Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

I am Done with the ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

I am Done with the CFP Committee

Page 5 / 5
Tammany's avatar
(@tammany)
Famed Member

@iunorth Really?  The B1G is getting killed on the political dynamics of the committee.  Lots of questions and controversy there.

The last six words are acknowledging what happens on the field still matters to some extent.  I think the SEC is better this season, but not by as much as the committee thinks.

The whole committee process sucks but the B1G has to play the game and make its case more than it does.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/19/2026 10:05 am
Boogie's avatar
(@boogie)
Famed Member

Joel Klatt is spot on.  

 

He asked why the SEC is so good.  The answer, because they have 9 ranked teams.   

 

Why do they have 9 ranked teams?  Because the SEC is so good.

 

The committee has to have those teams in the rankings so it props up the top SEC teams.  If they didn't, their whole argument falls apart.  But nobody can tell us why the SEC is actually good.  It's just a bunch of word salad.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/19/2026 10:09 am
👍
2
Butch Crawling's avatar
(@big-ryan)
Famed Member

@walt542 That requires a pretty deep dive but I did quickly look at some related info.

The final AP poll (after the IU/Miami natty in January) had 7 SEC teams in the Top 25.  Notwithstanding the SEC's dismal performance in last season's CFP (more on that in a second), this year's preseason AP poll included 9 SEC teams. 

Five SEC teams competed in last year's CFP.  Except for Ole Miss, they sucked: 

  • Ole Miss (2-1): Beat Tulane in the first round, beat Georgia in the quarters (Sugar) and lost to Miami in the semis.
  • Alabama (1-1): Beat Oklahoma on the road in the first round and then was dismantled by us in the quarters (Rose). 
  • Georgia (0-1): The mighty SEC champs, the 3-seed in the CFP, made a quick exit, losing to Ole Miss in the quarters (Sugar).
  • Oklahoma (0-1): Lost at home to Alabama in the first round.
  • Texas A&M (0-1): Lost at home to Miami in the first round.

That's a combined 3-5, with just one win against a team from outside the SEC. 

Three Big Ten teams competed in last year's CFP:

  • Hoosiers (3-0): Beat Bama, Oregon and at Miami
  • Oregon (2-1): Beat JMU in the first round, crushed/shut out Texas Tech in the quarters (Orange) and, unfortunately for them, had to play us in the semis (Peach).
  • Ohio State (0-1): Lost to Miami in the quarters (Cotton).

That's a combined 5-2.

SEC bias is off the charts. 


This post was modified 1 hour ago by Butch Crawling
ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/19/2026 10:12 am
Boogie's avatar
(@boogie)
Famed Member

Posted by: @gros-louis
↑

Posted by: @iunorth
↑

In regards to Bama's ranking...  I think the thought that makes the most sense, to me, right now... is they're going to drop them in next week's ranking for playing Chattanooga, probably down to 5 or so.  UCLA up to 3 if they win, Texas up to 4, Bama 5, ND 6, Miami 7, IU 8, Tenn 9...  And they knew they were going to need to drop them no matter where they were ranked, just for playing that game.  So they're keeping them "artificially inflated", so the end result is them still being in a position to host a CFP game. 

Assuming all the teams above IU keep winning, IU won't have a chance to leap frog any of them, until after the B10 title game.  And if Georgia, Utah, and Miami all win out, I think its setup that IU won't get a bye, even if they win the B10 Title game.  At which point, this committee should be publicly shamed.  Like a public trial of some sorts, people allowed to throw rotten tomatoes at them... that sort of thing.  

You really think they'll ding Bama for this game even though they had a chance to ding them for am ugly performance at Vandy and didn't?  I don't see that at all.  And I maintain that if we beat undefeated UCLA for the B1G Championship, there's a really good chance we leap ND and Miami.

 

 

Not only that, but all of Bama's "good wins" lost last week.   Every single one of them.

 

Rules for thee but not for me.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/19/2026 10:13 am
👍
3
LBW's avatar
 LBW
(@lbw)
Estimable Member

@boogie I'm surprised no one has mentioned the bowl games last season. The Big Ten showed their strength by only losing one dowl game (?).


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/19/2026 10:43 am
Gros Louis's avatar
(@gros-louis)
Noble Member

As I said previously, my head about exploded when I saw the reveal of teams 21-25 this week.  South Carolina being ranked was my #1 issue, but many of the others as well.  I also don't get the Alabama placement as it relates to Texas and Tennessee.

But despite all of this 'SEC bias' conversation, I don't think we can ignore the fact that the first two 3-loss teams are both Big Ten teams.  And almost as head scratching as South Cackalacky still being ranked after their Pig Sooie embarrassment is how does Ohio State move up 6 spots after beating Northwestern without Aiden Chiles?  And in comfortable, but not dominating fashion.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/19/2026 11:15 am
👍
1
hooky
(@hooky)
Famed Member

Posted by: @gros-louis
↑

And almost as head scratching as South Cackalacky still being ranked after their Pig Sooie embarrassment is how does Ohio State move up 6 spots after beating Northwestern without Aiden Chiles?  And in comfortable, but not dominating fashion.

If they're getting that much credit for beating NU without him, why didn't we see a bump based on beating them when he was playing?


Hope is not optimism, which expects things to turn out well, but something rooted in the conviction that there is good worth working for. - Seamus Heaney, Irish poet and likely Hoosier basketball fan.
POTFB

ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/19/2026 11:23 am
👍
1
Page 5 / 5
Share: