Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

ChatGPT-5: Manhatta...
 
Notifications
Clear all

ChatGPT-5: Manhattan Project 2.0

Page 11 / 18
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

The first one is not the definition of a supernaturalist. 

 

If not, then what were you attempting to dispute with CoH? he was clearly using the first definition. 

I Dont Know

He doesn't understand what the definition of supernatural is/means.  It's like saying "Oh, you're using the definition of dog to mean cat."  

This isn't difficult: supernaturalists believe in the supernatural. Naturalists don't. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 1:18 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member
Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

The first one is not the definition of a supernaturalist. 

 

If not, then what were you attempting to dispute with CoH? he was clearly using the first definition. 

I Dont Know

He doesn't understand what the definition of supernatural is/means.  It's like saying "Oh, you're using the definition of dog to mean cat."  

This isn't difficult: supernaturalists believe in the supernatural. Naturalists don't. 

 

I get it. You don’t like his definition. CoH provided the definition that he’s using and I found such a definition in the dictionary. There are multiple definitions. That gets back to my first point. Communication cannot occur without an agreement on terms. 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 1:41 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

The first one is not the definition of a supernaturalist. 

 

If not, then what were you attempting to dispute with CoH? he was clearly using the first definition. 

I Dont Know

He doesn't understand what the definition of supernatural is/means.  It's like saying "Oh, you're using the definition of dog to mean cat."  

This isn't difficult: supernaturalists believe in the supernatural. Naturalists don't. 

 

I get it. You don’t like his definition. CoH provided the definition that he’s using and I found such a definition in the dictionary. There are multiple definitions. That gets back to my first point. Communication cannot occur without an agreement on terms. 

 

 

There is no definition of supernaturalist that excludes the belief in the supernatural.  

You're either arguing in bad faith or just not very educated in this matter.  I'd suggest sitting this one out.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 1:45 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

The first one is not the definition of a supernaturalist. 

 

If not, then what were you attempting to dispute with CoH? he was clearly using the first definition. 

I Dont Know

He doesn't understand what the definition of supernatural is/means.  It's like saying "Oh, you're using the definition of dog to mean cat."  

This isn't difficult: supernaturalists believe in the supernatural. Naturalists don't. 

 

I get it. You don’t like his definition. CoH provided the definition that he’s using and I found such a definition in the dictionary. There are multiple definitions. That gets back to my first point. Communication cannot occur without an agreement on terms. 

 

 

There is no definition of supernaturalist that excludes the belief in the supernatural.  

You're either arguing in bad faith or just not very educated in this matter.  I'd suggest sitting this one out.  

 

I’ve got no skin in your ”argument,” maestro. I’m not arguing anything. I’m simply pointing out that you and COH are engaging in the classic mistake of not agreeing on your terms.

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 2:42 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member
image

ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 3:08 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member
image

ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 3:11 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

You're just as bad as COH, just inventing fake definitions of terms to suit you. 

If something follows natural laws, then it is not supernatural, by definition. Period.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 3:22 pm
👍
1
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

@

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Clearly one has to stipulate which definition of supernatural one is using:

Observed or unobserved phenomena unexplained by science but considered belonging to the physical universe

Phenomena considered to exist outside the physical universe

Which yields two definitions of supernaturalist. Or leads to arguments about whether or not calling the first definition “supernatural” even makes any sense. 

You're just as bad as COH, just inventing fake definitions of terms to suit you. 

If something follows natural laws, then it is not supernatural, by definition. Period.

 

I freely admit I composed those two definitions based on dictionary definitions. Ignore them, if you please. 

That doesn’t change the fact that any standard dictionary presents your definition and CoH’s (see above). Very few words in Webster’s Unabridged have but one definition. But of course, you know that.

 
 

ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 4:45 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@goat 

You say that as if natural (physical) law is known and defined. Take dark matter. It does not react with light or any electromagnetic radiation, we cannot see or detect it and its presence is assumed solely by inference; in other words a fudge factor.  It’s only a part of natural law because we say so. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 4:52 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member
image

ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 4:57 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @goat
↑
If something follows natural laws, then it is not supernatural, by definition. Period.
The question is, what if science hasn’t determined if something follows natural laws or if science doesn’t have natural laws to explain something? Is that “by definition” supernatural?

As I described above, thoughts, mental images, awareness, memories are all examples of phenomena that can’t be empirically measured, detected, or located by scientific methods or devices. 

Edit: Are your thoughts supernatural, Goat? (snicker)


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 5:09 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

@hhlurker I’ve already answered that.

You’re not adding anything new and are contradicting yourself in consecutive posts. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 5:25 pm
HHLurker's avatar
(@hhlurker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

@hhlurker I’ve already answered that.

You’re not adding anything new and are contradicting yourself in consecutive posts. 

Sorry, I missed that. Are thoughts natural or supernatural for you? And if natural, what natural laws do they obey?

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 08/09/2025 5:40 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @hhlurker
↑

Are your thoughts supernatural, Goat? (snicker)

Depends who you ask. A naturalist would say no. He would say they are the result of dependable, natural processes that we simply don't fully understand yet.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 5:42 pm
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@goat 

You say that as if natural (physical) law is known and defined. Take dark matter. It does not react with light or any electromagnetic radiation, we cannot see or detect it and its presence is assumed solely by inference; in other words a fudge factor.  It’s only a part of natural law because we say so. 

You clearly don't understand what we are saying. A naturalist does not claim we understand how it all works. He simply claims that, if we did understand, we would find that everything which exists is part of nature and subject to natural laws.

Dark matter appears to behave as expected according to the natural forces we know about. There is nothing supernatural about it simply because it is invisible.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 08/09/2025 5:44 pm
Page 11 / 18
Share: