Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Does the Constituti...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Does the Constitution require birth right citizenship?

Page 6 / 21
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

We know “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” is necessary because it’s in the constitution. Being born in the U.S is not enough. So what else is required?

So a person visiting Disney from France is not subject to US laws? We know we cannot arrest a diplomat for theft, are you saying the tourist is also immune from arrest?


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/10/2025 8:24 pm
Spartans9312's avatar
(@spartans9312)
Noble Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Those would be the only 3 categories that met the definition of not “subject to the jurisdiction” to the end of time? Even though they are not listed? 

How hard would it have been for them to say that citizenship is passed from parents to children, and everyone else needs government action?

 

We know “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” is necessary because it’s in the constitution. Being born in the U.S is not enough. So what else is required?

 

This should be obvious. Anyone subject to the jurisdiction is basically anyone who is here, except for classes that are by custom excluded, like invading armies, diplomats, foreign heads of state, etc. Regular old aliens, regardless of the legality of their arrival, are certainly subject to our jurisdiction.

 

 

I’m not a lawyer but how does debating the language help if you’re opposed to the EO?

 

Does debating the relevant case law help if you’re opposed to the EO?

 

I’ll listen from here because otherwise I’ll be out over my skis 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/10/2025 8:29 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

Those would be the only 3 categories that met the definition of not “subject to the jurisdiction” to the end of time? Even though they are not listed? 

How hard would it have been for them to say that citizenship is passed from parents to children, and everyone else needs government action?

 

We know “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” is necessary because it’s in the constitution. Being born in the U.S is not enough. So what else is required?

 

This should be obvious. Anyone subject to the jurisdiction is basically anyone who is here, except for classes that are by custom excluded, like invading armies, diplomats, foreign heads of state, etc. Regular old aliens, regardless of the legality of their arrival, are certainly subject to our jurisdiction.

 

 

I’m not a lawyer but how does debating the language help if you’re opposed to the EO?

 

Does debating the relevant case law help if you’re opposed to the EO?

 

I’ll listen from here because otherwise I’ll be out over my skis 

 

So, I'm not predicting how anything will turn out. But the general understanding of this issue up until now has followed what I already said. If you go back to US v. Wong Kim Ark, the person in question was born in the US, and he was born of parents who were not US citizens, who were in fact subjects of the Emperor of China, and owed allegiance to him. And yet, the child born here automatically acquired citizenship. The court ruled that "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" meant that the government could deny citizenship to people who fell within specific exceptions, such as diplomats, but could not deny citizenship to people who were born here to alien parents generally.

Obviously, due to the nature of immigration policy at the time, they could not really touch on the difference between legal and illegal aliens. That distinction had little meaning then.

But it does seem clear that appeals to case law and statutory construction would traditionally favor those opposed to the EO, as the Trump admin here is effectively asking SCOTUS to ignore precedent and hand down a brand new definition/interpretation of the laws at hand.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/10/2025 8:38 pm
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

But it does seem clear that appeals to case law and statutory construction would traditionally favor those opposed to the EO, as the Trump admin here is effectively asking SCOTUS to ignore precedent and hand down a brand new definition/interpretation of the laws at hand.

He's also asking them to sign off on his making this determination by royal decree.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/10/2025 8:51 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @unclemark
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

But it does seem clear that appeals to case law and statutory construction would traditionally favor those opposed to the EO, as the Trump admin here is effectively asking SCOTUS to ignore precedent and hand down a brand new definition/interpretation of the laws at hand.

He's also asking them to sign off on his making this determination by royal decree.

 

How the fuck did you get a shield before me?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/10/2025 8:56 pm
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @unclemark
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

But it does seem clear that appeals to case law and statutory construction would traditionally favor those opposed to the EO, as the Trump admin here is effectively asking SCOTUS to ignore precedent and hand down a brand new definition/interpretation of the laws at hand.

He's also asking them to sign off on his making this determination by royal decree.

How the fuck did you get a shield before me?

Quality posting, bitch.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/10/2025 9:01 pm
😂
3
OneEyedUndertaker
(@oneeyedundertaker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @spartans9312
↑

We know “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” is necessary because it’s in the constitution. Being born in the U.S is not enough. So what else is required?

So a person visiting Disney from France is not subject to US laws? We know we cannot arrest a diplomat for theft, are you saying the tourist is also immune from arrest?

Arrested or prosecuted?  Do we arrest & deport, or arrest, subject to our legal system & incarcerate?  I don’t have an understanding of this.  I would think that distinction should matter…

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/12/2025 3:24 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @oneeyedundertaker
↑

Arrested or prosecuted?  Do we arrest & deport, or arrest, subject to our legal system & incarcerate?  I don’t have an understanding of this.  I would think that distinction should matter…

We can order a diplomat to leave, we cannot charge them with crimes. So if a French hitman comes over and kills someone, if they are not subject to our laws, are you ok with just sending them home? I see a thriving business opportunity for entrepreneurs from other nations. 

Now to be fair, the host country can waive diplomatic immunity. I don't know what that would mean for our hitman entrepreneurs as they don't have immunity, just our belief they are outside our laws.

Now to complicate my point, they are outside some law. They aren't subject to jury duty, a potential draft, and the like. Though if they win the billion dollar lottery, they would be subject to taxes. They would have to pay higher federal taxes than we, and still pay state taxes. They may hire a lawyer to claim they are outside tax law.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/12/2025 3:47 pm
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @unclemark
↑

He's also asking them to sign off on his making this determination by royal decree.

 

If it was a royal decree in the sense you're talking about, it wouldn't be subject to judicial review.  

President's act on their own, interpreting the Constitution themselves, in plenty of ways.  It's impossible not to.  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 12/12/2025 4:35 pm
👍
1
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @oneeyedundertaker
↑

Arrested or prosecuted?  Do we arrest & deport, or arrest, subject to our legal system & incarcerate?  I don’t have an understanding of this.  I would think that distinction should matter…

We can order a diplomat to leave, we cannot charge them with crimes. So if a French hitman comes over and kills someone, if they are not subject to our laws, are you ok with just sending them home? I see a thriving business opportunity for entrepreneurs from other nations. 

Now to be fair, the host country can waive diplomatic immunity. I don't know what that would mean for our hitman entrepreneurs as they don't have immunity, just our belief they are outside our laws.

Now to complicate my point, they are outside some law. They aren't subject to jury duty, a potential draft, and the like. Though if they win the billion dollar lottery, they would be subject to taxes. They would have to pay higher federal taxes than we, and still pay state taxes. They may hire a lawyer to claim they are outside tax law.

 

The fact that foreign criminals are subject to our jurisdiction is proven every time our State Department makes an extradition request.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/12/2025 7:23 pm
Aloha Hoosier's avatar
(@aloha-hoosier)
Famed Member

There was a scholar from SCOTUSblog on the radio today discussing the tariff decision. She predicts the upcoming decision on birthright citizenship would be unanimous against Trump's EO on it. The other person predicted that two would vote to uphold: Alito and Thomas. He basically thinks they're going to vote to approve anything Trump wants. I don't think that's right. I sure hope it's not right.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 02/20/2026 5:15 pm
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @aloha-hoosier
↑

There was a scholar from SCOTUSblog on the radio today discussing the tariff decision. She predicts the upcoming decision on birthright citizenship would be unanimous against Trump's EO on it. The other person predicted that two would vote to uphold: Alito and Thomas. He basically thinks they're going to vote to approve anything Trump wants. I don't think that's right. I sure hope it's not right.

Has either one ever voted against a Trump policy? Ever?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 02/20/2026 5:45 pm
Aloha Hoosier's avatar
(@aloha-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @unclemark
↑

Posted by: @aloha-hoosier
↑

There was a scholar from SCOTUSblog on the radio today discussing the tariff decision. She predicts the upcoming decision on birthright citizenship would be unanimous against Trump's EO on it. The other person predicted that two would vote to uphold: Alito and Thomas. He basically thinks they're going to vote to approve anything Trump wants. I don't think that's right. I sure hope it's not right.

Has either one ever voted against a Trump policy? Ever?

 

My guess is probably yes, but I don't know. You can dig in to see for yourself:

Opinions of the Court - 2025

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 02/20/2026 6:01 pm
dbmhoosier
(@dbmhoosier)
Famed Member

🔥 🔥 🔥 

https://twitter.com/i/status/2039336262671159413


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/01/2026 8:57 am
😂
1
Butch Crawling's avatar
(@big-ryan)
Famed Member

Posted by: @dbmhoosier
↑

🔥 🔥 🔥 

https://twitter.com/i/status/2039336262671159413

He won't understand any of it. 

Hopefully he won't be farting up a storm like the last time he was in court. 

No chance he stays (or stays awake) for the entirety of the arguments. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 04/01/2026 9:29 am
😂
1
Page 6 / 21
Share: