For more on the Iroquis dispute re the founders following their example. This guy saw/heard the same thing I noted and goes on to show how the Trump admin has actually bought into it in some fashion. LOL:
https://substack.com/inbox/post/179642727?triedRedirect=true
And this is an in-depth look at the merits:
https://williamhogeland.substack.com/p/did-the-iroquois-really-influence
@oneeyedundertaker I think you will also find evidence the Brits said the French were engaged in cannibalism in North America. It was a charge that galvanized people.
Or maybe the French were cannibals, anyone that eats snails needs to be watched.
You’re sidestepping the real issue here, why is it so difficult for some of you to admit these brown people had flaws & they don’t detract from the great things the did? Be careful or Aloha will call you a snowflake…
Certainly they had flaws. I say this repeatedly, no one was perfect.
I will also say I am not in the camp that diversity is a weakness that many say. Yet so far no one has pointed out the groups that make us weak. Is it our Scots-Irish living alongside Germans? Protestants and Catholics? What groups cause us to be weakened by diversity. So many say we cannot be like Scandanavia or Japan because we are diverse but they refuse to say why.
Laudable objective.
Poor planning.
Poorer execution.
All of that was a flaw because a successful operation would certainly have changed the course of history.
You're bringing present day politics into this discussion. So are you admitting that Burns's reframing is an attempt to strengthen the diversity-is-our-strength argument?I will also say I am not in the camp that diversity is a weakness that many say. Yet so far no one has pointed out the groups that make us weak. Is it our Scots-Irish living alongside Germans? Protestants and Catholics? What groups cause us to be weakened by diversity.
As for groups that make the United States social fabric weaker, I'd answer those illiberals on both sides who influence public debate.
Go on further to 2:10 and onward and Burns clearly implies that Franklin made his famous cartoon and call for union based directly on the Iroquois.
It is not my fault you infer that. He never says the US is based on the Iroquois. There are some similarities, they had federalism, we had federalism. He had a quote about never falling out one against another, and he later shows our join or die cartoon. Again, similarities but not cause and effect. You read it as cause and effect.
Yes, he had a goal to show that the Natives had constitutional law, they had diplomacy, they had international trade. All that is way to unknown for many Americans.
Correlation is not causation. I have been back through that a couple of times. Tell me the exact words that Burns uses to say causation.
I really thought his point that the colonists were out from the beginning to take Native lands would anger people, not his point that Natives were capable of having what amounts to a constitutional federalist Republic. And yes, the clan mothers selected the leaders so it isn't a democracy like we think today. But also not far from the landed White males that we used in our beginning.
If you want to suggest he infers too much, I accept that. But that hasn't been what is said. He does not say the Iroquois Confederacy created the join or die flag, he does not say our government is based on them. I think he is saying that Natives were our equals in many ways but the way it is said makes it easy to believe he is saying those things.
Do people arguing against me dispute that Natives and Whites were/are equal? Both had warts, some the same and some different. I would argue they didn't have democracy, but I would argue we didn't either for the exact same reason.But it isn't like we brought political theory to the Natives, nor taught them to feed themselves, wear clothes, you know, civilize them.
We Whites did not bring democracy, federalism, the law, to North America. It was here. What happens in the Revolution will have a tremendous impact on those things that were already here.
Burns isn't a saint, he is a damn good story teller. I love the Civil War even though it has like 7 times more words by Shelby Foote than anyone else, and Foote spends a fair amount of time espousing the Lost Cause myth. I disagree with that myth. That said, Foote too is a hell of a story teller. I have several of his books. He gave a presentation saying historians should write more like fiction authors, more concerned about pacing, wording prose. He thought presenting history as boring and dry is why people don't like history. I think he was right. But if that epic was mine, less time would be given to Foote and more to McPherson whose opinion on that war is closer to mine.
Below is the view of that series from someone else. I think it is clear that I have no love for the Lost Cause, but I also don't think presenting Lee as kind is in any way a problem. I would have scaled back Foote some, or presented more McPherson to compensate, but it is an artistic choice he made. I trust people can see that series and not decide the war had almost nothing to do with slavery. Just as I trust people can see the Revolution and not think we are based on Native philosophy.
Second link below takes the view that the author, as a White Southerner loved the series in his youth but realized later it went way too easy on White Southerners. Interesting given the belief Burns is a race-baiting leftist.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/why-we-need-new-civil-war-documentary-180971996/
It is not my fault you infer that. He never says the US is based on the Iroquois. There are some similarities, they had federalism, we had federalism. He had a quote about never falling out one against another, and he later shows our join or die cartoon. Again, similarities but not cause and effect. You read it as cause and effect.
Yes, he had a goal to show that the Natives had constitutional law, they had diplomacy, they had international trade. All that is way to unknown for many Americans.
Correlation is not causation. I have been back through that a couple of times. Tell me the exact words that Burns uses to say causation.
Of course it's not your fault. It's Burns's fault. If you can't see that he did that intentionally, I don't know what to tell you. I'm a lawyer--I can tell you that's exactly how you try to get people to infer something without ever saying flat out there was causation.Read the substacks I linked. If you think what Burns did is just a coincidence, you're incredibly naive--especially given the statements he's already made about his intentions with this series.
And I notice you're still dodging the "centuries of democracy" lie.
I don't know if you're intending to do it, but you keep lumping me in with everyone who has offered a criticism of the series, and as I've said, that's complete horseshit. I have no problem acknowledging some Native American tribes had sophisticated governing apparatus. I do have a problem sneakily insinuating something that there is very little, if any, proof for in a widely watched series, funded by public dollars, to advance a current political argument. That's it. If you want to read racism or white supremacy or Eurocentrism into that, that's a you problem.
"We Whites."We Whites did not bring democracy, federalism, the law, to North America. It was here. What happens in the Revolution will have a tremendous impact on those things that were already here.
Rick Atkinson is used in the series and he has 2/3rds of a trilogy out on the Revolution and it is outstanding. A buddy whose doctoral thesis was on the Revolution loved the first book, sadly passed before the second. And he was very much a conservative, so don't fear my endorsement.
Atkinson also wrote a trilogy on WW2 in Europe that was brilliant. The first book was on North Africa, second on Italy, third on Western Europe. Online discussions on that trilogy reminds me of the discussion here. The books are on the US-British alliance in the war. So very little mention of Russia. It drives Europeans crazy claiming it is far too pro-American and portrays us as winning the war single-handedly. The thing is, it isn't a comprehensive view of the war. It doesn't portray America as winning the war single-handedly, it just portrays how Britain and America fought together. I find their criticism to be like me reading a book on F1 and complaining it portrays the F1 as the only car races in the world.
So if you want to read so.e great history, read Atkinson's books.
And I notice you’re still dodging the “centuries of democracy” lie.
I addressed it. I said it was wrong but that having mother's choose leaders isn't that different than saying only property owning White males can choose leaders, which is what the US had and we still claim a democracy. Both are either right or wrong, you choose. But be consistent. Were we a democracy? If so, they were. If not, they were not
Of course it’s not your fault. It’s Burns’s fault. If you can’t see that he did that intentionally, I don’t know what to tell you. I’m a lawyer–I can tell you that’s exactly how you try to get people to infer something without ever saying flat out there was causation.Read the substacks I linked. If you think what Burns did is just a coincidence, you’re incredibly naive–especially given the statements he’s already made about his intentions with this series.
Ken Burns comes to you and says he a wants Americans to know a constitutional government existed in the same land as the US before the Revolution. Do you object.
Should he tack that in at the end, "oh, by the way, a constitutional government called the Iroquois Confederacy was here during all the previous events, thanks for watching."
Does he put it at the beginning, but with a disclaimer. "All that you saw on the Iroquois is not meant to imply that anything you have seen in any way influenced any events in our founding."
I do not see any evidence their federalism influenced our, but they had it. I do not see any evidence their prohibition against having two positions influenced ours, but they had it. I see no evidence their impeachment clause influenced ours, but they had it. It is very possible we came on those ideas totally independently. It is also possible we were aware of those and they had some influence. I can't totally discount that for a reason. How many American leaders do you think would gain popularity in the late 1700s by saying, "we are taking this from the Iroquois?" Do you think that would be a positive selling point?
So in my mind, both are possible. In all probability people like Madison knew they had federalism. At a minimum nothing in the Confederacy scared Madison off from federalism.
But back to the first point, how does a story teller divorce the idea that there was a functioning constitutional government here already from the rest of the story without saying, "now, nevermind that as it plays no role in anything." At that point you aren't really telling an entertaining story
You're right that the 18th Century version of democracy was more limited than now.And I notice you’re still dodging the “centuries of democracy” lie.
I addressed it. I said it was wrong but that having mother's choose leaders isn't that different than saying only property owning White males can choose leaders, which is what the US had and we still claim a democracy. Both are either right or wrong, you choose. But be consistent. Were we a democracy? If so, they were. If not, they were not
Re the Iroquis, from what I'm reading, it's complicated. You write "mother's choose leaders." But tt wasn't every mother of a child that got to decide, it was a clan mother. For your analogy to hold, the US system would have allowed only the oldest white male in a village or town to vote to choose leaders. And once chosen, titles passed based on hereditary grounds along the female line but to men. Is that a democracy?
I think to better understand it, you'd have to delve into their culture and the interactions and influence of the typical Iroqouis on the clan mother's choices. Again, context matters. Warts and all. For example, I'm guessing the Iroquois did not consider the legitimacy of their system as being based on the consent of the governed, but on some combination of tradition, maybe some supernatural conveyance, group identity and preservation, etc. That, too, would be a big difference that would lead to practical differences in governance, individual freedoms, and definitional accuracy. Counter to that might be the fact that some tribes gathered and would hold meetings and try to build consensus to make big decisions. We have little, though, to go on to test how those meetings might have taken place and if popular will really was what was driving things.
And notice, this is NOT the system we adopted. That doesn't make it better or worse, but it does matter if you make the claim that the US system is somehow derivative of the Iroquois one.
@
@oneeyedundertaker I think you will also find evidence the Brits said the French were engaged in cannibalism in North America. It was a charge that galvanized people.
Or maybe the French were cannibals, anyone that eats snails needs to be watched.
You’re sidestepping the real issue here, why is it so difficult for some of you to admit these brown people had flaws & they don’t detract from the great things the did? Be careful or Aloha will call you a snowflake…
Certainly they had flaws. I say this repeatedly, no one was perfect.
I will also say I am not in the camp that diversity is a weakness that many say. Yet so far no one has pointed out the groups that make us weak. Is it our Scots-Irish living alongside Germans? Protestants and Catholics? What groups cause us to be weakened by diversity. So many say we cannot be like Scandanavia or Japan because we are diverse but they refuse to say why.
So if we acknowledge that all groups have flaws, this could lead to some interesting discussion. Where it typically goes sideways, is the inability of people to make the distinction between culture & genetics. For example, if I say Muslims in the US have a net negative effect on society, someone will undoubtedly tab me as a racist or a bigot. My stance, however, is based on the opinion that their cultural values not only do not align with ours, they actively seek to diminish things foundational to our country, including the inalienable rights our constitution calls out, not to mention many of them would like to murder us all. How do they strengthen or improve our country? If I state that Somali immigrants have a net negative impact on our society because as a group their IQ is lower (due to many environmental factors) than the existing population, leading to higher crime rates & disproportionate resource drain, what would your counter arguments be as to how specifically they improve our society?
These people don’t want to be Americans, they want to make America something else. Not improve it or add to it, but to take from us & make it their own.
@arthur-dent Easy. Don't open the series with it. Don't immediately jump from the [false] description of a "flourishing democracy" and out of context quote about sticking together to Franklin's cartoon and Join or Die advocacy. Or keep it all in and have a simple transition sentence or two like this:
"Historians disagree about the extent the Iroquios system acted as a democracy and to what degree their system might have influenced later American founding documents or causes. There is little evidence connecting the two. But as early as the 1750s (or 60's), Benjamin Franklin had championed a similar idea of joining together to defeat a common enemy."
Serious and honest question: does Burns EVER discuss historians disagreeing about anything in this series?
By the way, do you realize just how inconsistent this narrative is with the rest of the narratives about that founding generation? We are told these guys were incredibly racist, incredibly white supremacist, incredibly misogynist and male centered. They are Enlightenment dudes, really wrapped up in "Reason," and philosophy, and science, and reading a ton. Yet we are to believe they secretly really loved the ideas and systems of a people they called savages and who were not white, not Christian, who had set up a system with women making a lot of the big decisions, who had no in-depth writings to back it up, justify it, etc. and so copied their governmental system, rather than follow the ideas of the English common law, Magna Carta, etc. that they all were steeped in, read and wrote about incessantly, and had real life experience dealing with? Sorry, I just find that very implausible without actual strong evidence to back it up.
I would think that anything similar to the Bill of Rights would be DOA with the Iroquois. Also the Iroquois had no written language to memorialize their civil system. I have a lot of trouble seeing any important and relevant connection.

