I'm with COH on this one. Not only is it wrong-headed thinking, it's unhelpful to black people.telling folks in bombed-out neighborhoods they’ve been free for 60 out of 300 years, get your shit together. Non-starters.
This is the problem. I’m talking about teenagers not 60 year olds or even 300 year olds. The kids haven’t experienced that history.
But it's not the whole explanation of what's going on.
And one that is very, very old.For America, crime is partly a legacy of slavery and the shitty way we dealt with emancipation
Some of that is true. But it’s overplayed. It’s as if every black youngster receives an injection of slavery and Jim Crow serum so those experiences are permanently implanted in their minds. Part of reason the world can’t solve intractable conflicts is because events of hundreds or thousands of years old are kept on permanent life support. Any effort to overcome this problem is met with cries of erasing history and that we must learn history “warts and all”.
It’s a frustrating problem.
Or it’s met with cries of “You hate America, and we shouldn’t be blaming whites for anything!”
You’re part of the problem. Refuse to engage the issue; only want to blame the other side.
I think the question is which white people do you want to blame? White people today aren't white people of the 1840s, the 1940s, etc. So why blame them because they share the same skin color? Because some are descendents of some of the people who did bad things in the past?
@bradstevens I’m mostly with mapletom on this one. Sort of agree with goat going back to slavery and to an extent with mapletom re guns germs and Steele shit but when you go that many generations back I think you lose people. The better explanation and argument need only go back to when coh was born. Mid 40s. Restrictive covenants. Dearth of ownership and business opportunities, dumped in an impoverished area. When you couch it as “within our lifetimes” it becomes more relatable and more understandable. No parents able to help bc they were held back. On and on. They climb is way more daunting
Or it’s met with cries of “You hate America, and we shouldn’t be blaming whites for anything!”
You’re part of the problem. Refuse to engage the issue; only want to blame the other side.
I think the question is which white people do you want to blame? White people today aren't white people of the 1840s, the 1940s, etc. So why blame them because they share the same skin color? Because some are descendents of some of the people who did bad things in the past?
Specific white people? Mostly dead ones, obviously. But the point here is not to deny that their legacy actually exists and has had an effect up through the modern day.
@bradstevens I’m mostly with mapletom on this one. Sort of agree with goat going back to slavery and to an extent with mapletom re guns germs and Steele shit but when you go that many generations back I think you lose people. The better explanation and argument need only go back to when coh was born. Mid 40s. Restrictive covenants. Dearth of ownership and business opportunities, dumped in an impoverished area. When you couch it as “within our lifetimes” it becomes more relatable and more understandable. No parents able to help bc they were held back. On and on. They climb is way more daunting
This issue is double-rare in that it's one in which we mostly agree, and also one in which you actually state it better than I do.
@bradstevens I’m mostly with mapletom on this one. Sort of agree with goat going back to slavery and to an extent with mapletom re guns germs and Steele shit but when you go that many generations back I think you lose people. The better explanation and argument need only go back to when coh was born. Mid 40s. Restrictive covenants. Dearth of ownership and business opportunities, dumped in an impoverished area. When you couch it as “within our lifetimes” it becomes more relatable and more understandable. No parents able to help bc they were held back. On and on. They climb is way more daunting
Bingo. Just a slight nod to this would buy a lot of goodwill. Current options are self-flagellation or total whitewash. Maddening.
I don't think that is the point. I think a lot of the rhetoric isn't theoretical but instead designed to advance the argument for reparations and money to be paid from today's white people to today's black people and the reasons given often devolve into "white people owned black people so are morally indebted and should pay." That argument is always lurking behind all these things. Which is why the opponents push on the theory to show it's bunk.Or it’s met with cries of “You hate America, and we shouldn’t be blaming whites for anything!”
You’re part of the problem. Refuse to engage the issue; only want to blame the other side.
I think the question is which white people do you want to blame? White people today aren't white people of the 1840s, the 1940s, etc. So why blame them because they share the same skin color? Because some are descendents of some of the people who did bad things in the past?
Specific white people? Mostly dead ones, obviously. But the point here is not to deny that their legacy actually exists and has had an effect up through the modern day.
I'm ready willing and able to criticize those of the past for slavery. I'll also try to put them in the context of their time and place. I'm ready willing and able to feel sympathy for my fellow man who grows up in poverty or with abusive parents or with a disability, etc. whether they are white, black, or purple and think we should have social programs to help same.
But I don't feel an ounce of guilt for what others do, including what people who happen to share with my skin color did to people with a darker skin color in the past.
I don't think that is the point. I think a lot of the rhetoric isn't theoretical but instead designed to advance the argument for reparations and money to be paid from today's white people to today's black people and the reasons given often devolve into "white people owned black people so are morally indebted and should pay." That argument is always lurking behind all these things. Which is why the opponents push on the theory to show it's bunk.Or it’s met with cries of “You hate America, and we shouldn’t be blaming whites for anything!”
You’re part of the problem. Refuse to engage the issue; only want to blame the other side.
I think the question is which white people do you want to blame? White people today aren't white people of the 1840s, the 1940s, etc. So why blame them because they share the same skin color? Because some are descendents of some of the people who did bad things in the past?
Specific white people? Mostly dead ones, obviously. But the point here is not to deny that their legacy actually exists and has had an effect up through the modern day.
I'm ready willing and able to criticize those of the past for slavery. I'll also try to put them in the context of their time and place. I'm ready willing and able to feel sympathy for my fellow man who grows up in poverty or with abusive parents or with a disability, etc. whether they are white, black, or purple and think we should have social programs to help same.
But I don't feel an ounce of guilt for what others do, including what people who happen to share with my skin color did to people with a darker skin color in the past.
Your focus on guilt and deflecting that guilt from yourself says you're looking at things differently than what I and McM are talking about. Maybe others you have a claim for. But we're just talking about recognizing where the problems came from so we can fashion a solution. The point isn't to assign blame or ask for "reparations."
But the point here is not to deny that their legacy actually exists and has had an effect up through the modern day.
People, for different reasons, perpetuate the legacy and keep the grievances the legacy produces on the front burner. The grievance people are still living in a world that requires white people to change. That is their way to apply control and influence, two very powerful human characteristics. Well, white people have changed. The underachievers among us now need to take life, education, and culture seriously. It’s not just the kids, it’s the cultural infrastructure in many urban areas that sucks. Look at the mayors and educators in many urban areas. What do you see?
You’re part of the problem. Refuse to engage the issue; only want to blame the other side.
Back atcha. We’ve had 70+ years of blaming whites. That has produced prolific white mea culpas, anti- discrimination laws, education reform, racial preferences, economic set asides, court sympathy for discrimination cases, black leadership in all large cities, a black president, and more. Things are worse in many different measures.
Refusal to engage the issue my ass.
First, by saying I’m “deflecting” guilt, you imply some guilt is called for, don’t you?I don't think that is the point. I think a lot of the rhetoric isn't theoretical but instead designed to advance the argument for reparations and money to be paid from today's white people to today's black people and the reasons given often devolve into "white people owned black people so are morally indebted and should pay." That argument is always lurking behind all these things. Which is why the opponents push on the theory to show it's bunk.Or it’s met with cries of “You hate America, and we shouldn’t be blaming whites for anything!”
You’re part of the problem. Refuse to engage the issue; only want to blame the other side.
I think the question is which white people do you want to blame? White people today aren't white people of the 1840s, the 1940s, etc. So why blame them because they share the same skin color? Because some are descendents of some of the people who did bad things in the past?
Specific white people? Mostly dead ones, obviously. But the point here is not to deny that their legacy actually exists and has had an effect up through the modern day.
I'm ready willing and able to criticize those of the past for slavery. I'll also try to put them in the context of their time and place. I'm ready willing and able to feel sympathy for my fellow man who grows up in poverty or with abusive parents or with a disability, etc. whether they are white, black, or purple and think we should have social programs to help same.
But I don't feel an ounce of guilt for what others do, including what people who happen to share with my skin color did to people with a darker skin color in the past.
Your focus on guilt and deflecting that guilt from yourself says you're looking at things differently than what I and McM are talking about. Maybe others you have a claim for. But we're just talking about recognizing where the problems came from so we can fashion a solution. The point isn't to assign blame or ask for "reparations."
Second, MapleTom is writing some pretty persuasive and I think accurate stuff in this thread on this topic. But even he came back to the white v black dichotomy that fuses all whites and blacks together into one morally responsible group over centuries.
So if two thoughtful people on here still can’t eradicate these notions of racial guilt across the centuries from their thought, why should we believe the mass of SJWs can or even want to?
Re causes and solutions, I’m not sure solving the first helps with the second on these historical problems (I think Ishiguro touches on this in The Buried Giant, by the way).
Specific white people? Mostly dead ones, obviously. But the point here is not to deny that their legacy actually exists and has had an effect up through the modern day.
The history is permanent, but it is history. The legacy from that history is a fact of life. What do you think that legacy demands of white people that hasn’t already been done?
Here is more legacy for you. Back in the 18th and 19th century it was a crime to teach a slave to read and write. Now black youngsters have free education but many are still only semi-literate. Black kids are run through black schools, with black teachers, black administrators, black school boards and we have an educational desert. What can we do to change that?
Sort of agree with goat going back to slavery and to an extent with mapletom re guns germs and Steele shit but when you go that many generations back I think you lose people. The better explanation and argument need only go back to when coh was born. Mid 40s. Restrictive covenants. Dearth of ownership and business opportunities, dumped in an impoverished area. When you couch it as “within our lifetimes” it becomes more relatable and more understandable. No parents able to help bc they were held back. On and on. They climb is way more daunting
Of course all that is true and all of that has been acknowledged, addressed and remedial measures taken. What now?

