Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Palestine-Israeli-I...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Palestine-Israeli-Iran War

Page 8 / 22
CarRamRod's avatar
(@carramrod)
Famed Member

@qparker listened to Daryll Copper's podcast on the founding of Israel in 1948 and the decades leading up to it. 

The Zionists had literal terrorist militias going town to town slaughtering Palestinians, to move them out out. That is a piece of history that tends to get glossed over. 

That is so different than any recitation I've heard from Zionists which essentially amounts to " The Israeli's were given this uninhabited land and then all their Muslim neighbors started attacking them"

And I can abide a people subject to decades of pogroms and a holocaust finally saying, "Fuck it, were done abiding by international rules and being subject to the will of our sponsor country". 

I actually think it's commendable. 

What I can't abide by is the idea is that Israeli's are and always have been dealing with Palestinians in good faith. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 10:19 am
👍
1
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

listened to Daryll Copper’s podcast

That scans.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 10:36 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

listened to Daryll Copper’s podcast

That scans.

The substance he mentions is true, though. I don't know how many they killed, though, or how well its documented.    

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/04/2025 11:05 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

@qparker listened to Daryll Copper's podcast on the founding of Israel in 1948 and the decades leading up to it. 

The Zionists had literal terrorist militias going town to town slaughtering Palestinians, to move them out out. That is a piece of history that tends to get glossed over. 

That is so different than any recitation I've heard from Zionists which essentially amounts to " The Israeli's were given this uninhabited land and then all their Muslim neighbors started attacking them"

And I can abide a people subject to decades of pogroms and a holocaust finally saying, "Fuck it, were done abiding by international rules and being subject to the will of our sponsor country". 

I actually think it's commendable. 

What I can't abide by is the idea is that Israeli's are and always have been dealing with Palestinians in good faith. 

Re Cooper, I understand the debate around him but haven't independently verified any of the claims against him.  

This article from Mother Jones (who I always take with a huge grain of salt) is not flattering:

https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2025/07/martyr-made-darryl-cooper-nazi-jews-juggernaut-nihilism-tucker-carlson-joe-rogan-substack/

For example:

Cooper’s suggestion that many Jewish deaths during the Holocaust had been unintentional ended up provoking the largest backlash of his career. . . . 

Since the incident, Cooper has grown bolder. In a Substack post in response to the criticism, Cooper left no doubt he was also talking about Jewish victims of the Holocaust—not only Soviet POWs. He stated that one of his sources was a letter written by Rolf-Heinz Höppner, a senior Nazi official, to Adolf Eichmann in July 1941. “There exists this winter the danger that all the Jews can no longer be fed,” Höppner wrote about 300,000 Jews under his authority, whom he planned to send to a concentration camp. “It should be seriously considered if it would not be the most humane solution to dispose of the Jews, insofar as they are not capable of work, through a quick-acting agent. In any case it would be more pleasant than to let them starve.”

Höppner continued, in a section not included in Cooper’s Substack post: “In addition the proposal was made to sterilize all the female Jews in this camp from whom children could still be expected, so that with this generation the Jewish problem is in fact completely solved.” Nor did Cooper mention the subject line: “Re.: Solution of the Jewish Question.”

The letter from Höppner makes clear Nazi leaders’ willingness to exterminate Jews. But, in Cooper’s telling, it is evidence of how millions of people “ended up” dead and that, as Cooper put it on Substack, a senior Nazi official did not seem “overjoyed at the prospect of mass killing.”

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/04/2025 11:25 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Also, while I don't like digging through people's old social media posts, etc., this is troublesome:

In 2016, a user going by the name “Juggernaut Nihilism” left a comment on a transparently white nationalist website called Counter-Currents.

Public records show that “Juggernaut Nihilism” is part of an email address associated with Cooper. When Juggernaut Nihilism asked goldbugs in the online forums of the TF Metals Report in 2013 whether he should buy a house, the personal details he supplied about his work history and where he lived matched those of Darryl Cooper. David Simon, the creator of The Wire, once attacked Cooper in a Twitter post that began “You go by juggernaut nihilism.” (This was an apparent reference to Cooper’s username on the site at the time.) “No time for scrotes who live in shit & won’t work a shovel,” Simon added.

Cooper did not respond to a detailed list of questions sent to him by Mother Jones, including whether he wrote the comments from Juggernaut Nihilism.

The article Juggernaut Nihilism was responding to on Counter-Currents was written by Colin Liddell. Previously, Liddell had wondered about what the “best and easiest way to dispose of [Blacks]” would be in an essay titled “Is Black Genocide Right?” In the reply, Juggernaut Nihilism took him to task for attacking allies on the far-right who chose not to publicize their racist views. 

“A movement like this needs to operate at various levels, from the intellectual core (that remains terrifying and offensive to the general population right up until the big shift), on up to covert supporters slipping occasional language and subversive information into conversation and normie media,” Juggernaut Nihilism wrote. “Think of how most people you know got here. It wasn’t from basic American ideology to reading Mein Kampf and then, boom, they’re onboard. It’s a process, and you have to initiate people without scaring them off (and without blaming them for being scared off…the human mind works the way it works, and the enemy studies it carefully, controls the education system, and dominates the media).”

Juggernaut Nihilism’s comment reads as an almost perfect encapsulation of Cooper’s work as an amateur revisionist historian. He is highly attuned to when he can operate at which level. He makes it known that he is largely “onboard,” but leaves it up to his followers to surmise just how much. He has read Mein Kampf but is patient with those who have not. 

Two months after the comment appeared, Greg Johnson, the founder of Counter-Currents, posted an interview in which he argued for a white America and aligned himself with the “judeo-critical” wing of the far right on the “Jewish Question.”

“Wow, really great,” Juggernaut Nihilism wrote in response. 

Nine days later, Johnson shared a new interview. It was a podcast with Darryl Cooper. 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/04/2025 11:26 am
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

listened to Daryll Copper’s podcast

That scans.

The substance he mentions is true, though. I don't know how many they killed, though, or how well its documented.    

 

Oh, I know it happened. I mentioned it on the old forum in response to people claiming Palestinians had no historic right to any of the land because they had willingly abandoned it. I'm pretty sure I was accused of being anti-Semitic for bringing it up.

Farva jumping back and forth from attacking Eppy for being a self-described Israeli supporter despite being critical of the current regime to promoting the likes of Darryl Cooper, however, is just absolutely delicious.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 11:45 am
CarRamRod's avatar
(@carramrod)
Famed Member

@goat it’s not a simple issue to solve. Both sides have done a lot of wrong and will never trust each other.

I’m sorry if I don’t have the requisite clarity for you. 

Cooper had a correct diagnoses as far as I can tell. He’s not my favorite historian or one I would necessarily recommend, but I think he was right in this respect. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 11:59 am
Aloha Hoosier's avatar
(@aloha-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

A Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital. Ridiculous.  

Yep. No chance of that happening.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 1:08 pm
Eppy99
(@eppy99)
Prominent Member

@carramrod I agree it's never an easy answer cut and dry.  Without being a historian I'm sure we can name many instances countries, religions, cultures made the decision to go to war to preserve or create a home for their people.  I would think we can look no further then the United States treatment of the Indians.  

This is about survival for a people.  When you've just experienced a Holocaust, been subjected to the Eastern European pogroms it's time to stand up for yourself.  I think many including yourself agree.

I do wish there was a path to peace where there wasn't so much death.  Seems that's a problem since the dawn of time.

Yes, I agree both sides have done wrong and as I've previoulsy mentioned I'm not in favor of the current Israeli governments handling of this situation.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 2:04 pm
👍
1
Eppy99
(@eppy99)
Prominent Member

I also think theres a large faction of Jews in Israel and throughout the diaspora that haven't forgotten the US turned away Jews during WWII.  It's not as if the US just loves Jews and Israel.  There's certainly a strategic reason for the US to supporting Israel. I think at times Israeli's and the government take the stance throughout history we can only trust ourselves.  

I'm not versed enough to suggest what all those strategies might be for the US, but Israel hasn't forgotten the Jews being turned away.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 2:10 pm
Eppy99
(@eppy99)
Prominent Member

@qparker I was hoping you might answer the yes or no question regarding do you deny the existance of the holocaust and the killing of others?  Lets just answer this once and for all.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 2:13 pm
CarRamRod's avatar
(@carramrod)
Famed Member

Posted by: @eppy99
↑

@carramrod I agree it's never an easy answer cut and dry.  Without being a historian I'm sure we can name many instances countries, religions, cultures made the decision to go to war to preserve or create a home for their people.  I would think we can look no further then the United States treatment of the Indians.  

This is about survival for a people.  When you've just experienced a Holocaust, been subjected to the Eastern European pogroms it's time to stand up for yourself.  I think many including yourself agree.

I do wish there was a path to peace where there wasn't so much death.  Seems that's a problem since the dawn of time.

Yes, I agree both sides have done wrong and as I've previoulsy mentioned I'm not in favor of the current Israeli governments handling of this situation.

 

 

It wasn’t war, until it was. Straight up bombing of bus stations. Kidnapping British officers. It was everything you accuse Hamas of being. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 2:49 pm
Eppy99
(@eppy99)
Prominent Member

@carramrod The Irgun were certainly controversial and earned their right to be considered terrorists of the time.  I think it's still reasonable to say post WWII these people were determined to never let Jews again be victims of a Holocaust.   They also were responsible for the bombing of the King David Hotel.  I don't think Israel would have become an independent state in 1948 without the Irgun and Haganah.  Pretty sure they were the first iteration of the IDF.  

If you all have never seen the movie Exodus starring Paul Newman, I'd highly recommend watching it.  It's about the ship Exodus trying to land at Palestine and having to convince the Brits they should be allowed entry.  Essentially a loose telling of Israel becoming a state in 1948.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0053804/?ref_=ext_shr_lnk


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/04/2025 3:04 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @carramrod
↑

@goat it’s not a simple issue to solve. Both sides have done a lot of wrong and will never trust each other.

I’m sorry if I don’t have the requisite clarity for you. 

Cooper had a correct diagnoses as far as I can tell. He’s not my favorite historian or one I would necessarily recommend, but I think he was right in this respect. 

To be clear, he's not a historian at all. 

Of course, neither is Dan Carlin.  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/04/2025 3:16 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @eppy99
↑

I also think theres a large faction of Jews in Israel and throughout the diaspora that haven't forgotten the US turned away Jews during WWII.  It's not as if the US just loves Jews and Israel.  There's certainly a strategic reason for the US to supporting Israel. I think at times Israeli's and the government take the stance throughout history we can only trust ourselves.  

I'm not versed enough to suggest what all those strategies might be for the US, but Israel hasn't forgotten the Jews being turned away.

Is there a safer place on the planet for Jewish people than today's United States? Which nations does "the US . . . love" more than Israel?  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/04/2025 3:21 pm
Page 8 / 22
Share: