Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Palestine-Israeli-I...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Palestine-Israeli-Iran War

Page 9 / 22
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

Posted by: @eppy99
↑

@carramrod I agree it's never an easy answer cut and dry.  Without being a historian I'm sure we can name many instances countries, religions, cultures made the decision to go to war to preserve or create a home for their people.  I would think we can look no further then the United States treatment of the Indians.  

This is about survival for a people.  When you've just experienced a Holocaust, been subjected to the Eastern European pogroms it's time to stand up for yourself.  I think many including yourself agree.

I do wish there was a path to peace where there wasn't so much death.  Seems that's a problem since the dawn of time.

Yes, I agree both sides have done wrong and as I've previoulsy mentioned I'm not in favor of the current Israeli governments handling of this situation.

 

 

It wasn’t war, until it was. Straight up bombing of bus stations. Kidnapping British officers. It was everything you accuse Hamas of being. 

 

Really?

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/04/2025 3:22 pm
CarRamRod's avatar
(@carramrod)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

@goat it’s not a simple issue to solve. Both sides have done a lot of wrong and will never trust each other.

I’m sorry if I don’t have the requisite clarity for you. 

Cooper had a correct diagnoses as far as I can tell. He’s not my favorite historian or one I would necessarily recommend, but I think he was right in this respect. 

To be clear, he's not a historian at all. 

Of course, neither is Dan Carlin.  

 

 

This fretting over who is and isn’t a historian seems rather trivial to me. 

I like people who take an interest in history and want to disseminate it.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 3:23 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

@goat it’s not a simple issue to solve. Both sides have done a lot of wrong and will never trust each other.

I’m sorry if I don’t have the requisite clarity for you. 

Cooper had a correct diagnoses as far as I can tell. He’s not my favorite historian or one I would necessarily recommend, but I think he was right in this respect. 

To be clear, he's not a historian at all. 

Of course, neither is Dan Carlin.  

 

 

This fretting over who is and isn’t a historian seems rather trivial to me. 

I like people who take an interest in history and want to disseminate it.

 

Rigor and careful thought matter.  PhDs are more likely--but not exclusively so--to display those traits. 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/04/2025 3:25 pm
Eppy99
(@eppy99)
Prominent Member

@bradstevens Absolutely Jews are safer in the US.  Certainly doesn't stop them from wanting to live in the homeland.  Probably no other nation than Israel, but the point is that wasn't always the case as evidenced by the US refusing to grant asylum to many Jews trying to escape Europe.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 3:27 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @eppy99
↑

@carramrod The Irgun were certainly controversial and earned their right to be considered terrorists of the time.  I think it's still reasonable to say post WWII these people were determined to never let Jews again be victims of a Holocaust.   They also were responsible for the bombing of the King David Hotel.  I don't think Israel would have become an independent state in 1948 without the Irgun and Haganah.  Pretty sure they were the first iteration of the IDF.  

If you all have never seen the movie Exodus starring Paul Newman, I'd highly recommend watching it.  It's about the ship Exodus trying to land at Palestine and having to convince the Brits they should be allowed entry.  Essentially a loose telling of Israel becoming a state in 1948.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0053804/?ref_=ext_shr_lnk

It's also a loose adaptation of the Leon Uris novel Exodus which is a good read, but in the book, which is highly slanted toward the Jewish side, you can still get a sense of how the Arabs were seen as second class by the original generation of Israelis.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 3:27 pm
👍
2
Eppy99
(@eppy99)
Prominent Member

@goat If I recall that's a pretty sizeable book.  I generally pass on those.  I'm pretty sure it still sits in my dads library.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 3:32 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

@eppy99 About 600 pages. Not short, but not his longest book, by far.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 3:36 pm
👍
1
CarRamRod's avatar
(@carramrod)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

@goat it’s not a simple issue to solve. Both sides have done a lot of wrong and will never trust each other.

I’m sorry if I don’t have the requisite clarity for you. 

Cooper had a correct diagnoses as far as I can tell. He’s not my favorite historian or one I would necessarily recommend, but I think he was right in this respect. 

To be clear, he's not a historian at all. 

Of course, neither is Dan Carlin.  

 

 

This fretting over who is and isn’t a historian seems rather trivial to me. 

I like people who take an interest in history and want to disseminate it.

 

Rigor and careful thought matter.  PhDs are more likely--but not exclusively so--to display those traits. 

 

I’m not close enough to them to judge their rigor and careful thought. But I enjoyed the output. Cooper claims he read 100+ different books before crafting “fear and loathing in the new Jerusalem”

I don’t like counting degrees, I think it’s bullshit. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 7:07 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

I’m not close enough to them to judge their rigor and careful thought. But I enjoyed the output. Cooper claims he read 100+ different books before crafting “fear and loathing in the new Jerusalem”

The problem with people like Cooper is that they are very good at presenting one face to the public and another to the in-group. The goal is to move attitudes using something called social judgment theory. There's a lot to it, but the basic gist is that we all have a range of ideas on a topic that are within our "latitude of acceptance" and outside this is our "latitude of rejection." If someone comes to us with something in the rejection zone, we tell them to piss off, but if they come to us with something in the acceptance zone, and they are persuasive, they can move us ever so slightly within that zone, and then our latitude of acceptance moves along with us, which gives them the opportunity to move us further later on. Enough of this eventually gets us to a point that, at the start, would have been deep in the rejection zone.

That's how you go from "Irgun did some awful things" to "All Jews need to be eradicated." Not at once, but with a million tiny steps. People like Cooper are very good at it, but do not be deceived: getting you to "All Jews need to be eradicated" is absolutely their goal.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 7:20 pm
CarRamRod's avatar
(@carramrod)
Famed Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

I’m not close enough to them to judge their rigor and careful thought. But I enjoyed the output. Cooper claims he read 100+ different books before crafting “fear and loathing in the new Jerusalem”

The problem with people like Cooper is that they are very good at presenting one face to the public and another to the in-group. The goal is to move attitudes using something called social judgment theory. There's a lot to it, but the basic gist is that we all have a range of ideas on a topic that are within our "latitude of acceptance" and outside this is our "latitude of rejection." If someone comes to us with something in the rejection zone, we tell them to piss off, but if they come to us with something in the acceptance zone, and they are persuasive, they can move us ever so slightly within that zone, and then our latitude of acceptance moves along with us, which gives them the opportunity to move us further later on. Enough of this eventually gets us to a point that, at the start, would have been deep in the rejection zone.

That's how you go from "Irgun did some awful things" to "All Jews need to be eradicated." Not at once, but with a million tiny steps. People like Cooper are very good at it, but do not be deceived: getting you to "All Jews need to be eradicated" is absolutely their goal.

Also known as the Overton window. All I can say is I listened to it,  nothing approaching “All Jews need to be eradicated” was said. 

I would venture to guess you haven’t listened and are forming your opinion via second hand sources. 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 7:48 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

All I can say is I listened to it,  nothing approaching “All Jews need to be eradicated” was said. 

That's the point. It won't be said. Not yet. But if you follow him, you'll eventually hear him say it, but only when he thinks you are ready to hear it.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 7:50 pm
Zeke4ahs
(@zeke4ahs)
Noble Member

@eppy99 For the record, I know many Jewish people, including some who live in Israel, who feel the exact same way that you do.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 8:01 pm
👍
1
Zeke4ahs
(@zeke4ahs)
Noble Member

@eppy99 I just reread Exodus a couple years ago after my trip to Israel. Leon Uris is one of my favorite authors.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 8:17 pm
👍
1
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @zeke4ahs
↑

@eppy99 I just reread Exodus a couple years ago after my trip to Israel. Leon Uris is one of my favorite authors.

Trinity is one of my favorite books. And even though it got mediocre reviews, I loved A God in Ruins.

We talked about Exodus on the old book thread, when you said you hadn't read it in a long time. Did you pick up on the anti-Arab sentiments on your reread?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 8:21 pm
Eppy99
(@eppy99)
Prominent Member

@goat never read it, only saw the movie


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 8:29 pm
Page 9 / 22
Share: