Yeah, this is my sense of how many people think of America now too.The US has been turned into an economic zone.
We used to be a multi ethnic monoculture. Somewhere along the line someone got the idea in their head that we had to be multicultural. That doesn't work. Americanism used to be strictly enforced. You want to come here and earn money? Cool, here is what it costs, most of your ties to the old country. We won't cater to your cultural sensitivities because you are an American. If you want to be Mexican or German or Chinese, get back on the f-ing boat. That isn't the case anymore. Now we are everything to everyone which means we are nothing. The US has been turned into an economic zone. Americans are just the old shopping mall employees who the bosses use for labor. We shop at the "company" store and pay dues that are increasingly used by new workers coming from the town over who work for $.50 cheaper an hour. The massimmigration with no cultural
That is wrong, entire communities spoke German. What ended that was world war one. We had hundreds of German newspaper, Ohio passed a law requiring bilingual education, see below. An entire corps in the Army of the Potomac spoke German, not English. Both the Union (brigade) and Confederacy (regiment) had units that fought under an Irish flag
https://withwingsandroots.org/en/timelines/state-legislation-authorizes-german-bilingual-education
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_German-language_newspapers_published_in_the_United_States
You got my position wrong. I don't think you have to learn about Jefferson's sex with his slaves to understand the historical importance of the Declaration of Independence.The America Reagan referenced no longer exists. It’s been washed out by “warts and all” teaching of US history. Recall our discussion about the Declaration of Independence? I think that is one of the most important documents in world history concerning the nature of government. You insisted that in order to teach about and understand the declaration, we must also teach that TJ banged a slave. I think that is a useless distraction. (If I got your position wrong, I’m sure you will post a correction).
But I do think that if you're learning U.S. history (which is much more expansive than the Dec of Independence), you need to know what life was like for the leaders and everyone else back then and personal stuff about Jefferson and all the other founders, just as we know a ton and like to discuss the personal stuff around all big historical figures. And Jefferson's relationship with Hemmings qualifies for both those subjects.
Here's what I wrote previously:
I think the “warts and all” approach to US history for the reasons I said is crap. The warts are nothingbergers. When almost all southern ag owners, and many in the north, owned slaves, the fact that some founders also owned some is irrelevant to our history. So yeah, if I were to teach history, I’d teach about the Missouri compromise, Dredd, Scott, Andrew Jackson, and Calhoon. That is much more instructive about the issue.
Im guessing he’ll learn all that too. It’s AP US History.
I’d argue an inability to recognize the importance of the Founders’ hypocrisy on slavery and race makes it difficult for one to understand a very important part of US history and why race still, to this day, is so important to our politics.
Jefferson’s particular hypocrisy didn’t end at slavery—his stated desire for a very limited federal government and powers evaporated when he became Prez.
For me, though, I’m not sure what good it does to assume the moral value conclusion of rape (very strong word with connotations of violence) in 1770s based on 21st century norms. There is evidence that Hemings “consented” in a non-trivial way within her circumstances. I think it’s a very thorny issue.
Fascinating. I wonder, did those Germans think of themselves as Americans, German Americans, or Germans who just happened to live in America? The strong posiition would be that we should require the first, with no modifiers; the middle position would be that we want people here to be Americans first, but should be able to reference their culture/ancestry with pride; the third would be in favor of non assimilation and is what I am definitely against.We used to be a multi ethnic monoculture. Somewhere along the line someone got the idea in their head that we had to be multicultural. That doesn't work. Americanism used to be strictly enforced. You want to come here and earn money? Cool, here is what it costs, most of your ties to the old country. We won't cater to your cultural sensitivities because you are an American. If you want to be Mexican or German or Chinese, get back on the f-ing boat. That isn't the case anymore. Now we are everything to everyone which means we are nothing. The US has been turned into an economic zone. Americans are just the old shopping mall employees who the bosses use for labor. We shop at the "company" store and pay dues that are increasingly used by new workers coming from the town over who work for $.50 cheaper an hour. The massimmigration with no cultural
That is wrong, entire communities spoke German. What ended that was world war one. We had hundreds of German newspaper, Ohio passed a law requiring bilingual education, see below. An entire corps in the Army of the Potomac spoke German, not English. Both the Union (brigade) and Confederacy (regiment) had units that fought under an Irish flag
https://withwingsandroots.org/en/timelines/state-legislation-authorizes-german-bilingual-education
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_German-language_newspapers_published_in_the_United_States
I'm for the middle option, I guess, even though I don't have any modifiers I think important.
One reason that the left and right (used to?) agree upon:
https://twitter.com/adamkjohnston/status/1843434782858063923?s=46
I hope we're not different. It would mean we're for open borders. The last time the amount of foreign born population was close to this high the country drastically cut back on it. Hopefully, history repeats.
The problem this time is a bunch of naive (putting it kindly) leftist have been brainwashed into thinking ICE and/or border control are the problems. I am not hopeful, but Trump did win in 24, so there is some hope.
Edit: lol...I forgot to answer your original question on why America is different now. If leftists win this time and we don't cut back. Then I think it's due to media propaganda (best guess). The way you phrase the question shows how powerful it is. Sorry, but it was backwards.
America is different now because of several reasons:
1. We are in the beginning of another work place revolution that is beginning to impact employment. Sectors of the workforce that used to be untouchable are now starting to feel the pinch and sectors of the economy (like tech) are importing a bunch of 3rd world brown people for jobs with a fairly high unemployment rate, particularly among new grads. Those third worlders have a tendency to show their ass when challenged (see Ramaswamy forever destroying his political career with his "stupid Americans" tweets) and that just adds to the friction. We can't guarantee the economy that can continue to support a bunch of new mouths, particularly "other" new mouths. People are inherently tribal and those tribal tendencies tend to be much more pronounced when starting to face scarcity.
2. We used to be a multi ethnic monoculture. Somewhere along the line someone got the idea in their head that we had to be multicultural. That doesn't work. Americanism used to be strictly enforced. You want to come here and earn money? Cool, here is what it costs, most of your ties to the old country. We won't cater to your cultural sensitivities because you are an American. If you want to be Mexican or German or Chinese, get back on the f-ing boat. That isn't the case anymore. Now we are everything to everyone which means we are nothing. The US has been turned into an economic zone. Americans are just the old shopping mall employees who the bosses use for labor. We shop at the "company" store and pay dues that are increasingly used by new workers coming from the town over who work for $.50 cheaper an hour. The massimmigration with no cultural ties means that the foreigners coming over aren't viewed as Americans by anyone, including themselves.
3. And we got here by destroying all of our secular "heroes". We have deconstructed pretty much every founding father and every founding story into evil oppressor colonial imperialists. We have stripped the soul out of everything. It was the cultural equivalent of tearing out all of the old mom and pop stores in the classic downtown square and replacing them with a strip mall anchored by Walmart. There is no community anymore, only an economic zone. When you are the Mom and Pop people, these newbies coming in are representative of the destruction of what you once knew. They aren't new neighbors, they are invaders, economic competitors. And again, getting back to basic human psychology, they don't look like you, they don't talk like you, they (in many cases) don't share your religious cultural worldview, and they don't share your views on morality.
4. Not an exhaustive list, but my final point that was somewhat touched on up above: all of these new people that are brought in get exposed to a growing political movement that portrays the original inhabitants as those oppressors and imperialists and the inheritors of an illegitimate political and cultural nation. So not only does we not force them to assimilate, we flat out encourage them to be antagonistic towards everything that made this place the type of country they wanted to come extract wealth from in the first place.
And that is prejudiced and it is racist and it is bigoted and all the other things that people would want to label it, but it is how every country on the planet operates without criticism except for the first world countries that happened to be predominantly white. They are expected to surrender their cultures to the horde. I say that we expel quite a bit of the new folks and strictly control who comes in from here forward. We can be multi ethnic again and open the doors to other ethnicities but it has to be under the old rules. When you come here you aren't whatever you were, you are American now. That secular cultural zeitgeist should be vigorously enforced. Thomas Jefferson was a good dude from the perspective of how this country was built and I don't give a f--- that he owned slaves. It is ok to have a national mythology. We need to stop apologizing for who we are. Anyone that wants us to apologize probably doesn't belong here anyway.
This is spot on. This discouraging thing is that there is no fixing it. 2020-2024 has forever changed our country for the worse. Americans were sold out by Dems for votes.
We used to be a multi ethnic monoculture. Somewhere along the line someone got the idea in their head that we had to be multicultural. That doesn't work. Americanism used to be strictly enforced. You want to come here and earn money? Cool, here is what it costs, most of your ties to the old country. We won't cater to your cultural sensitivities because you are an American. If you want to be Mexican or German or Chinese, get back on the f-ing boat. That isn't the case anymore. Now we are everything to everyone which means we are nothing. The US has been turned into an economic zone. Americans are just the old shopping mall employees who the bosses use for labor. We shop at the "company" store and pay dues that are increasingly used by new workers coming from the town over who work for $.50 cheaper an hour. The massimmigration with no cultural
That is wrong, entire communities spoke German. What ended that was world war one. We had hundreds of German newspaper, Ohio passed a law requiring bilingual education, see below. An entire corps in the Army of the Potomac spoke German, not English. Both the Union (brigade) and Confederacy (regiment) had units that fought under an Irish flag
https://withwingsandroots.org/en/timelines/state-legislation-authorizes-german-bilingual-education
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_German-language_newspapers_published_in_the_United_States
Being an American does not mean speaking English.
@oneeyedundertaker Iucrazy had a very thoughtful and accurate essay. You are also right. President Biden, to those who think, will go down as the worst president in American history. It's not even debatable. In all areas he was on a a path to destroy the country. What's frightening is that those who pulled his strings have gained even more power in politics. The radical left. You asked what we can do. We can vote for Republicans. From the top to the bottom. Don't even look at their background. Maga. Kind. Despicable. Rino. Doesn't matter. If they are a Republican you vote for them. Maybe someday Democrats will become normal Americans again, but I'm not hopeful. And you support your community. Your kids' school. And you make sure your husband gets his ass to work and you have a separate bank account. The only thing I've encountered dumber than a modern Democrat is a husband. Buy him a freezer for the garage and you can spend a hundred grand on purses and he'll look the other way.
Being an American does not mean speaking English.
Were you around back in the English as a national language debate? Many on your side demanded that. They would say that not learning English was not assimilating.
At the time, Germans and Irish were absolutely hated. Both tended to congregate in communities of their nationality to feel more at home and insulate themselves from the hatred of the Scots-Irish. The NY draft riots were largely Irish worried that freed Black slaves would move North and pass them on the economic scale. Think how put down Irish must have felt to think they would be beneath slaves.
Some Americans like having an "other", some outside group to blame. It was Germans, Irish, Catholics, Chinese, Japanese, Vietnamese, Hispanic, and now Muslim. And we are supposed to believe, "yes we were wrong all those other times, but this time we are right."
There are many Muslims I do not want in this country. And I would be very comfortable telling the current Saudi leader to go to hell if he asked to come here again. But that doesn't mean all Muslims are that way any more than it meant all Catholics took orders from the Pope or all Jews are part of a global cabal.
Being an American does not mean speaking English.
Were you around back in the English as a national language debate? Many on your side demanded that. They would say that not learning English was not assimilating.
At the time, Germans and Irish were absolutely hated. Both tended to congregate in communities of their nationality to feel more at home and insulate themselves from the hatred of the Scots-Irish. The NY draft riots were largely Irish worried that freed Black slaves would move North and pass them on the economic scale. Think how put down Irish must have felt to think they would be beneath slaves.
Some Americans like having an "other", some outside group to blame. It was Germans, Irish, Catholics, Chinese, Japanese, Vietnamese, Hispanic, and now Muslim. And we are supposed to believe, "yes we were wrong all those other times, but this time we are right."
There are many Muslims I do not want in this country. And I would be very comfortable telling the current Saudi leader to go to hell if he asked to come here again. But that doesn't mean all Muslims are that way any more than it meant all Catholics took orders from the Pope or all Jews are part of a global cabal.
Marv, You are consumed by suicidal empathy. How do we tell which Muslims are violent or are not when deciding who to let in? How many rapes, violent crimes, etc. committed by foreigners against US citizens are acceptable? What is the reward for this risk?
And you make sure your husband gets his ass to work and you have a separate bank account. The only thing I've encountered dumber than a modern Democrat is a husband. Buy him a freezer for the garage and you can spend a hundred grand on purses and he'll look the other way.
Marv, You are consumed by suicidal empathy. How do we tell which Muslims are violent or are not when deciding who to let in? How many rapes, violent crimes, etc. committed by foreigners against US citizens are acceptable? What is the reward for this risk?
I don't think it is empathy, it is taking, "All men are created equal" literally. I have said many times, I grew up in a racist/populist household that thought George Wallace was a great American. I reject that past. A friend's dad was head of the local Birch Society, I find it interesting he has made the same progression and left his Evangelical Church for mainstream.
We are bringing Qatari military to the US to train. Did you oppose that in the thread it came up?
I don't know how to screen, but we have experts on this. Probably the same experts that will screen the Qataris.
Marv, You are consumed by suicidal empathy. How do we tell which Muslims are violent or are not when deciding who to let in? How many rapes, violent crimes, etc. committed by foreigners against US citizens are acceptable? What is the reward for this risk?
I don't think it is empathy, it is taking, "All men are created equal" literally. I have said many times, I grew up in a racist/populist household that thought George Wallace was a great American. I reject that past. A friend's dad was head of the local Birch Society, I find it interesting he has made the same progression and left his Evangelical Church for mainstream.
We are bringing Qatari military to the US to train. Did you oppose that in the thread it came up?
I don't know how to screen, but we have experts on this. Probably the same experts that will screen the Qataris.
I can set up a good system in two minutes. Nobody from Muslim nations and have everyone take an IQ test. If they score under 100, see ya. The only exceptions on the IQ test are BBLs (Big Booty Latinos).
Marv, You are consumed by suicidal empathy. How do we tell which Muslims are violent or are not when deciding who to let in? How many rapes, violent crimes, etc. committed by foreigners against US citizens are acceptable? What is the reward for this risk?
I don't think it is empathy, it is taking, "All men are created equal" literally. I have said many times, I grew up in a racist/populist household that thought George Wallace was a great American. I reject that past. A friend's dad was head of the local Birch Society, I find it interesting he has made the same progression and left his Evangelical Church for mainstream.
We are bringing Qatari military to the US to train. Did you oppose that in the thread it came up?
I don't know how to screen, but we have experts on this. Probably the same experts that will screen the Qataris.
Qataris are going to train & go home, & have absolutely nothing to do with immigration. Not stay here to steal, rape, kill, & impose their culture on us.
Every anecdote & example you present is decades old & not relevant today, no matter how racist your upbringing. It’s not your fault, let go of your guilt, it’s ruining America.
Qataris are going to train & go home, & have absolutely nothing to do with immigration. Not stay here to steal, rape, kill, & impose their culture on us.
Every anecdote & example you present is decades old & not relevant today, no matter how racist your upbringing. It’s not your fault, let go of your guilt, it’s ruining America.
So the Qataris will have no contact with Americans while there. It will be impossible for them to kill or rape a single person? Are they being locked in cells when they are not training under armed guards?
