Honest question, you don't think Ohio State deserves credit for playing Texas and losing a close game? You think us beating Kennesaw St or North Texas should carry more weight than that? I don't.@gros-louis by that logic, we should schedule Georgia, Bama and LSU. If we lose by a point to each team, that's way better than beating a Iowa State or Georgia Tech.
Close losses to P4 powers have have now become better then winning against lower P4 schools.
What are we doing here?
I think beating North Texas should carry the weight that it deserves, which this year, is a decent win. A win better than UGA's win over Georgia Tech will be. There should have been more sane people recognizing that beating ODU and Kennesaw last year was better than some P4 wins.
But I'm not sure losing a close game to a P4 top 10 team should ding a team that much.
In terms of judging how good a team is—its ability to win a title in the playoff—yeah, I think that actually makes sense.@gros-louis by that logic, we should schedule Georgia, Bama and LSU. If we lose by a point to each team, that's way better than beating a Iowa State or Georgia Tech.
Close losses to P4 powers have have now become better then winning against lower P4 schools.
What are we doing here?
IU’s best data point on the year is the Marsh foot away from beating a full strength OSU. It is not beating Minny, Michigan, or Rutgers this year.
Now, whether or not what I listed as what might be judged is the correct criteria is obviously up for debate.
Didnt OSU beat Iowa?And almost as head scratching as South Cackalacky still being ranked after their Pig Sooie embarrassment is how does Ohio State move up 6 spots after beating Northwestern without Aiden Chiles? And in comfortable, but not dominating fashion.
If they're getting that much credit for beating NU without him, why didn't we see a bump based on beating them when he was playing?
This is pretty easy to understand though when you think about it from the committee perspective.
Who do they think will draw more eyes, Ohio State or Iowa, on a national stage? They had to move Ohio State in front of Iowa because if they both win out, they want Ohio State and that fan base playing instead of Iowa.
They're not even hiding their disdain for the non big name teams.
With Sayin. They are not the same team now
@boogiebradstevens - For me it's the odd precedent they are now setting. Yes, a 1 loss difference could impact rankings if someone had a stunningly good win or bad loss, but the record was the most important factor for the history of college football. Suddenly, it's not that. The highest 2 loss team through week 12 was #6 LSU in 2022. They were coming off back-to-back wins over then currently ranked #7 and #6 teams. We now have 2 in the top 5, and one of them is over an undefeated B1G team. It's the changing of criteria in a way that is so abnormally in favor of the teams in one conference for no reason other than "eye test", that is maddening to people.
@boogiebradstevens - For me it's the odd precedent they are now setting. Yes, a 1 loss difference could impact rankings if someone had a stunningly good win or bad loss, but the record was the most important factor for the history of college football. Suddenly, it's not that. The highest 2 loss team through week 12 was #6 LSU in 2022. They were coming off back-to-back wins over then currently ranked #7 and #6 teams. We now have 2 in the top 5, and one of them is over an undefeated B1G team. It's the changing of criteria in a way that is so abnormally in favor of the teams in one conference for no reason other than "eye test", that is maddening to people.
The big ten and other conferences need to stand up for their teams and denounce the obvious favoritism

