Bingo. Just a slight nod to this would buy a lot of goodwill. Current options are self-flagellation or total whitewash. Maddening.
I don’t understand this point. Are you really saying that a perpetual public apology for the past sins of slavery is required? How would we publish such a “slight nod” to make it meaningful?
@co-hoosier you’re going too far back coh. A slight nod would be to acknowledge blacks have been denied the same economic opportunities during YOUR lifetime. So as we crack down on crime we recognize this imbalance and want to invest in communities and people. And do so. The problem is we don’t want to give it to the same people who have had worthless programs and pissed away resources. How we get more competent people into those roles I don’t know. They’re usually social workers and shit. Not to be a dick but not exactly the A team
@co-hoosier you’re going too far back coh. A slight nod would be to acknowledge blacks have been denied the same economic opportunities during YOUR lifetime. So as we crack down on crime we recognize this imbalance and want to invest in communities and people. And do so. The problem is we don’t want to give it to the same people who have had worthless programs and pissed away resources. How we get more competent people into those roles I don’t know. They’re usually social workers and shit. Not to be a dick but not exactly the A team
It's more than that. There is much higher number of white households that live in poverty vs black households in this country yet there is no white violent crime epidemic. Obviously a higher percentage of black households live in poverty but numbers wise it's not close.
Look at JD Vance. Essentially grew up in a trailer park raised by his chain smoking redneck grandmother. Never knew his Dad and his mother was a heroine addict yet he rose above it and graduated from Yale Law. You're just making excuses.
There are tons of white people that grow up in some of worst conditions imaginable (think Appalachia) yet they don't grow up to commit violent crimes.
you’re going too far back coh. A slight nod would be to acknowledge blacks have been denied the same economic opportunities during YOUR lifetime.
I have given that slight nod and more whenever it was appropriate, including in this thread. Do you think the multiple slight nods have been turned into excuses for bad educations, crime, drugs etc.? The slight nods don’t appear to provide an incentive to do better.
I'm with COH here. I don't understand how anyone could say the US as a nation or a culture hasn't been giving quite a bit more than a slight nod since the 1960s.Bingo. Just a slight nod to this would buy a lot of goodwill. Current options are self-flagellation or total whitewash. Maddening.
I don’t understand this point. Are you really saying that a perpetual public apology for the past sins of slavery is required? How would we publish such a “slight nod” to make it meaningful?
It's like people are just ignoring the civil rights era, the Great Society, the War on Poverty, affirmative action, DEI, social welfare programs, etc. Via all these social programs, paid for through a progressive tax system--that if we are going to analyze in crude black v. white terms--white people have transferred billions, maybe trillions of dollars to black people.
@bradstevens it's not working. and in my view much of it is because social workers are indoctrinated and simply not very bright. mean to say but i have spent enough time with them to have an opinion. it's time for a new approach and the nod that mapletom references could come with same. aggressive policing and sentencing with a new approach to funding.
incidentally im not a huge reparations guy but i'm not totally opposed under the right conditions. biden used covid as a pretense to give out free cheese. after biden gave out all of that free cheese the poverty rate hit the lowest level in i can't remember how long. long time. now it was fckd bc things weren't means tested and bc everyone got dough and stayed home ordering amazon inflation skyrocketed BUT under a means tested proper set of conditions it MAY work.
i've used this example in the past. we spend a fortune on our train. it's full of crackheads and drug dealers. and it doesn't go to 90 percennt of the places in the metro area. so if you want a job you have to either get one near the train line or take the train and thirty buses. if you have kids and shit it's not tenable. however if you had an extra $500 a month for a car that other 90 percent of the places in the metro would become available to you for work. and you get a better job. and drive to be there for your kids. etc.
i'm not sure gov programs and earmarking more money to just create more government, which is all these programs are, is the best path. maybe just giving people money. some of this stuff was kicked around, tried, etc. during clinton's years. you'd get it and had to prove you were employed, seeking, came with end dates, etc.
I agree it's not working. And I agree that we should be concerned with the plight of the downtrodden and try to help them make their lives better. 1000%.@bradstevens it's not working. and in my view much of it is because social workers are indoctrinated and simply not very bright. mean to say but i have spent enough time with them to have an opinion. it's time for a new approach and the nod that mapletom references could come with same. aggressive policing and sentencing with a new approach to funding.
incidentally im not a huge reparations guy but i'm not totally opposed under the right conditions. biden used covid as a pretense to give out free cheese. after biden gave out all of that free cheese the poverty rate hit the lowest level in i can't remember how long. long time. now it was fckd bc things weren't means tested and bc everyone got dough and stayed home ordering amazon inflation skyrocketed BUT under a means tested proper set of conditions it MAY work.
i've used this example in the past. we spend a fortune on our train. it's full of crackheads and drug dealers. and it doesn't go to 90 percennt of the places in the metro area. so if you want a job you have to either get one near the train line or take the train and thirty buses. if you have kids and shit it's not tenable. however if you had an extra $500 a month for a car that other 90 percent of the places in the metro would become available to you for work. and you get a better job. and drive to be there for your kids. etc.
i'm not sure gov programs and earmarking more money to just create more government, which is all these programs are, is the best path. maybe just giving people money. some of this stuff was kicked around, tried, etc. during clinton's years. you'd get it and had to prove you were employed, seeking, came with end dates, etc.
I believe that because those people are human beings just like I'm a human being, and my kids are human beings, etc. and I can empathize with their situation. Bringing the race stuff into it, IMHO, doesn't help and only harms the political ability to start or fund the needed programs though. In addition, always concentrating on disparate impact without looking deeper is never going to discover the root cause of anything.
@bradstevens race is woven into the circumstance in a way that is unique. if i'm some poor bloke in mcdowell co wv my condition may be no different than that of some brother in the hood. probably less dangerous but equal in terms of being broke and opportunity challenges. but what contributed to, not gave rise to, but contributed to, is different. the poor dude in app can say well i'm a dumbshit. and my daddy was a dumbshit. and my granddaddy was a dumbshit. i guess it's just the family curse. there's no extrinsic governmental reason. oppressive laws etc. and that is an important distinction. so you can't take race out of it and giving a nod to our recognition of same isnt a bad thing.
at the end all of this is of no moment tho. dems elect their own. who won't subscribe to this stuff. and pubs move to the burbs and don't give a shit. but whatever
"safe". they just don't kill each other but drug addiction and child/spousal abuse is just as high. If not higher.@all4you that’s kind of interesting. Lack of homogeneity is what gives rise in part to crime. Hegemony I do believe is a problem of the political left. The academic left. Hollywood left. Are too stupid to recognize it.
the right uses it as a political tool but as policy not voters. The right voters just leave. If they have resources the wealthy burbs. If they don’t. They go rural or just keep going as far out as it takes until they can find something they can afford. New construction in zionsville is one thing. But what is it 30 mins from there. Bam! Pubs with resources. Pubs without.
It's a million times safer to live in a trailer park than to live in the hood. Pubs care about their lives and their families. Others do not. Not my problem.
"safe". they just don't kill each other but drug addiction and child/spousal abuse is just as high. If not higher.
Rural white areas have the highest rate of drug overdoses per capita is the US. It's not really even close. It's an epidemic. One we hear about constantly. For good reason. There is countless efforts to combat fentanyl. Countless drug rehabilitation programs setup up. Drug court deferment programs. As a nation we are doing our damndest to combat the issue. 100,000 people per year die of overdoses. White people being the biggest group. By far. What the fuck is our problem? Why haven't we learned? Why are we so self destructive?
Black people kill each other. We kill ourselves. Same end results.
@mrhighlife no. You’re trying to compare things that have no comparison.
yeah I'm not really sure what my point was other than no one really cares about poor people in this country. Regardless of race.@mrhighlife no. You’re trying to compare things that have no comparison.
Preach.yeah I'm not really sure what my point was other than no one really cares about poor people in this country. Regardless of race.@mrhighlife no. You’re trying to compare things that have no comparison.
Could cross-post this in the thread on what it's like to send a kid to a progressive school:Your focus on guilt and deflecting that guilt from yourself says you’re looking at things differently than what I and McM are talking about. Maybe others you have a claim for. But we’re just talking about recognizing where the problems came from so we can fashion a solution. The point isn’t to assign blame or ask for “reparations.”
Just took a walk with a dad whose kid is a senior. Also happens to have attended IU but I didn't know him there. Said his kid walks in on his first day of AP English Lit and the white male teacher goes on a rant to the class about white privilege, how embarrassed he is to be white, and how "whiteness" will not be allowed to dominate his classroom.

