Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Notifications
Clear all

THE BEAUTIFUL GAME

Page 4 / 8
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @larsiu
↑

giphy

her magic hand has my attention 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 8:58 am
😂
1
C Probert's avatar
(@bar-down)
Illustrious Member

@goat so i didn't get up to watch it but i watched the replay they do on there.  what a bitch.  i HATE those fing handballs.  dude is sliding. he isn't htinking about where is arm is. it's away from his body so they call it but i really wish they'd change that.  imo natural position should reflect what you're actually doing.  if you are sliding i'd argue his arm was in a natural position.  and the fing keeper.  omg he guessed right and it went under him.  he's got to be sick.  anyway.


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 05/16/2026 4:24 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bar-down
↑

@goat so i didn't get up to watch it but i watched the replay they do on there.  what a bitch.  i HATE those fing handballs.  dude is sliding. he isn't htinking about where is arm is. it's away from his body so they call it but i really wish they'd change that.  imo natural position should reflect what you're actually doing.  if you are sliding i'd argue his arm was in a natural position.  and the fing keeper.  omg he guessed right and it went under him.  he's got to be sick.  anyway.

Don't forget the offside call.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 4:34 pm
C Probert's avatar
(@bar-down)
Illustrious Member

@goat i never really understand that hto.  so the player "in play" was on an onside position but the guy who ultimately scored was essentially deemed not involved in that play so fine.  but i always thought you couldn't come from an offsides position.  i don't know. i get confused with all that


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 05/16/2026 4:45 pm
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @bar-down
↑

@goat i never really understand that hto.  so the player "in play" was on an onside position but the guy who ultimately scored was essentially deemed not involved in that play so fine.  but i always thought you couldn't come from an offsides position.  i don't know. i get confused with all that

So lemme get this straight... all this soccer you've played for all these years at so many levels and you don't know the rules?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 5:01 pm
😂
1
C Probert's avatar
(@bar-down)
Illustrious Member

@unclemark not really.  was a god awful coach as well.


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 05/16/2026 5:03 pm
😂
2
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bar-down
↑

@goat i never really understand that hto.  so the player "in play" was on an onside position but the guy who ultimately scored was essentially deemed not involved in that play so fine.  but i always thought you couldn't come from an offsides position.  i don't know. i get confused with all that

I always thought that if you were involved in the play when the pass was made, you had to be onside, whether you touch the ball or not. I would have thought Daizen qualified as "involved" even before it got punched back to him, because he was so close to the forward pass, he had to have an effect on spacing, at the very least. I totally understand the explanation the experts are giving, but in the moment, it really felt like that flag should have been upheld.

But I actually understand the rules even less than you. As far as I can tell, the ultimate rule of soccer is just "I feelz it."

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 9:29 pm
C Probert's avatar
(@bar-down)
Illustrious Member

@goat i don't know.  maybe @larsiu does.  but hte guy who the ball is played to (to use your words was involved in the play) was on so we are good there.  then HE played the ball to a guy WHO WAS NOT INVOLVED IN THE PLAY (arguably) and he scored so all good according to what happened.  now.  the guy who scored who was NOT ostensibly involved in teh play originally came from an off sides position. i had always thought that that was enough to preclude him from being eligible.  so he scored and it was confirmed.  so it's at that point that i think that what i always presumed was wrong.  as long as he wasn't involved in the original ball it doesn't matter that he came from an off sides position to finish it.


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 05/16/2026 9:38 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bar-down
↑

@goat i don't know.  maybe @larsiu does.  but hte guy who the ball is played to (to use your words was involved in the play) was on so we are good there.  then HE played the ball to a guy WHO WAS NOT INVOLVED IN THE PLAY (arguably) and he scored so all good according to what happened.  now.  the guy who scored who was NOT ostensibly involved in teh play originally came from an off sides position. i had always thought that that was enough to preclude him from being eligible.  so he scored and it was confirmed.  so it's at that point that i think that what i always presumed was wrong.  as long as he wasn't involved in the original ball it doesn't matter that he came from an off sides position to finish it.

Yeah, that's kind of why I'm confused. Some people say he was fine if he didn't touch the ball, some people say he was fine if he wasn't involved, some people say he was fine if he didn't interfere. Okay, he didn't touch the ball. Questionably, he didn't interfere. But I'd argue he was absolutely involved in the first pass, just because of how close he was. So I guess I don't know shit, is what it comes down to.

I'm fine with the result. Helluva finish for the Bhoys. Ran the entire top of the table to make up the gap and win on the last day. That's a special accomplishment. If it weren't for their fans flipping off Hearts supporters and storming the field, I'd have no complaint. But you'll get that. There are other teams I root for whose fans are shitty. I went to a game in Minneapolis once, and the Vikings fans were just right assholes. Cubs fans are drunks. IU fans, well we all know what's wrong with them.

I think the only time I've ever been to a game where the fans on my side didn't offend me was at Comerica. Tigers fans are the absolutely most polite people in the world.

Edit: Also, let's be honest, Celtic had the better of things today most of the time. Hearts might have gotten more shots off, but a lot of them weren't very good. Celtic had all the possession and controlled the pace. It was a deserved win.

 


This post was modified 6 months ago by Goat
ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 9:53 pm
C Probert's avatar
(@bar-down)
Illustrious Member

@goat okay well I’m only replying to your edit as I didn’t watch it but if that’s the case all good with me.  And as for the call and rules I really don’t know.  I’ve never really been great with or known all the rules.


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 05/16/2026 10:18 pm
larsIU
(@larsiu)
Noble Member

@bar-down @goat 

both Celtic goals were legit. The handball was a handball. 

second goal - the goal scorer didn’t impact the defender on the original pass and was established onside when the assist came. 

sucks for hearts but they should have dirtied up the last ten mins of that game. Don’t save yellows for next season. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 10:39 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @larsiu
↑

@bar-down @goat 

both Celtic goals were legit. The handball was a handball. 

second goal - the goal scorer didn’t impact the defender on the original pass and was established onside when the assist came. 

sucks for hearts but they should have dirtied up the last ten mins of that game. Don’t save yellows for next season. 

Also, they shouldn't have played the entire second 45 on defense. My father always taught me "The only thing the prevent defense prevents is winning." Hearts were playing the soccer version of prevent almost the entire second half.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 10:40 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @larsiu
↑

second goal - the goal scorer didn’t impact the defender on the original pass

How do they decide what "impacts the defender?" That's my only question. I thought it was clear that Daizen's position had an effect on the flow of the play and the position of the players. But he clearly didn't directly interfere with any of them. Is that the standard, then? Just don't directly interfere and you're fine?


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 10:43 pm
C Probert's avatar
(@bar-down)
Illustrious Member

@larsiu he was “ onside” when the ball was played but I’m fairly certain that it used to be that you couldn’t come from an offsides position.  He would have just had to let it go and turn his back. So he came from an offsides position and could never be onside. I’m clearly wrong in the instant case but I’m certain that’s how it used to be


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 05/16/2026 10:59 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bar-down
↑

@larsiu he was “ onside” when the ball was played but I’m fairly certain that it used to be that you couldn’t come from an offsides position.  He would have just had to let it go and turn his back. So he came from an offsides position and could never be onside. I’m clearly wrong in the instant case but I’m certain that’s how it used to be

In that case, though, there would need to be a way to establish yourself back onsides. How would you go about that?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/16/2026 11:04 pm
Page 4 / 8
Share: