@snarlcakes have you checked their population? Have you looked at the numbers of Chinese getting PhDs? From Google's AI:
@arthur-dent in that case it's just a numbers game then. Shouldn't we be more concerned with why Americans aren't having children than allowing in several million legal and illegal immigrants each year? Biden tried it and it didn't go well. Also, it's been a while since the foreign born percentage was as high as it is right now and the results have be lackluster (putting it mildly).
https://twitter.com/geiger_capital/status/1949491577073652055?s=46
@snarlcakes why does it matter? What happened to caring about content of character over race and things like that?
Birth rates in advanced countries around the world are down. Look at Europe, Japan, Russia, even China. China is at an all-time low. It is far more than a US problem. Personally I suspect that at one time we needed large numbers of kids to provide a source of labor for the family. And there is now strong encouragement, often by conservatives, to wait to have children for financial stability. It is hard to afford children at 18. If one has a kid at 32, the number of kids possible is way down.
And damn, are kids ever expensive. Even Mc will agree with that
@arthur-dent we already do that. Rich beneficial people can buy their way in. Eb 5
the amount of $ pouring into these schools is absurd. Privates can figure out a way to handle their endowments in the future. The public ees. Shit. We have them on here posting all day. Cut it.
I'm guessing because the state can tell people what they are going to study, to some degree.@arthur-dent China has very little to no immigration. Why are we having a brain drain, but they aren't? Or will China eventually have one?
I don't think you have to be that deft.@carramrod it requires some deft to tell one group of foreigners "we love you, please come" and another, "you are worthless trash, get out". Deft hasn't been the strong suit to a group that believes anything nice is "woke".
Message: Are you smart? Hard working? Believe in fundamental American values? Or just amazingly beautiful 😀 ? Come on in.
@bradstevens that IS what I support. Buy i see you noted to DBM what led me to my point
We had a poster once make a comment about Soros not being American. He and Musk are as American as I. Some don't seem to accept that. As far as I know, only in being elected president is there a difference. And frankly, we ought to say that anyone is eligible after being an American for 35 years. We CLEARLY are scraping the bottom of the barrel with Americans and that job (including candidates) since 2016.
I believe since she took over, the standard deviation of the jobs numbers has increased significantly. Add to that the increased number of leaks/errors. I think there were like 3-4 in 2024 alone. I remember one late summer last year where some Wall St firms got the numbers earlier than the public.
While revisions do happen often, under her tenure they were WAY off. She really needed to go. Trump should have done it day 1.
How would all of her statisticians follow along? How could they remain silent? Sorry, not buying this at all. This would be a scandal for any other President.
I believe since she took over, the standard deviation of the jobs numbers has increased significantly. Add to that the increased number of leaks/errors. I think there were like 3-4 in 2024 alone. I remember one late summer last year where some Wall St firms got the numbers earlier than the public.
While revisions do happen often, under her tenure they were WAY off. She really needed to go. Trump should have done it day 1.
I'm not saying she or her team fudged numbers. Maybe the WH is saying that. I haven't seen that but it wouldn't surprise me.
I am saying she sucked at her job. It seems she didn't hold her team accountable for maintaining the standards of previous leaders. That can happen by lowering standards, accepting higher error rates, creating a demoralizing work environment, or maybe not properly vetting the data for accuracy. She also didn't have control over the information leaks. To me, she and the leakers should have been fired when that happened.
I'm not sure what made her suck at her job, but she did, and deserved to be fired.
@ribbont I think a lot of economists are captured by groupthink and they lack diversity of opinions in the institutions (not to mention most of them are leftists, which doesn't help).
Take for example tariffs and inflation. Somehow almost every mainstream economists says their inflationary, including Powell. However, they haven't been and they still refuse to change their opinions. Can he fire Powell as well? I kid, I kid. For what it's worth I agree she should have been fired. At some point results need to matter.
@ribbont What leaks? They made their standard monthly reports and their standard revisions the same as BLS has done for decades.
The President is firing her simply because he didn’t like the results found by BLS. It really is as simple, and petty, as that.
Are you referring to Trump's new tariffs? Too early to tell, isn't it?@ribbont I think a lot of economists are captured by groupthink and they lack diversity of opinions in the institutions (not to mention most of them are leftists, which doesn't help).
Take for example tariffs and inflation. Somehow almost every mainstream economists says their inflationary, including Powell. However, they haven't been and they still refuse to change their opinions. Can he fire Powell as well? I kid, I kid. For what it's worth I agree she should have been fired. At some point results need to matter.
Are you referring to Trump's new tariffs? Too early to tell, isn't it?Take for example tariffs and inflation. Somehow almost every mainstream economists says their inflationary, including Powell. However, they haven't been and they still refuse to change their opinions.
Exactly. Many/most haven't kicked in yet. In fact, the inflationary pressures very well may have been delayed by importers front loading their purchases, hoping to avoid the hit that's coming.
