Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Iran War Has Starte...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Iran War Has Started

Page 129 / 198
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @twenty
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑

Trump badly underestimated the resolve (and firepower) of the crazy and malevolent IRGC.

"Iran retains about 75 percent of its prewar inventories of mobile launchers and about 70 percent of its prewar stockpiles of missiles, a U.S. official said. The official said there is evidence that the regime has been able to recover and reopen almost all of its underground storage facilities, repair some damaged missiles and even assemble some new missiles that were nearly complete when the war began."

"One of the U.S. officials who spoke to The Washington Post said they thought Iran’s capacity to endure prolonged economic hardship is far greater than even the CIA estimate. 'The leadership has gotten more radical, determined and increasingly confident they can outlast U.S. political will and sustain domestic repression to check any resistance' inside Iran, the official said. 'Comparatively, you see similar regimes lasting years under sustained embargoes and airpower-only wars.'”

U.S. intelligence says Iran can outlast Trump’s blockade for months - The Washington Post

 

https://twitter.com/SpencerGuard/status/2053587830123978997

 

 

So we spent $25-50B to "mow the lawn" and now go back to living with the same regime? Nobody should be convinced that's a strategic win.

 

 

Are we considering this a success only if there is complete capitulation? Are we considering it a success for Iran if all they do is survive?

 

False dichotomy. There's a universe of possibilities between Twenty's phrasing and yours.

We don't need regime change to claim a victory. But we certainly need a helluva lot more than just a temporary disruption to their strategic capabilities.

 

If you agree Iran cannot have nuclear weapons, what more need be done and can we accomplish it without boots on the ground?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/13/2026 8:27 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @twenty
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑

Trump badly underestimated the resolve (and firepower) of the crazy and malevolent IRGC.

"Iran retains about 75 percent of its prewar inventories of mobile launchers and about 70 percent of its prewar stockpiles of missiles, a U.S. official said. The official said there is evidence that the regime has been able to recover and reopen almost all of its underground storage facilities, repair some damaged missiles and even assemble some new missiles that were nearly complete when the war began."

"One of the U.S. officials who spoke to The Washington Post said they thought Iran’s capacity to endure prolonged economic hardship is far greater than even the CIA estimate. 'The leadership has gotten more radical, determined and increasingly confident they can outlast U.S. political will and sustain domestic repression to check any resistance' inside Iran, the official said. 'Comparatively, you see similar regimes lasting years under sustained embargoes and airpower-only wars.'”

U.S. intelligence says Iran can outlast Trump’s blockade for months - The Washington Post

 

https://twitter.com/SpencerGuard/status/2053587830123978997

 

 

So we spent $25-50B to "mow the lawn" and now go back to living with the same regime? Nobody should be convinced that's a strategic win.

 

 

Are we considering this a success only if there is complete capitulation? Are we considering it a success for Iran if all they do is survive?

 

False dichotomy. There's a universe of possibilities between Twenty's phrasing and yours.

We don't need regime change to claim a victory. But we certainly need a helluva lot more than just a temporary disruption to their strategic capabilities.

 

If you agree Iran cannot have nuclear weapons, what more need be done and can we accomplish it without boots on the ground?

 

I don't know. I think the JCPOA was a good start, though flawed. I think backing away from it made us less safe. But that's water under the bridge now. What I do know - or rather strongly suspect - is that our current war has done little to nothing to hinder Iranian attempts at the bomb, and has almost certainly strengthened their desire for it. So if nuclear capability is the measuring stick, I'm doubtful this war will be deemed a success long term.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/13/2026 9:19 pm
Ginger Martin's avatar
(@gingerkitten)
Active Member

Should we use military force to disarm them or should we just wash our hands of it and walk away? 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/13/2026 11:29 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@goat 

I dont understand any of this.  The bombs used for Midnight Hammer were built for that purpose.  We never backed away from that use. Obama’s JCPOA accomplished nothing and was the product of Obama’s desperation to do something. 

Midnight Hammer destroyed much infrastructure, but it didn’t destroy the Mullahs desires to build a bomb.  While we delivered a serious blow, the Mullahs didn’t abandon their bomb desires.  When negotiations stalled, or maybe failed, we struck again and now we are where we are.  I don’t understand the democrats who claim the current pause reflects a stalemate,  there is no stalemate.  We and Israel can deliver a mortal blow at a time of our choosing.  The issue now is how to deal with the certain destruction of Iran’s economy and how to balance that burden with a no nukes objective.  The Islamic minds will need to somehow change.  .  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 12:33 am
😂
1
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

@co-hoosier what fatal blow fo we have? I will stipulate that we have nukes that would be a fatal blow, even I don't think Trump is crazy enough to use them. So what can we do that would be fatal?


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 6:59 am
👍
1
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member
Butch Crawling's avatar
(@big-ryan)
Famed Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

@co-hoosier what fatal blow fo we have? I will stipulate that we have nukes that would be a fatal blow, even I don't think Trump is crazy enough to use them. So what can we do that would be fatal?

The other poster's comments reflect a lack of understanding of the geopolitical situation. 

Trump took a lot of heat, from Republican legislators to the Pope, for his "a whole civilization will die tonight" threat.  There was a lot of talk about that genocidal rhetoric, and some experts opined that the threat itself was a war crime under international law (the Geneva Conventions and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court) 

Trump's crazy, but even he has limits as you've indicated.  He doesn't want the label of war criminal damaging what I'm sure he believes is an otherwise stellar reputation and legacy.

The other issue is the enriched uranium.  That's what Trump wants, but Iran's not inclined to surrender it.  In fact, according to Trump, Iran claims they're now unable to physically get to it.  Trump can't get it without boots on the ground, and boots on the ground would mean US servicemember casualties. No one in the US wants that.  He definitely needs Iran's cooperation on denuclearization, and apocalyptic attacks with mass civilian casualties are not a great motivator for cooperation. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 8:24 am
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @twenty
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑
If you agree Iran cannot have nuclear weapons, what more need be done and can we accomplish it without boots on the ground?
Iran not building or having nukes are different goals. Iran will have nukes if we continue to think we can force others to behave according to our wishes. 

The modern civilized world is a delicate and fragile agreement between an anarchy of nations. I’ve often wondered about the vulnerability of undersea internet cables. I had no idea some run through Hormuz. This highlights just one of many aspects of the tentative nature of our modern international system. Like it or not, civilization is built on mutual trust and respect. Terrorists of all sorts have shown asymmetrical destruction can threaten our way of life. The USA is the greatest and thus has the most to lose. The only reason Iran has yet to snip a cable is they hold on to some threads of hope they can continue in the world. Trump threatens to stone age them into oblivion. That would take away any motivation to not snip the cables. No doubt there are other asymmetric ways to wreak havoc. 
Force will no longer solve the problem. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 8:44 am
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@big-ryan 

Trump’s problem is that despite decades of presidents from both parties saying “no nukes for Iran” that was mostly bluster.   There is a groundswell in this country that say “nukes for Iran are Okay”.  When it comes down to paying the price for no nukes, we blink.  The JCPOA which guaranteed perpetual conflict was acceptable.

https://www.breitbart.com/clips/2026/05/13/tim-kaine-the-senate-will-vote-to-end-this-war/

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 9:11 am
😂
1
Butch Crawling's avatar
(@big-ryan)
Famed Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@big-ryan 

Trump’s problem is that despite decades of presidents from both parties saying “no nukes for Iran” that was mostly bluster.   There is a groundswell in this country that say “nukes for Iran are Okay”.  When it comes down to paying the price for no nukes, we blink.  The JCPOA which guaranteed perpetual conflict was acceptable.

https://www.breitbart.com/clips/2026/05/13/tim-kaine-the-senate-will-vote-to-end-this-war/

 

The JCPOA had limitations (including sunset provisions) but there was verified compliance and it was effectively limiting Iran's nuclear program.  It was certainly better than nothing, which was what we were left with after Trump tore it up because he hates Obama. (Trump still posts awful lies about him regularly).  

Trump, our "No New Wars!" president, is learning on the job about the unique challenges the US faces in dealing with this fanatical regime.  Tactical advantage doesn't always carry the day.  Iran has all kinds of leverage that Trump either didn't understand or chose to ignore.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 9:32 am
Aloha Hoosier's avatar
(@aloha-hoosier)
Famed Member
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Iran will have nukes if we continue to think we can force others to behave according to our wishes. 

I'm not sure that's right.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 4:51 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@goat 

I dont understand any of this.  The bombs used for Midnight Hammer were built for that purpose.  We never backed away from that use. Obama’s JCPOA accomplished nothing and was the product of Obama’s desperation to do something. 

Midnight Hammer destroyed much infrastructure, but it didn’t destroy the Mullahs desires to build a bomb.  While we delivered a serious blow, the Mullahs didn’t abandon their bomb desires.  When negotiations stalled, or maybe failed, we struck again and now we are where we are.  I don’t understand the democrats who claim the current pause reflects a stalemate,  there is no stalemate.  We and Israel can deliver a mortal blow at a time of our choosing.  The issue now is how to deal with the certain destruction of Iran’s economy and how to balance that burden with a no nukes objective.  The Islamic minds will need to somehow change.  .  

 

Other than your reflexive desire to attack Obama, you are basically agreeing with me, so I don't see why you are having trouble understanding.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 4:53 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @aloha-hoosier
↑

A few for those interested:

There's this along with another article I read yesterday that reported that Israel has sent Iron Dome systems and Israeli operators to the UAE. Netanyahu says he secretly visited UAE during Iran war; UAE denies it | The Times of Israel

Tensions flare near Strait of Hormuz as a ship is seized and another is sunk

South Korea official says unlikely anyone but Iran behind Hormuz ship attack, Yonhap reports

U.S. Intelligence Shows Iran Retains Substantial Missile Capabilities - The New York Times

Republican resistance to Iran war grows as Murkowski flips | AP News

Energy secretary: Iran ‘frighteningly close’ to nuclear weapon despite Operation Epic Fury

The military times article is the scariest.  Blame Trump all you want, but the reality is: we are in this war. We aren't getting back in Iran's good graces ever again as long as the theocratic regime continues to rule that nation. So do we stop now and try diplomacy when they are so close to a bomb or do we send troops in?  I, personally, do not want Iran to possess a bomb and this all appears to be much more dangerous and much closer to fruition than Iraq's possession of one was.  

Zero good options here.  Need to pick the least worst one.  None of us have the intel to do that. Hell, our leaders (including all the higher up adults at all the intelligence and military institutions) probably can't handicap the odds well enough to make a really informed decision.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 5:22 pm
👍
1
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

@goat 

He's linking Breitbart, for fucks sake. His decent into madness is nearly complete. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 05/14/2026 5:43 pm
👍
1
Page 129 / 198
Share: