@bradstevens we had a ton of arguments before and during the war during the GWB years. I have little, actually no, enthusiasm for doing it again. I do disagree with some of what you wrote in both posts, but that argument is over for me. And believe me, we did a lot analysis and many discussions about what we did right and wrong before and during that war the last several years of my military career.
Did the Navy do much wrong during the military actions in Iraq? I wouldn't blame the military for much (Abu Ghraib sure but CIA, too).@bradstevens And believe me, we did a lot analysis and many discussions about what we did right and wrong before and during that war the last several years of my military career.
It was the political actors that fucked it all up. And I'm counting the political higher ups at the intelligence services.
First, Hussein was the biggest check on Iranian influence in the region. We eliminated that and created a power vacuum. Guess who filled it? And with that increased power, Iran became more capable of influencing Hamas, Hezbollah etc. since they had nothing to worry about right next door.Trump doesn't have the Iranian problem without the Iraq War.
What reasoning makes you come to that conclusion?
Second, the war and resulting chaos (hey there ISIS) resulted in the US and probably the entire West to not pay enough attention to Iran and it’s growing power.
Third, taking Hussein out for the trumped up reason that he had WMDs (something only the blind and dumb still argue over) created a lot more incentive for every rogue nation to get a nuke and prevent a reckless, irrational invasion against them while also proving that WMD justifications work on Americans, no matter how weak. So if you want one, hide your intentions and hurry up, lest the US comes after you.
Fourth, and unrelated to the Iran problem as it existed in 2025 but relevant to alternative history, we probably don’t get Trump or MAGA without all the disaffected and pissed off people caused by Bush era decisions.
Where you and I agree, though, is that I don’t think GWB and Cheney did it for corrupt reasons and our military obviously took care of business quickly. But that last point doesn’t really matter if you fuck up the aftermath. And boy did we do that.
Keeping Hussein around just to check Iranian power would have been bad policy. Sure, we supported him during his war with Iran but that was a your enemy's enemy deal. Iraq was probably more dangerous than Iran at the time. Remember, they invaded and annexed Kuwait prior to GW1. They likely would have carved out parts of Saudi Arabia without our intervention. Not hard to imagine an intact Iraq under Hussein (or his sons) being the same or bigger pain in the world's ass that Iran is today.
The WMD hunt and justifications for the invasion were ridiculous, but a brutal and decisive geopolitical message had to be sent to the ME after 9 / 11. There was nothing irrational about toppling a couple ME governments, even one that wasn't involved. The hijackers came from and were supported by several different ME countries, some of whom we were close to politically, militarily, and economically. Hussein drew the short straw but everyone else but got the message. The Saudis and UAE quickly put there extremists in check and are reliable partners today. They even find ways to work with Israel now.
The irrational and tragic part was thinking we could snap our fingers and make them liberal democracies.
@bradstevens no. The problem was the political strategy, not the military operations.
I agree on your last point.First, Hussein was the biggest check on Iranian influence in the region. We eliminated that and created a power vacuum. Guess who filled it? And with that increased power, Iran became more capable of influencing Hamas, Hezbollah etc. since they had nothing to worry about right next door.Trump doesn't have the Iranian problem without the Iraq War.
What reasoning makes you come to that conclusion?
Second, the war and resulting chaos (hey there ISIS) resulted in the US and probably the entire West to not pay enough attention to Iran and it’s growing power.
Third, taking Hussein out for the trumped up reason that he had WMDs (something only the blind and dumb still argue over) created a lot more incentive for every rogue nation to get a nuke and prevent a reckless, irrational invasion against them while also proving that WMD justifications work on Americans, no matter how weak. So if you want one, hide your intentions and hurry up, lest the US comes after you.
Fourth, and unrelated to the Iran problem as it existed in 2025 but relevant to alternative history, we probably don’t get Trump or MAGA without all the disaffected and pissed off people caused by Bush era decisions.
Where you and I agree, though, is that I don’t think GWB and Cheney did it for corrupt reasons and our military obviously took care of business quickly. But that last point doesn’t really matter if you fuck up the aftermath. And boy did we do that.
Keeping Hussein around just to check Iranian power would have been bad policy. Sure, we supported him during his war with Iran but that was a your enemy's enemy deal. Iraq was probably more dangerous than Iran at the time. Remember, they invaded and annexed Kuwait prior to GW1. They likely would have carved out parts of Saudi Arabia without our intervention. Not hard to imagine an intact Iraq under Hussein (or his sons) being the same or bigger pain in the world's ass that Iran is today.
The WMD hunt and justifications for the invasion were ridiculous, but a brutal and decisive geopolitical message had to be sent to the ME after 9 / 11. There was nothing irrational about toppling a couple ME governments, even one that wasn't involved. The hijackers came from and were supported by several different ME countries, some of whom we were close to politically, militarily, and economically. Hussein drew the short straw but everyone else but got the message. The Saudis and UAE quickly put there extremists in check and are reliable partners today. They even find ways to work with Israel now.
The irrational and tragic part was thinking we could snap our fingers and make them liberal democracies.
I disagree on some of the others. Hussein wasn't a religious nut, just an evil dictator. Easier to deal with his self interest. And Iraq's downfall led to hardliners and more extremists in Iran, so that point works against you. The relative moderates lost out in 2005 and that's when Iran started going full on again towards a nuke.
On the "brutal and decisive" geopolitical message, I think there was another way. Again, we had world-wide support after 9/11. We wasted that capital by now being perceived as tricking the rest of the West into the war with not much to show for it.
For the record, if your'e going to do that, at least cross out what I originally wrote so no one stumbles across this and mistakes me for an anti-semite.fifyTrump doesn't have the Iranian problem without a Jewish son-in-law.
Edit: Did Jimmy Carter have an Iranian problem because of the IRaq War?
A good friend will bail you out of jail, but your best friend will be sitting next to you in the cell saying "that was f***ing awesome"
Uh...the Trump Iran War problem is something Trump started, amigo, not Iran. Trump's genius warmongering worked great until he crossed the Atlantic and bit off more than he could chew. US military experts for decades (back to Jimmy Carter if not before) have wargamed a military encounter with Iran and Hormuz was ALWAYS the sticking point. But...good ol' Donny Johnny, who promised all of us back in 2015 that he could solve all the world's problems all be his little lonesome, ignored all those US military hacks and dove in headfirst and the bequest of Netanyahu.
Dumbass
Uh...the Trump Iran War problem is something Trump started, amigo, not Iran. Trump's genius warmongering worked great until he crossed the Atlantic and bit off more than he could chew. US military experts for decades (back to Jimmy Carter if not before) have wargamed a military encounter with Iran and Hormuz was ALWAYS the sticking point. But...good ol' Donny Johnny, who promised all of us back in 2015 that he could solve all the world's problems all be his little lonesome, ignored all those US military hacks and dove in headfirst and the bequest of Netanyahu.
Dumbass
It's been going on for decades, dipshit. Just because other presidents didn't address it doesn't mean attacks and violence weren't being thrust on the U.S. and other countries.
America vs Iran: Seventy Years of Conflict | GovFacts
| Year(s) | Event | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| 1953 | CIA/MI6-backed coup overthrows Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh | Reinstalls the Shah, creating lasting Iranian resentment—the “original sin” of the relationship |
| 1957 | US “Atoms for Peace” program establishes Iran’s nuclear program | Ironic origin of what becomes the central 21st century conflict |
| 1957 | US and Israeli intelligence help create SAVAK secret police | US directly aids repressive apparatus, fueling revolutionary anger |
| 1979 | Islamic Revolution overthrows the Shah | Iran transforms from key ally to primary ideological adversary |
| 1979–1981 | Iran Hostage Crisis: 52 Americans held for 444 days | Diplomatic relations severed, creating enduring American trauma |
| 1980–1988 | Iran-Iraq War: US “tilts” toward Iraq | US support for Saddam Hussein deepens Iranian animosity |
| 1985–1987 | Iran-Contra Affair: Reagan administration illegally sells arms to Iran | Scandal exposes US duplicity, confirming both sides’ worst suspicions |
| 1988 | Operation Praying Mantis: US Navy engages Iranian warships | Largest US naval surface engagement since WWII marks direct military clash |
| 1988 | USS Vincennes shoots down Iran Air Flight 655 | 290 civilian deaths cement Iranian view of US as “Great Satan” |
| 2002 | Iran’s secret nuclear facilities revealed | Triggers decades-long standoff and crippling sanctions |
| 2015 | Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) signed | Landmark diplomatic achievement providing sanctions relief for nuclear limits |
| 2018 | Trump withdraws US from JCPOA, launches “maximum pressure” | Deal collapses, Iran accelerates nuclear program to near-weapons-grade |
| 2020 | US drone strike assassinates Qasem Soleimani | Major escalation brings nations to brink of direct war |
| 2023–Present | Escalating proxy conflicts following October 7 Hamas attack | Shadow war erupts into open, Iran launches first direct strike on Israel |
Iran crisis of 1946 - Wikipedia
"In August–September 1941, Pahlavi Iran had been jointly invaded and occupied by the Allied powers: the Soviet Red Army invaded in the north; the British invaded from the south into the centre.[6] Iran was used by the Americans and the British as a transportation route to provide vital supplies to the Soviet Union's war efforts."
"After Germany broke its pact with the Soviets and invaded the USSR in June 1941, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union jointly occupied neutral Iran as a preventive measure, starting on August 25, 1941. They justified their invasion by the need to use Iran as a gateway for delivery of Lend-Lease supplies to the Soviet Union from British India between 1941 and 1945.[7] Iran had long been torn between the bordering zones of influence of Britain and Russia, but had managed until then to remain independent, despite several foreign interventions, by taking advantage of the rivalry between the two powers. Now that Russia and Britain stood together against Germany, nothing opposed a formal joint occupation of the country. As a result, Rezā Shāh was forced to abdicate on September 16, 1941,[6] and exiled to Mauritius; his son, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the crown prince, became the new monarch."
Iran crisis of 1946 - Wikipedia
"In August–September 1941, Pahlavi Iran had been jointly invaded and occupied by the Allied powers: the Soviet Red Army invaded in the north; the British invaded from the south into the centre.[6] Iran was used by the Americans and the British as a transportation route to provide vital supplies to the Soviet Union's war efforts."
"After Germany broke its pact with the Soviets and invaded the USSR in June 1941, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union jointly occupied neutral Iran as a preventive measure, starting on August 25, 1941. They justified their invasion by the need to use Iran as a gateway for delivery of Lend-Lease supplies to the Soviet Union from British India between 1941 and 1945.[7] Iran had long been torn between the bordering zones of influence of Britain and Russia, but had managed until then to remain independent, despite several foreign interventions, by taking advantage of the rivalry between the two powers. Now that Russia and Britain stood together against Germany, nothing opposed a formal joint occupation of the country. As a result, Rezā Shāh was forced to abdicate on September 16, 1941,[6] and exiled to Mauritius; his son, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the crown prince, became the new monarch."
Islam ruined Iran
https://twitter.com/liz_churchill10/status/2009825838410158395
https://twitter.com/JamesLucasIT/status/1898815260900868604
https://twitter.com/realMaalouf/status/1935076043238637855
Shall we do Lebanon next?
