It's much simpler than that. Ohio State 31 Iowa 14. And it wasn't that close.And almost as head scratching as South Cackalacky still being ranked after their Pig Sooie embarrassment is how does Ohio State move up 6 spots after beating Northwestern without Aiden Chiles? And in comfortable, but not dominating fashion.
If they're getting that much credit for beating NU without him, why didn't we see a bump based on beating them when he was playing?
This is pretty easy to understand though when you think about it from the committee perspective.
Who do they think will draw more eyes, Ohio State or Iowa, on a national stage? They had to move Ohio State in front of Iowa because if they both win out, they want Ohio State and that fan base playing instead of Iowa.
They're not even hiding their disdain for the non big name teams.
ND was left out last year. They'd have garnered huge ratings.
In 2024, Bama was left out in favor of SMU.
Let's not get so carried away with the conspiracy stuff.
Herbstreit actually pretended to have no idea where teams were ranked on the McAfee show today. Like legit asked where Bama was ranked, and where Tennessee was ranked. I can't...
Mr ESPN College Football, has no idea where Alabama is ranked. Its getting pretty deep...
In a desperate attempt to make the CFP field, Iowa is rolling out new uniforms.
Hope is not optimism, which expects things to turn out well, but something rooted in the conviction that there is good worth working for. - Seamus Heaney, Irish poet and likely Hoosier basketball fan.
POTFB
@kkott Another example of SEleCtive applications of factors... Alabama has beaten a few teams that were ranked, when they played them, but that have since fallen off and aren't ranked any more. Sound familiar? Its astounding how blatantly bias this year's rankings have been, and how awful the overall process now is.
I typed in to chat GPT just now... "taking all factors in, all stats, all analytics, who's healthy on every team, rank the top 12 teams in college football". Here's what it gave me, with small explanations after each team...
1. Georgia... Most complete team
2. Notre Dame... Elite overall talent and efficiency
3. Utah... Undefeated, extremely dangerous
4. Miami... Explosive offense, championship ceiling
5. Indiana... Elite defensive performance
6. Texas... Excellent defense and big game ability
7. Alabama... High end talent, but some concerns
8. UCLA... Undefeated, deserves significant respect
9. Wake Forest... One of the most impressive recent performances
10. Tennessee... very strong efficiency numbers
11. Texas Tech... Dangerous offense, defensive questions
12. BYU... consistent, balanced team
5 seconds... markedly better rankings, and reasonings for the rankings, than what the committee is putting out. Bring back the computer rankings.
That's a damn good list. Only thing I'd be serious about changing is putting TN 9 and Wake 10.
@gros-louis thats not the reason given for Ohio State jumping 6 spots after beating Northwestern, without Chiles, by 11.
It was stated that they went in front of Iowa because they lost to Texas early in the season and Iowa didn't have a tough non-con game.
Iowa doesn't get credit for playing Iowa State, who last I checked was a P4 opponent.
I mean, not all P4 opponents are the same. I wouldn't argue that playing Iowa State and Texas are the same thing at all.@gros-louis thats not the reason given for Ohio State jumping 6 spots after beating Northwestern, without Chiles, by 11.
It was stated that they went in front of Iowa because they lost to Texas early in the season and Iowa didn't have a tough non-con game.
Iowa doesn't get credit for playing Iowa State, who last I checked was a P4 opponent.
Georgia Tech vs Iowa State? Last year Georgia seemed to get credit for squeaking by a weak GT 16 to 9 . Because 'It's a rivalry game!' . I doubt Iowa ever gets much credit for winning the rivalry game, only demerits if they lose. Double standard.I mean, not all P4 opponents are the same. I wouldn't argue that playing Iowa State and Texas are the same thing at all.
Yeah, Texas is a much tougher opponent. But the committee has noted quite a bit how teams are playing now. Ohio State has only won one game in their last three! A Northwestern without their QB and at Ohio State.
Iowa shut out Wisconsin and beat them by more than Notre Dame did. And have only lost to Ohio State with Sayen, and a 13-10 loss at Minnesota. But the committee doesn't want the Iowa fanbase, they want flashier eyeball drawing Oregon or OSU. Of course Iowa had a miracle to beat Michigan who controlled that game. So, I don't necessarily think they should be in. But by committee standards they don't get the credit for that they have done.
@gros-louis by that logic, we should schedule Georgia, Bama and LSU. If we lose by a point to each team, that's way better than beating a Iowa State or Georgia Tech.
Close losses to P4 powers have have now become better then winning against lower P4 schools.
What are we doing here?
Overheard in the committee room...
"I know what to do, guys. Let's rank 4-loss South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida, and Ole Miss to make the SEC look great."
"But SC just got bitch-slapped by Arkansas."
"Then let's rank the Razorbacks as well."
@gros-louis by that logic, we should schedule Georgia, Bama and LSU. If we lose by a point to each team, that's way better than beating a Iowa State or Georgia Tech.
Close losses to P4 powers have have now become better then winning against lower P4 schools.
What are we doing here?
Losses to SEC teams don't need to be close. They routinely are getting blown out by 2-3 touchdowns and its a quality loss that doesn't affect their resume at all.
Didnt OSU beat Iowa?And almost as head scratching as South Cackalacky still being ranked after their Pig Sooie embarrassment is how does Ohio State move up 6 spots after beating Northwestern without Aiden Chiles? And in comfortable, but not dominating fashion.
If they're getting that much credit for beating NU without him, why didn't we see a bump based on beating them when he was playing?
This is pretty easy to understand though when you think about it from the committee perspective.
Who do they think will draw more eyes, Ohio State or Iowa, on a national stage? They had to move Ohio State in front of Iowa because if they both win out, they want Ohio State and that fan base playing instead of Iowa.
They're not even hiding their disdain for the non big name teams.
Even that isn't really the case, unless you go back to when Fox gave up their BCS games in 2008 and ESPN has had first-right of refusal windows ever since.Not true. The expanded playoff never went up for bid because ESPN had an exclusive window to negotiate an expanded format and took it.They/Fox had the chance to outbid ESPN for the rights to the CFP but didn't.
I'm talking originally.

