Without reviewing the entire thread, I’m pretty sure I said the SCOTUS would rule unanimously against the President’s EO. It appears the SCOTUS will strike down the EO but Thomas might dissent. I actually oppose birthright citizenship but also think (soon to be know) that it can’t be changed by Presidential decree.
Alito will join Thomas. Those two are barking mad.
Yesterday, in responding to a comment by Sauer about how the world is changing and all these Chinese "birth tourists" are going to exploit birthright citizenship, Roberts remarked, "New world, same constitution." Alito has always subscribed to that thinking too - - until yesterday. Here's Alito:
"What we are dealing with is something that was basically unknown at the time when the 14th amendment was adopted, which is illegal immigration."
Imagine if someone made a similar argument before Alito about the Second Amendment - - that the founders never could have anticipated "arms" would encompass the killing machines that are available today? The argument would go over like a lead balloon.
https://twitter.com/collinsfortx/status/2039380118221586574?s=46&t=Csl_r88muvNMBV79b5VS-Q
It’s right in front of us yet some refuse to see it…Omar, Tlaib, it’s only gonna get worse.
It’s right in front of us yet some refuse to see it…Omar, Tlaib, it’s only gonna get worse.
The problem is, if you go scorched earth on this one, you are taking out a good chunk of Republicans too.
Cruz, Rubio, Moreno, Patel, Haley,etc. Lots of members of the Republican caucus are children of immigrants who weren't naturalized until after their birth.
It’s right in front of us yet some refuse to see it…Omar, Tlaib, it’s only gonna get worse.
The problem is, if you go scorched earth on this one, you are taking out a good chunk of Republicans too.
Cruz, Rubio, Moreno, Patel, Haley,etc. Lots of members of the Republican caucus are children of immigrants who weren't naturalized until after their birth.
As long as they meet the qualifications, minor children become citizens when their parents are naturalized.
I have no idea if that applies to all or some of the people mentioned.
Hope is not optimism, which expects things to turn out well, but something rooted in the conviction that there is good worth working for. - Seamus Heaney, Irish poet and likely Hoosier basketball fan.
POTFB
I think Alito's view will lose in this case, but re your "imagine" statement, we don't have to--those arguments were made and they affected the outcome. The response is that the Heller decision (which applies to arms bans) does not encompass all weapons "that are available today," it explicitly limits 2A protection to arms "in common use" for personal defense.Without reviewing the entire thread, I’m pretty sure I said the SCOTUS would rule unanimously against the President’s EO. It appears the SCOTUS will strike down the EO but Thomas might dissent. I actually oppose birthright citizenship but also think (soon to be know) that it can’t be changed by Presidential decree.
Alito will join Thomas. Those two are barking mad.
Yesterday, in responding to a comment by Sauer about how the world is changing and all these Chinese "birth tourists" are going to exploit birthright citizenship, Roberts remarked, "New world, same constitution." Alito has always subscribed to that thinking too - - until yesterday. Here's Alito:
"What we are dealing with is something that was basically unknown at the time when the 14th amendment was adopted, which is illegal immigration."Imagine if someone made a similar argument before Alito about the Second Amendment - - that the founders never could have anticipated "arms" would encompass the killing machines that are available today? The argument would go over like a lead balloon.
One thing for sure, a lot more people have heard about United States v. Wong Kim Ark!
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/169/649/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Wong_Kim_Ark
"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451
U.S. vs. ArkOne thing for sure, a lot more people have heard about United States v. Wong Kim Ark!
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/169/649/
Sounds biblical. Hard to lose that case.
https://twitter.com/jackunheard/status/2039450860506288205?s=61&t=1KiTJ7EYgX-uQgf4Wkb9sg
Our country has become a literal breeding ground for scammers…thanks Dems.
Now we know where @larsiu has been going on weekends.https://twitter.com/jackunheard/status/2039450860506288205?s=61&t=1KiTJ7EYgX-uQgf4Wkb9sg
Our country has become a literal breeding ground for scammers…thanks Dems.
Now we know where @larsiu has been going on weekends.https://twitter.com/jackunheard/status/2039450860506288205?s=61&t=1KiTJ7EYgX-uQgf4Wkb9sg
Our country has become a literal breeding ground for scammers…thanks Dems.

Without reviewing the entire thread, I’m pretty sure I said the SCOTUS would rule unanimously against the President’s EO. It appears the SCOTUS will strike down the EO but Thomas might dissent. I actually oppose birthright citizenship but also think (soon to be know) that it can’t be changed by Presidential decree.
Alito will join Thomas. Those two are barking mad.
Yesterday, in responding to a comment by Sauer about how the world is changing and all these Chinese "birth tourists" are going to exploit birthright citizenship, Roberts remarked, "New world, same constitution." Alito has always subscribed to that thinking too - - until yesterday. Here's Alito:
"What we are dealing with is something that was basically unknown at the time when the 14th amendment was adopted, which is illegal immigration."Imagine if someone made a similar argument before Alito about the Second Amendment - - that the founders never could have anticipated "arms" would encompass the killing machines that are available today? The argument would go over like a lead balloon.
That’s not a proper representation of Alito’s argument. It’s completely distorted.
"Justice Scalia had an example that dealt with this situation," Alito said. "He imagined an old theft statute that was enacted well before anybody conceived of a microwave oven. And then, afterwards, someone is charged with the crime of stealing a microwave oven. And this fellow says, 'Well, I can't be convicted under this because the microwave oven didn't exist at that time.' And he dismissed that. There's a general rule there, and you apply it to future applications."
What about the hypocrisy of the Democrat appointed judges becoming strict textualists in this case?
Tomorrow they’ll go back to reading gay marriage, abortion and whatever other rights they please into the constitution.
Any hate for their hypocrisy?
If you are expecting LAWYERS to not be hypocrites, taking whatever angle suits them for one case and then taking the opposite the next, then good luck with that.
"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451
What about the hypocrisy of the Democrat appointed judges becoming strict textualists in this case?
There's no hypocrisy. The judges took a textualist approach because the controversy was a purely textual one. If the Government had argued legislative intent, and the judges had said, "No, we don't do that around these parts," then you would have a point, but that didn't happen. Both parties argued for their interpretation of the text, so the various rulings were based on interpreting the text.
Perhaps you meant something else when you said "textualist."
What about the hypocrisy of the Democrat appointed judges becoming strict textualists in this case?
There's no hypocrisy. The judges took a textualist approach because the controversy was a purely textual one. If the Government had argued legislative intent, and the judges had said, "No, we don't do that around these parts," then you would have a point, but that didn't happen. Both parties argued for their interpretation of the text, so the various rulings were based on interpreting the text.
Perhaps you meant something else when you said "textualist."
Can't wait for COH to come by and tell you how wrong you are.
This is easy. The 14Th language in question was a civil rights statement intended to overrule Dredd Scott, the worst decision ever.
It isn’t an immigration statement, but SCOTUS in Ark made an immigration issue. The Ark facts are specific. Taking Ark into birth tourism and illegal offspring is an administrative process, not judicial. There is no public policy driving birth tourism and offspring of illegals being citizens. The court should end that but it won’t.

