@kkott Another example of SEleCtive applications of factors... Alabama has beaten a few teams that were ranked, when they played them, but that have since fallen off and aren't ranked any more. Sound familiar? Its astounding how blatantly bias this year's rankings have been, and how awful the overall process now is.
I typed in to chat GPT just now... "taking all factors in, all stats, all analytics, who's healthy on every team, rank the top 12 teams in college football". Here's what it gave me, with small explanations after each team...
1. Georgia... Most complete team
2. Notre Dame... Elite overall talent and efficiency
3. Utah... Undefeated, extremely dangerous
4. Miami... Explosive offense, championship ceiling
5. Indiana... Elite defensive performance
6. Texas... Excellent defense and big game ability
7. Alabama... High end talent, but some concerns
8. UCLA... Undefeated, deserves significant respect
9. Wake Forest... One of the most impressive recent performances
10. Tennessee... very strong efficiency numbers
11. Texas Tech... Dangerous offense, defensive questions
12. BYU... consistent, balanced team
5 seconds... markedly better rankings, and reasonings for the rankings, than what the committee is putting out. Bring back the computer rankings.
I think the committee gets blown away by the SEC visuals. Their conference is more logical geographically (more interesting games) and on average has great game day atmospheres.
How could a team that plays in these amazing places like Neyland or Jordan Hare or Tiger Stadium not be good? Well they can be despite what it looks like.
I do worry Petitti doesn’t know how to play the political game as well as the SEC and set the B1G up for trouble by going with this committee structure.
@iunorth I would take a committee of AI. Pick the top three or five models every year and use those. vbg but I’m serious.
That 12 would be totally acceptable. With BYU dropped for Boise per the G6 agreement.5 seconds... markedly better rankings, and reasonings for the rankings, than what the committee is putting out. Bring back the computer rankings.
Far, far better than the trash the committee is spewing. We all knew the computer was the one reasonable part of the BCS and humans putting their thumbs on the scale was very bad. But ESPN makes more money with the CFP thumb on the scale. So we got that trash of an idea. Corruption, and they don't care as long as their schools and ESPN benefits.
And I don't care that Coach Cignetti likes Petitti . Petitti has clearly shown himself to be a fool. Unless he has behind the scenes money greasing his pocket, or the pockets of the Big Ten teams.
@openwheel Probably could have UCLA higher, ranked right above IU even... but overall, its quite a lot better, and more reasoned, than what the CFP is putting out. B10, B12, ACC leaders should be more vocal about some of these inconsistencies... B10 leaders, as an example, are leaving their most marquee coach out on a limb, on his own, right now.
12. BYU... consistent, balanced team
*clank* Consistent after 2 second half season losses, one to UCF?
Oh wait, per Dinich leaking the committee methods, that loss was a 'let down game' so it is discounted.
But anyway, good ranking, BYU would reasonably get dropped for a G6. (Not sure if Boise, just going by the corrupt committee on that.)
Either you go by an algorithm or the statisticians or you don't. Humans looking at it and agreeing or not would not be good.Probably could have UCLA higher, ranked right above IU even...
But yes, different formulas would have different results. UCLA could be top 5. For some reason I haven't seen them up there in the stat guys rankings. Top 10 almost everywhere though.
If I do 'feelz' or old school human ranking, UCLA's undefeated status trumps us by one spot. Since although we might be a foot (pun intended) from beating OSU, we did not, and have offensively struggled a bit too much. Defense used to be highly thought of in 'old school' ratings though. Not by the current CFP committee. Heck they don't even mind teams losing!
So my head kind of exploded when I saw the reveal of 21-25 just like everyone else. But then I started looking at the other options for teams to include in those last 5 spots instead of the 5 they have in there. It's not real pretty if you scroll through here are look at all of the teams in the country.I think the committee gets blown away by the SEC visuals. Their conference is more logical geographically (more interesting games) and on average has great game day atmospheres.
How could a team that plays in these amazing places like Neyland or Jordan Hare or Tiger Stadium not be good? Well they can be despite what it looks like.
I do worry Petitti doesn’t know how to play the political game as well as the SEC and set the B1G up for trouble by going with this committee structure.
https://www.espn.com/college-football/standings
The great thing is that ESPN can’t protect SEC teams once they step on the field and we’ve all seen how they’ve flamed out over the last three playoffs. Will be glorious to watch again.
@gros-louis Personally I think the SEC is the top to bottom best league this year. I'm okay with them having more teams ranked and in the playoff, I do think it's going a little too far though.
As of now, even the in-conference relative rankings make little sense.
Look at Alabama, Tennessee, Texas. All with the same overall records. All with the same conference records. All with relatively close SOS.
Based on head-to-head, they should be ranked Texas>Tennessee>Alabama. Texas has more “big” wins than Alabama, too. Id put all three right behind IU.
As of now, I’d go something like:
Georgia
UCLA/ Utah
ND/IU/Miami
Texas
Tennessee
Alabama
Wake Forest
BYU
TX Tech
IF we can win out and Georgia does too, we should be #2.
Lots of football left to play.
The Good News.
If Tennessee loses to LSU this weekend, and there is no other chaos, the SEC will only get 3 CFP bids.
Heard a good question posed.
Is Bama the same record and ranking fraud that A&M was last season?
How about this question.
Let's say the Washington game is in hand per se, does Cignetti break character and not grind the closing quarters out on the ground with the run game, but instead, intentionally make the calls to run up the score with beautiful deep shots to our WRs?
@middawg That's a good question and he had a shot to do that against USC a little bit as well and bled the last couple minutes out instead of pushing the score to 34-13. We'll see, but it seems like this year Cig wants to get his team off the field as quick as possible if the game is in hand.
Thank you for reading Hoosier Huddle
The Good News.
If Tennessee loses to LSU this weekend, and there is no other chaos, the SEC will only get 3 CFP bids.
Heard a good question posed.
Is Bama the same record and ranking fraud that A&M was last season?
I don’t think it so. Keelon Russell is a lot better than Marcel Reed. Bama has had a tougher schedule.
Don’t get me wrong I think they’re getting overrated a bit. I just don’t see Bama doing something like scoring 3 pts in a home playoff game.
