who has nothing to hold dear possible understand?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 11:38 am
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @mark-milton
↑

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@mark-milton @arthur-dent 

”This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, . . . .” 

 

This is why I think birth tourism and offspring of illegals are different. I also think this would be consistent with Ark.

I don’t have a quarrel with jus soli.  However, I think it was a way to encourage immigration.  Birth tourism is not immigration.  And illegal immigration would not be immigration under the law either.  

 

 

You've basically added an "and" in that sentence when it didn't exist --the language was self-limiting to "This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States".  In other words, the 14th amendment didn't apply to foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors. You've implied an "and" after "foreigners, aliens [AND] ambassadors"

There is a statute already prohibiting people from coming to the US to give birth.  

 

He's also arguing legislative intent, rather than the text.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 2:12 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@goat 

More than that. In what state will a tourist “reside”?  The concept of residence is deeply intertwined in birth right citizens. Ark reinforces this. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/06/2026 2:35 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @mark-milton
↑

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@mark-milton @arthur-dent 

”This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, . . . .” 

 

This is why I think birth tourism and offspring of illegals are different. I also think this would be consistent with Ark.

I don’t have a quarrel with jus soli.  However, I think it was a way to encourage immigration.  Birth tourism is not immigration.  And illegal immigration would not be immigration under the law either.  

 

 

You've basically added an "and" in that sentence when it didn't exist --the language was self-limiting to "This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States".  In other words, the 14th amendment didn't apply to foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors. You've implied an "and" after "foreigners, aliens [AND] ambassadors"

There is a statute already prohibiting people from coming to the US to give birth.  

 

I think the status quo has the winning argument, but re your citations, the introducing senator's words are interesting, but not conclusive.  It's one person's interpretation of the language who voted for it. His interpretation might be a brick of evidence towards the public meaning at the time, but not dispositive. Your quote of a case that includes allegiance might cut against birthright citizenship.  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 04/06/2026 8:38 pm
Page 9 / 21
Share: