Also the Iroquois had no written language to memorialize their civil system.
Apparently, their Grand Peace Treaty was recorded on wide belts of beads. So they had a form of writing, albeit very rudimentary.
One of the really striking things that you remember when reading about all this stuff, by the way, is that the Native Americans--the entire Western hemisphere, I think--never learned to domesticate large animals, specifically bison. Meanwhile, people in the Near East had domesticated the forerunner to cattle at least 10,000 years ago. Had they, they probably would have also developed the wheel for transport, too, and from there who knows what other technology.
So if we acknowledge that all groups have flaws, this could lead to some interesting discussion. Where it typically goes sideways, is the inability of people to make the distinction between culture & genetics. For example, if I say Muslims in the US have a net negative effect on society, someone will undoubtedly tab me as a racist or a bigot. My stance, however, is based on the opinion that their cultural values not only do not align with ours, they actively seek to diminish things foundational to our country, including the inalienable rights our constitution calls out, not to mention many of them would like to murder us all. How do they strengthen or improve our country? If I state that Somali immigrants have a net negative impact on our society because as a group their IQ is lower (due to many environmental factors) than the existing population, leading to higher crime rates & disproportionate resource drain, what would your counter arguments be as to how specifically they improve our society?
These people don’t want to be Americans, they want to make America something else. Not improve it or add to it, but to take from us & make it their own.
I don't know how to measure this. I will say I have doubts about fundamentalist Muslims, our diversity of thought and religion creates issues.
If it matters, there are Christian White Nationalists that concern me as well. Yes, slightly less but still concerning.
Overall I know there are Muslims that live here, work hard, and are good neighbors. I don't know how to measure their productivity and neighborliness against others.
And I don't want to overrate productivity, humans are more than ledgers in a profit and loss statement.
After Vietnam we brought in a lot of Vietnamese. Also a group that largely came from a totally different culture. But it seems there were a lot of success stories
One of the really striking things that you remember when reading about all this stuff, by the way, is that the Native Americans–the entire Western hemisphere, I think–never learned to domesticate large animals, specifically bison. Meanwhile, people in the Near East had domesticated the forerunner to cattle at least 10,000 years ago. Had they, they probably would have also developed the wheel for transport, too, and from there who knows what other technology.
But they also didn't ride in trains shooting bison simply for the entertainment, so there is a tradeoff. At least for some, being able to domesticate an animal led to a belief slaughtering animals is a fun sport.
So if we acknowledge that all groups have flaws, this could lead to some interesting discussion. Where it typically goes sideways, is the inability of people to make the distinction between culture & genetics. For example, if I say Muslims in the US have a net negative effect on society, someone will undoubtedly tab me as a racist or a bigot. My stance, however, is based on the opinion that their cultural values not only do not align with ours, they actively seek to diminish things foundational to our country, including the inalienable rights our constitution calls out, not to mention many of them would like to murder us all. How do they strengthen or improve our country? If I state that Somali immigrants have a net negative impact on our society because as a group their IQ is lower (due to many environmental factors) than the existing population, leading to higher crime rates & disproportionate resource drain, what would your counter arguments be as to how specifically they improve our society?
These people don’t want to be Americans, they want to make America something else. Not improve it or add to it, but to take from us & make it their own.
I don't know how to measure this. I will say I have doubts about fundamentalist Muslims, our diversity of thought and religion creates issues.
If it matters, there are Christian White Nationalists that concern me as well. Yes, slightly less but still concerning.
Overall I know there are Muslims that live here, work hard, and are good neighbors. I don't know how to measure their productivity and neighborliness against others.
And I don't want to overrate productivity, humans are more than ledgers in a profit and loss statement.
After Vietnam we brought in a lot of Vietnamese. Also a group that largely came from a totally different culture. But it seems there were a lot of success stories
Agreed that some Muslims work hard & are good neighbors, but that will apply to virtually any group. The question is what do they bring to the table to improve our country that is unique to them, if diversity truly is a strength. Same goes for the P&L comment - I have presented my take on the specific negatives, what are the positives?
Edit: Are white Christian nationalists immigrating in large numbers or are you talking about US Citizens? Care to expand on what your concerns are, what they might achieve?
Positive: less demand for pork meaning more and cheaper delicious bacon for us!So if we acknowledge that all groups have flaws, this could lead to some interesting discussion. Where it typically goes sideways, is the inability of people to make the distinction between culture & genetics. For example, if I say Muslims in the US have a net negative effect on society, someone will undoubtedly tab me as a racist or a bigot. My stance, however, is based on the opinion that their cultural values not only do not align with ours, they actively seek to diminish things foundational to our country, including the inalienable rights our constitution calls out, not to mention many of them would like to murder us all. How do they strengthen or improve our country? If I state that Somali immigrants have a net negative impact on our society because as a group their IQ is lower (due to many environmental factors) than the existing population, leading to higher crime rates & disproportionate resource drain, what would your counter arguments be as to how specifically they improve our society?
These people don’t want to be Americans, they want to make America something else. Not improve it or add to it, but to take from us & make it their own.
I don't know how to measure this. I will say I have doubts about fundamentalist Muslims, our diversity of thought and religion creates issues.
If it matters, there are Christian White Nationalists that concern me as well. Yes, slightly less but still concerning.
Overall I know there are Muslims that live here, work hard, and are good neighbors. I don't know how to measure their productivity and neighborliness against others.
And I don't want to overrate productivity, humans are more than ledgers in a profit and loss statement.
After Vietnam we brought in a lot of Vietnamese. Also a group that largely came from a totally different culture. But it seems there were a lot of success stories
Agreed that some Muslims work hard & are good neighbors, but that will apply to virtually any group. The question is what do they bring to the table to improve our country that is unique to them, if diversity truly is a strength. Same goes for the P&L comment - I have presented my take on the specific negatives, what are the positives?
All kidding aside, I have had many Muslim military students from many countries. Many have moved to the states because they really enjoyed their time here as a student. Our interpreters in Afghanistan are in the states now (both were Medical Doctors) and are friends on Facebook. Many of these people are just as anti-terrorism as we are. In fact, aid and programs to prevent terrorism is one of the subjects we taught (we taught the broad category of Security Cooperation). While I agree many are not compatable with American culture there are many exceptions. I'd argue we should do very thorough vetting of Muslims of certain countries (Muslims in Malysia are generally not the same as those in Afghanistan for one comparison example) before allowing them to visit or to eventually become citizens.
We are still just discussing positives that will apply to any group of people, whether it be white Western Europeans or middle Eastern Muslims. Under the guise of “diversity is a strength”, how do more Somalis or ME Muslims make us a better country than if those immigrants were White Europeans?
Ultimately, my point is that diversity should not come at the expense of compatibility or a net positive on our country, yet it seems some disagree, so I’m seeking to understand what I’m not seeing.
Agreed that some Muslims work hard & are good neighbors, but that will apply to virtually any group. The question is what do they bring to the table to improve our country that is unique to them, if diversity truly is a strength. Same goes for the P&L comment – I have presented my take on the specific negatives, what are the positives?
Edit: Are white Christian nationalists immigrating in large numbers or are you talking about US Citizens? Care to expand on what your concerns are, what they might achieve?
I believe the current plan is to bring a total of 7500 legally into the country next year, the vast majority South African. South Africans, of either race, have not proven to be totally accepting of a pluralistic society. I would argue they are primed to become White Christian Nationalists. Now, White Nationalists in this country tend toward claiming Christian, but I wouldn't want White Agnostic Nationalists any more. Nor Black Nationalists, another possible group but much smaller.
Much of this fits why I don't know fundamentalist Muslims work. At the end of the day the American philosophy is it doesn't matter your race, what God you worship (if any), or where you came from. Like the Stripes comment, we are all mutts and have been kicked out of every decent country.
https://www.google.com/www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy40jj71243o
I love the Civil War even though it has like 7 times more words by Shelby Foote than anyone else, and Foote spends a fair amount of time espousing the Lost Cause myth. I disagree with that myth. That said, Foote too is a hell of a story teller.
https://youtube.com/shorts/NNw9jY2OZPw?si=AOdJB0-JGAH4W4dM
That is different from remembering them for who they were.
What does this even mean? How should we tell the story of a slave during the revolution without remembering the fact that they were, you know, a slave?
One of the really striking things that you remember when reading about all this stuff, by the way, is that the Native Americans--the entire Western hemisphere, I think--never learned to domesticate large animals, specifically bison. Meanwhile, people in the Near East had domesticated the forerunner to cattle at least 10,000 years ago. Had they, they probably would have also developed the wheel for transport, too, and from there who knows what other technology.
They domesticated plenty of other animals, though, so they clearly understood the concept. It's probably simply that the buffalo wasn't really domesticable. And without that or horses, did the Americas have another potential option for a reliable draft animal? I can't think of any. Without a draft animal, agricultural production hits a ceiling based on humans' physical limitations, which leaves less available man hours for developing other technologies.
So, yeah, I guess I'm agreeing with you, just adding the caveat that it probably wasn't their fault. It was simply that buffalo are assholes and all the horses died right when people arrived. Of course, if the people killed all the horses, maybe it was their fault.
Agreed that some Muslims work hard & are good neighbors, but that will apply to virtually any group. The question is what do they bring to the table to improve our country that is unique to them, if diversity truly is a strength. Same goes for the P&L comment – I have presented my take on the specific negatives, what are the positives?
Edit: Are white Christian nationalists immigrating in large numbers or are you talking about US Citizens? Care to expand on what your concerns are, what they might achieve?
I believe the current plan is to bring a total of 7500 legally into the country next year, the vast majority South African. South Africans, of either race, have not proven to be totally accepting of a pluralistic society. I would argue they are primed to become White Christian Nationalists. Now, White Nationalists in this country tend toward claiming Christian, but I wouldn't want White Agnostic Nationalists any more. Nor Black Nationalists, another possible group but much smaller.
Much of this fits why I don't know fundamentalist Muslims work. At the end of the day the American philosophy is it doesn't matter your race, what God you worship (if any), or where you came from. Like the Stripes comment, we are all mutts and have been kicked out of every decent country.
https://www.google.com/www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy40jj71243o
Why would any Christian American be for Muslim immigration? Christians shouldn't be promoting and helping spread Islam and the worshiping of false gods. Muslins literally worship a child molester.
I think the forerunner to cattle were supposed to be ornery, too, but those Near East ancients had Want To.One of the really striking things that you remember when reading about all this stuff, by the way, is that the Native Americans--the entire Western hemisphere, I think--never learned to domesticate large animals, specifically bison. Meanwhile, people in the Near East had domesticated the forerunner to cattle at least 10,000 years ago. Had they, they probably would have also developed the wheel for transport, too, and from there who knows what other technology.
They domesticated plenty of other animals, though, so they clearly understood the concept. It's probably simply that the buffalo wasn't really domesticable. And without that or horses, did the Americas have another potential option for a reliable draft animal? I can't think of any. Without a draft animal, agricultural production hits a ceiling based on humans' physical limitations, which leaves less available man hours for developing other technologies.
So, yeah, I guess I'm agreeing with you, just adding the caveat that it probably wasn't their fault. It was simply that buffalo are assholes and all the horses died right when people arrived. Of course, if the people killed all the horses, maybe it was their fault.
Calling them buffalo and not bison?
Agreed that some Muslims work hard & are good neighbors, but that will apply to virtually any group. The question is what do they bring to the table to improve our country that is unique to them, if diversity truly is a strength. Same goes for the P&L comment – I have presented my take on the specific negatives, what are the positives?
Edit: Are white Christian nationalists immigrating in large numbers or are you talking about US Citizens? Care to expand on what your concerns are, what they might achieve?
I believe the current plan is to bring a total of 7500 legally into the country next year, the vast majority South African. South Africans, of either race, have not proven to be totally accepting of a pluralistic society. I would argue they are primed to become White Christian Nationalists. Now, White Nationalists in this country tend toward claiming Christian, but I wouldn't want White Agnostic Nationalists any more. Nor Black Nationalists, another possible group but much smaller.
Much of this fits why I don't know fundamentalist Muslims work. At the end of the day the American philosophy is it doesn't matter your race, what God you worship (if any), or where you came from. Like the Stripes comment, we are all mutts and have been kicked out of every decent country.
https://www.google.com/www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy40jj71243o
Why would any Christian American be for Muslim immigration?


