@goat For sure, portrayed them as dirty, cheaters, etc. That part made me a little uncomfortable. QB 7 and Mila 19 are my favorites.
Did you pick up on the anti-Arab sentiments on your reread?
Man, good vs. evil hasn't changed in over a half century, has it?

@goat For sure, portrayed them as dirty, cheaters, etc. That part made me a little uncomfortable. QB 7 and Mila 19 are my favorites.
Uris was a committed Zionist, and there's a reason much of his writing has been labeled as propaganda. I still haven't read The Haj, although I think I owe it to myself to do so. But as much as I loved Exodus, there are definitely cringe scenes. I think the worst is near the end, when Ari violently rejects Taha as a suitor for his sister. Up until that point, they were still both tentative allies against the British, but the very idea of an Arab marrying his sister disgusts him so much, that any further alliance is unthinkable. And notably, Uris describes this response from Ari as perfectly reasonable, while portraying Taha's turn toward Arab nationalism as the true betrayal of their friendship, while any reasonable reader will/should clearly see Ari's prejudiced rejection of his putative friend as the actual betrayal.
@goat I had no idea his stuff was controversial, until I decided to reread Exodus. The Haj has been sitting on my shelf for years. I need to pick it up.
@bradstevens I feel like you failed to respond to my several posts re: our discussion of the mathematics of starvation. So I asked AI about whether or not it is happening.
It is a factual and verifiable statement that a severe hunger crisis, with the risk of famine, is occurring in Gaza. The UN-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), a leading authority on food security, has stated that two of the three thresholds for famine have been met: a collapse in food consumption and a rapid increase in acute malnutrition. The third threshold, death from starvation, is also being reported with increasing frequency, particularly among children.
The question of whether this is "on purpose" involves intent, which is a legal and ethical determination, not just a matter of observable facts. However, there are a number of facts that are relevant to that determination:
-
Israeli Government Policy: Israel has implemented a comprehensive blockade on Gaza since 2007. Following the October 7th attack, the Israeli Defense Minister announced a "complete siege," stating, "There will be no electricity, no food, no fuel, everything is closed." While some of these restrictions have since been eased, humanitarian organizations argue that the flow of aid remains far below the needs of the population.
-
Aid Access and Restrictions: International humanitarian organizations, including UN agencies, have consistently reported that Israel's control over border crossings, its vetting process for aid, and the destruction of aid distribution infrastructure have severely restricted the amount of food and other essentials entering Gaza. Israel, for its part, has claimed it is allowing sufficient aid and has blamed the UN and other groups for distribution failures, while also accusing Hamas of stealing aid.
-
Destruction of Food Systems: Israeli military operations have led to the widespread destruction of Gaza's agricultural land, bakeries, and water infrastructure. This has crippled local food production, making the population almost entirely dependent on outside aid.
-
International Legal Rulings: The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has issued provisional measures in a case brought by South Africa alleging genocide. These measures ordered Israel to "take all measures within its power to prevent the commission of all acts" that violate the Genocide Convention, including "deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part." The court's order specifically mentions the need for Israel to ensure the provision of humanitarian assistance. The ICC has also sought arrest warrants for Israeli leaders on charges including using starvation of civilians as a weapon of war. These are not final judgments of guilt, but they are legal facts that indicate a high level of concern from international judicial bodies.
-
Historical Context: Documents uncovered from a 2008 Israeli court case revealed that, following Hamas's takeover of Gaza, Israel calculated the minimum number of calories needed to sustain the population while limiting the amount of food that could enter, a policy that a senior adviser at the time described as "putting the Palestinians on a diet, but not to make them die of hunger." This fact provides historical context for the current situation.
Therefore, while Israel denies the charge of intentionally starving Palestinians, a large body of evidence from international organizations, human rights groups, and legal bodies points to a pattern of actions and policies that have directly led to the widespread starvation and malnutrition of the civilian population.
@goat I had no idea his stuff was controversial, until I decided to reread Exodus. The Haj has been sitting on my shelf for years. I need to pick it up.
Even in its time, it was recognized as propaganda, but accusing someone of pro-Israeli propaganda is such a loaded charge, it was very difficult to take seriously. And, to be clear, I still love his writing. We just need to recognize that it comes from a very particular point of view, is all.
@bradstevens Sometimes when you want to understand someone's motivation, the easiest thing to do is simply take them at their word.
Sorry, just read this.@bradstevens I feel like you failed to respond to my several posts re: our discussion of the mathematics of starvation. So I asked AI about whether or not it is happening.
It is a factual and verifiable statement that a severe hunger crisis, with the risk of famine, is occurring in Gaza. The UN-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), a leading authority on food security, has stated that two of the three thresholds for famine have been met: a collapse in food consumption and a rapid increase in acute malnutrition. The third threshold, death from starvation, is also being reported with increasing frequency, particularly among children.
The question of whether this is "on purpose" involves intent, which is a legal and ethical determination, not just a matter of observable facts. However, there are a number of facts that are relevant to that determination:
Israeli Government Policy: Israel has implemented a comprehensive blockade on Gaza since 2007. Following the October 7th attack, the Israeli Defense Minister announced a "complete siege," stating, "There will be no electricity, no food, no fuel, everything is closed." While some of these restrictions have since been eased, humanitarian organizations argue that the flow of aid remains far below the needs of the population.
Aid Access and Restrictions: International humanitarian organizations, including UN agencies, have consistently reported that Israel's control over border crossings, its vetting process for aid, and the destruction of aid distribution infrastructure have severely restricted the amount of food and other essentials entering Gaza. Israel, for its part, has claimed it is allowing sufficient aid and has blamed the UN and other groups for distribution failures, while also accusing Hamas of stealing aid.
Destruction of Food Systems: Israeli military operations have led to the widespread destruction of Gaza's agricultural land, bakeries, and water infrastructure. This has crippled local food production, making the population almost entirely dependent on outside aid.
International Legal Rulings: The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has issued provisional measures in a case brought by South Africa alleging genocide. These measures ordered Israel to "take all measures within its power to prevent the commission of all acts" that violate the Genocide Convention, including "deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part." The court's order specifically mentions the need for Israel to ensure the provision of humanitarian assistance. The ICC has also sought arrest warrants for Israeli leaders on charges including using starvation of civilians as a weapon of war. These are not final judgments of guilt, but they are legal facts that indicate a high level of concern from international judicial bodies.
Historical Context: Documents uncovered from a 2008 Israeli court case revealed that, following Hamas's takeover of Gaza, Israel calculated the minimum number of calories needed to sustain the population while limiting the amount of food that could enter, a policy that a senior adviser at the time described as "putting the Palestinians on a diet, but not to make them die of hunger." This fact provides historical context for the current situation.
Therefore, while Israel denies the charge of intentionally starving Palestinians, a large body of evidence from international organizations, human rights groups, and legal bodies points to a pattern of actions and policies that have directly led to the widespread starvation and malnutrition of the civilian population.
I think the general position on this that I've written a few times covers this: (1) We are still in a fog of war and can't know for certain what is going on; (2) Hamas MOH, et al. is the ultimate source for most of these reported facts and they have a stated desire to lie and deceive and that is in the way in which they wage war--through drumming up public opinion that pities their plight, even if they started it; and (3) Israel is at war with Palestine, yet they are feeding them, supplying them with energy, etc. Seems like a glaring double standard to accuse them of war crimes and genocide in light of what other nation-states (including ours) have and have not done in other wars.
Edit: Also, (4) Hamas is largely responsible for the starvation because it steals food and resists food aid from the US/Israel source, instead saying it wants it from the UN--who won't agree to have their trucks searched by Israeli forces. In other words, this whole situation is in line with Hamas's strategy of using the Palestinian populace as a sword and shield in its war with Israel--I think it is Hamas who is intentionally starving its own population, then.
The Average Joe Palestinian is caught in an awful place. I feel for them. But I put the blame primarily on Hamas. I think it's odd to hold Israel to a standard of caring more about the average Palestinian than their own elected govt. does, especially since they hate Jews so much.
Sorry, just read this.@bradstevens I feel like you failed to respond to my several posts re: our discussion of the mathematics of starvation. So I asked AI about whether or not it is happening.
It is a factual and verifiable statement that a severe hunger crisis, with the risk of famine, is occurring in Gaza. The UN-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), a leading authority on food security, has stated that two of the three thresholds for famine have been met: a collapse in food consumption and a rapid increase in acute malnutrition. The third threshold, death from starvation, is also being reported with increasing frequency, particularly among children.
The question of whether this is "on purpose" involves intent, which is a legal and ethical determination, not just a matter of observable facts. However, there are a number of facts that are relevant to that determination:
Israeli Government Policy: Israel has implemented a comprehensive blockade on Gaza since 2007. Following the October 7th attack, the Israeli Defense Minister announced a "complete siege," stating, "There will be no electricity, no food, no fuel, everything is closed." While some of these restrictions have since been eased, humanitarian organizations argue that the flow of aid remains far below the needs of the population.
Aid Access and Restrictions: International humanitarian organizations, including UN agencies, have consistently reported that Israel's control over border crossings, its vetting process for aid, and the destruction of aid distribution infrastructure have severely restricted the amount of food and other essentials entering Gaza. Israel, for its part, has claimed it is allowing sufficient aid and has blamed the UN and other groups for distribution failures, while also accusing Hamas of stealing aid.
Destruction of Food Systems: Israeli military operations have led to the widespread destruction of Gaza's agricultural land, bakeries, and water infrastructure. This has crippled local food production, making the population almost entirely dependent on outside aid.
International Legal Rulings: The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has issued provisional measures in a case brought by South Africa alleging genocide. These measures ordered Israel to "take all measures within its power to prevent the commission of all acts" that violate the Genocide Convention, including "deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part." The court's order specifically mentions the need for Israel to ensure the provision of humanitarian assistance. The ICC has also sought arrest warrants for Israeli leaders on charges including using starvation of civilians as a weapon of war. These are not final judgments of guilt, but they are legal facts that indicate a high level of concern from international judicial bodies.
Historical Context: Documents uncovered from a 2008 Israeli court case revealed that, following Hamas's takeover of Gaza, Israel calculated the minimum number of calories needed to sustain the population while limiting the amount of food that could enter, a policy that a senior adviser at the time described as "putting the Palestinians on a diet, but not to make them die of hunger." This fact provides historical context for the current situation.
Therefore, while Israel denies the charge of intentionally starving Palestinians, a large body of evidence from international organizations, human rights groups, and legal bodies points to a pattern of actions and policies that have directly led to the widespread starvation and malnutrition of the civilian population.
I think the general position on this that I've written a few times covers this: (1) We are still in a fog of war and can't know for certain what is going on; (2) Hamas MOH, et al. is the ultimate source for most of these reported facts and they have a stated desire to lie and deceive and that is in the way in which they wage war--through drumming up public opinion that pities their plight, even if they started it; and (3) Israel is at war with Palestine, yet they are feeding them, supplying them with energy, etc. Seems like a glaring double standard to accuse them of war crimes and genocide in light of what other nation-states (including ours) have and have not done in other wars.
Edit: Also, (4) Hamas is largely responsible for the starvation because it steals food and resists food aid from the US/Israel source, instead saying it wants it from the UN--who won't agree to have their trucks searched by Israeli forces. In other words, this whole situation is in line with Hamas's strategy of using the Palestinian populace as a sword and shield in its war with Israel--I think it is Hamas who is intentionally starving its own population, then.
The Average Joe Palestinian is caught in an awful place. I feel for them. But I put the blame primarily on Hamas. I think it's odd to hold Israel to a standard of caring more about the average Palestinian than their own elected govt. does, especially since they hate Jews so much.
I’m torn on the broader issue you guys are discussing but a quick note on what Israel does for Gaza. Israel controlled food imports into Gaza before the war as they control the ports. Not sure I see food aid as charitable or gracious under those circumstances but cutting them off, even if it’s an operational clusterfuck to provide, seems much like genocide.
To put how non functioning Palestine is or is forced to be into perspective, Israel also controls their power, water, telecommunications, borders, and census.
Sorry, just read this.@bradstevens I feel like you failed to respond to my several posts re: our discussion of the mathematics of starvation. So I asked AI about whether or not it is happening.
It is a factual and verifiable statement that a severe hunger crisis, with the risk of famine, is occurring in Gaza. The UN-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), a leading authority on food security, has stated that two of the three thresholds for famine have been met: a collapse in food consumption and a rapid increase in acute malnutrition. The third threshold, death from starvation, is also being reported with increasing frequency, particularly among children.
The question of whether this is "on purpose" involves intent, which is a legal and ethical determination, not just a matter of observable facts. However, there are a number of facts that are relevant to that determination:
Israeli Government Policy: Israel has implemented a comprehensive blockade on Gaza since 2007. Following the October 7th attack, the Israeli Defense Minister announced a "complete siege," stating, "There will be no electricity, no food, no fuel, everything is closed." While some of these restrictions have since been eased, humanitarian organizations argue that the flow of aid remains far below the needs of the population.
Aid Access and Restrictions: International humanitarian organizations, including UN agencies, have consistently reported that Israel's control over border crossings, its vetting process for aid, and the destruction of aid distribution infrastructure have severely restricted the amount of food and other essentials entering Gaza. Israel, for its part, has claimed it is allowing sufficient aid and has blamed the UN and other groups for distribution failures, while also accusing Hamas of stealing aid.
Destruction of Food Systems: Israeli military operations have led to the widespread destruction of Gaza's agricultural land, bakeries, and water infrastructure. This has crippled local food production, making the population almost entirely dependent on outside aid.
International Legal Rulings: The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has issued provisional measures in a case brought by South Africa alleging genocide. These measures ordered Israel to "take all measures within its power to prevent the commission of all acts" that violate the Genocide Convention, including "deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part." The court's order specifically mentions the need for Israel to ensure the provision of humanitarian assistance. The ICC has also sought arrest warrants for Israeli leaders on charges including using starvation of civilians as a weapon of war. These are not final judgments of guilt, but they are legal facts that indicate a high level of concern from international judicial bodies.
Historical Context: Documents uncovered from a 2008 Israeli court case revealed that, following Hamas's takeover of Gaza, Israel calculated the minimum number of calories needed to sustain the population while limiting the amount of food that could enter, a policy that a senior adviser at the time described as "putting the Palestinians on a diet, but not to make them die of hunger." This fact provides historical context for the current situation.
Therefore, while Israel denies the charge of intentionally starving Palestinians, a large body of evidence from international organizations, human rights groups, and legal bodies points to a pattern of actions and policies that have directly led to the widespread starvation and malnutrition of the civilian population.
I think the general position on this that I've written a few times covers this: (1) We are still in a fog of war and can't know for certain what is going on; (2) Hamas MOH, et al. is the ultimate source for most of these reported facts and they have a stated desire to lie and deceive and that is in the way in which they wage war--through drumming up public opinion that pities their plight, even if they started it; and (3) Israel is at war with Palestine, yet they are feeding them, supplying them with energy, etc. Seems like a glaring double standard to accuse them of war crimes and genocide in light of what other nation-states (including ours) have and have not done in other wars.
Edit: Also, (4) Hamas is largely responsible for the starvation because it steals food and resists food aid from the US/Israel source, instead saying it wants it from the UN--who won't agree to have their trucks searched by Israeli forces. In other words, this whole situation is in line with Hamas's strategy of using the Palestinian populace as a sword and shield in its war with Israel--I think it is Hamas who is intentionally starving its own population, then.
The Average Joe Palestinian is caught in an awful place. I feel for them. But I put the blame primarily on Hamas. I think it's odd to hold Israel to a standard of caring more about the average Palestinian than their own elected govt. does, especially since they hate Jews so much.
As I pointed out originally, and then The Guardian also pointed out a day later, even if you ignore Hamas and accept Israel's numbers as accurate, not nearly enough food is going into Gaza to feed everyone. By Israel's own accounting, people are going to succumb to starvation, if they are not already there.
By Israel’s own accounting, people are going to succumb to starvation, if they are not already there.
I've read reports from the Israeli govt that contest this. I admit Israel could be lying or misleading people. From AI:
- Rejection of famine reports: In response to the August 2025 finding of a famine in Gaza City by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the report an "outright lie".
- Basis for rejection: The Coordination of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT), the Israeli military body handling Palestinian civil affairs, claimed the IPC report was based on "unreliable sources" tied to Hamas and that it ignored Israel's recent efforts to surge aid into the enclave.
- Accusations of Hamas interference: Israel has repeatedly accused Hamas of stealing and diverting aid meant for civilians.
- Disputed claims: While Israel points to the need to pressure Hamas as a reason for aid restrictions, a July 2025 US government analysis found no evidence of systematic Hamas theft of US-funded aid. It indicated that most looting was conducted by desperate civilians or smaller, disorganized groups.
- Logistical blame on aid agencies: Israel has blamed the UN and other aid organizations for failing to distribute aid that is already present at border crossings.
- Obstruction claims: Aid agencies counter that Israel's military operations create unsafe distribution conditions and that Israel imposes significant administrative and security restrictions on aid convoys, leading to distribution backlogs.
- Emphasis on Israeli efforts: Israel highlights its role in facilitating aid, citing the total tonnage and number of trucks it has allowed into Gaza since the war began.
- Context of figures: Critics point out that these figures do not provide context regarding the number of daily trucks compared to what is needed, the impact of blockades, or the destruction of internal infrastructure necessary for distribution.
- Implementation of new distribution models:
- Controversial system: Since May 2025, Israel has supported a US-backed private aid group, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), to handle food distribution instead of the UN.
- Condemnation by aid groups: The UN and other agencies have refused to cooperate with the militarized GHF system, which has been criticized as inhumane and ineffective. According to Gaza's health ministry, more than 2,000 Palestinians seeking aid have been killed near GHF sites since May.
- Recent aid increases under pressure: Following international pressure, Israel began allowing more aid into Gaza in late July 2025 through measures like "tactical pauses" and airdrops.
- Continued insufficiencies: Aid agencies report these measures are insufficient to address the crisis, and aid remains far below the levels needed.
- Denial of starvation policy: The Israeli government vehemently denies that starvation is a deliberate policy. Instead, it asserts a policy of actively preventing starvation.
- Warcrime accusations: In contrast, UN officials and rights groups have accused Israel of using starvation as a weapon of war and committing war crimes.
By Israel’s own accounting, people are going to succumb to starvation, if they are not already there.
I've read reports from the Israeli govt that contest this. I admit Israel could be lying or misleading people. From AI:
Israel strongly rejects accusations that it is not allowing enough food into Gaza, claiming instead that it is working to prevent starvation and enable the flow of aid. It blames Hamas and the UN for aid shortages and other distribution issues. The Israeli government also points to its increased aid deliveries in recent weeks, including a new distribution system, but this has been contradicted by aid organizations and reports from the ground.Core Israeli arguments and counterclaims
- Rejection of famine reports: In response to the August 2025 finding of a famine in Gaza City by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the report an "outright lie".
- Basis for rejection: The Coordination of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT), the Israeli military body handling Palestinian civil affairs, claimed the IPC report was based on "unreliable sources" tied to Hamas and that it ignored Israel's recent efforts to surge aid into the enclave.
- Accusations of Hamas interference: Israel has repeatedly accused Hamas of stealing and diverting aid meant for civilians.
- Disputed claims: While Israel points to the need to pressure Hamas as a reason for aid restrictions, a July 2025 US government analysis found no evidence of systematic Hamas theft of US-funded aid. It indicated that most looting was conducted by desperate civilians or smaller, disorganized groups.
- Logistical blame on aid agencies: Israel has blamed the UN and other aid organizations for failing to distribute aid that is already present at border crossings.
- Obstruction claims: Aid agencies counter that Israel's military operations create unsafe distribution conditions and that Israel imposes significant administrative and security restrictions on aid convoys, leading to distribution backlogs.
- Emphasis on Israeli efforts: Israel highlights its role in facilitating aid, citing the total tonnage and number of trucks it has allowed into Gaza since the war began.
- Context of figures: Critics point out that these figures do not provide context regarding the number of daily trucks compared to what is needed, the impact of blockades, or the destruction of internal infrastructure necessary for distribution.
- Implementation of new distribution models:
- Controversial system: Since May 2025, Israel has supported a US-backed private aid group, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), to handle food distribution instead of the UN.
- Condemnation by aid groups: The UN and other agencies have refused to cooperate with the militarized GHF system, which has been criticized as inhumane and ineffective. According to Gaza's health ministry, more than 2,000 Palestinians seeking aid have been killed near GHF sites since May.
- Recent aid increases under pressure: Following international pressure, Israel began allowing more aid into Gaza in late July 2025 through measures like "tactical pauses" and airdrops.
- Continued insufficiencies: Aid agencies report these measures are insufficient to address the crisis, and aid remains far below the levels needed.
- Denial of starvation policy: The Israeli government vehemently denies that starvation is a deliberate policy. Instead, it asserts a policy of actively preventing starvation.
- Warcrime accusations: In contrast, UN officials and rights groups have accused Israel of using starvation as a weapon of war and committing war crimes.
Israel is flat out misleading. They published exactly how much food they distributed. Divide that number by how many people are in Gaza, and the answer is starvation. That's what I did, and that's what the Guardian did. Israel can deny all it wants, but you can't deny math.
Israel is flat out misleading. They published exactly how much food they distributed. Divide that number by how many people are in Gaza, and the answer is starvation. That’s what I did, and that’s what the Guardian did. Israel can deny all it wants, but you can’t deny math.
I think they are disputing whatever numbers the Guardian relied on:
https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-865017
