That big win over Purdue keeps ND in the top 25. The coaches have the Irish #21 and AP has them at #22.
Well, the Irish went to the title game and have cash to mostly reload, so theyre probably reasonably strong.
Yes, and it absolutely could come to that...Miami on the road was a fair loss, Miami look very good. A&M at home not a good one though. The rest of their schedule is pretty easy and there aren’t many impressive possible wins left (maybe USC).
I hope this knocks them out of the playoff, but if they run the table and time passes they’ll probably somehow be in the mix.
We’ll see. I definitely don’t like them.
You know they will absolutely put a 2 loss ND team in over a 2 loss IU team if it comes to that.
SEC....4
Big 10.3
ACC....2
Big 12.1
Non P4 1
ND 1
If ND loses to anyone else, they're out. We need them to lose to USC, Arkansas, Syracuse, Navy or Boise St. All but Arkansas are at home. If we go 11-1 they're out anyway unless FSU should collapse.
That big win over Purdue keeps ND in the top 25. The coaches have the Irish #21 and AP has them at #22.
I think ND moved up 2 spots. They win next week, they be top 10!
@big-red-cb-v-2-0 My old college roomie called from South Bend to tell me he probably wouldn't be able to see IU play until the second half as the TV people were going to show ND / Purdue in South Bend and Lafayette until that game was over. He wasn't too happy about that decision.
Need Illinois to beat USC and USC to beat Notre Dame. Ahh, in an ideal world.
But really, we just need to take care of business. Beat Iowa!
Miami and A&M are really, really good losses. The average fan just doesn't understand how strong those losses proved the Irish are.
Of course we played Kennesaw State and Indiana State. And have to go by Old Dominion beating mighty Virginia Tech to show just how great our wins are. So far. And the Irish beat us somewhat recently. With home field advantage though.
But by the end of the year, even after the B1g Ten gauntlet, our losses if any will be bad losses, our good wins will mean the other team is overrated.
Now, Tennessee at home just had a really good loss. They're in!
I disagree. Miami got elevated by beating what will now be an unranked ND team. Because ND loses, doesn't mean their opponents are good. ND just doesn't look the same this year. I see them losing more, for sure.
Care to amend this statement? After Miami trounces FSU today they’ll be in a glide path to a first round bye.
Notre Dame offense looks like one of the best units in football. Defense is progressing.
IU went 11-1 last year, didn’t beat a single team that was ranked at the end of the season, and lots of people wanted them left out of the playoffs.
Notre Dame could run the table, finish 10-2, and not have a single ranked win.
If that’s the case, they are getting left out.
IU went 11-1 last year, didn’t beat a single team that was ranked at the end of the season, and lots of people wanted them left out of the playoffs.
Notre Dame could run the table, finish 10-2, and not have a single ranked win.
If that’s the case, they are getting left out.
They aren’t. Because there aren’t 12 teams better than Notre Dame. The teams that beat Notre Dame might not even be better than Notre Dame.
IU went 11-1 last year, didn’t beat a single team that was ranked at the end of the season, and lots of people wanted them left out of the playoffs.
Notre Dame could run the table, finish 10-2, and not have a single ranked win.
If that’s the case, they are getting left out.
They aren’t. Because there aren’t 12 teams better than Notre Dame. The teams that beat Notre Dame might not even be better than Notre Dame.
They lost to the only two good teams on their schedule.
@kelly_32 what is a “good team”.
They’re going to beat plenty of bowl teams. Usually that qualifies as good.
It looks like they lost to the ACC champion on the road with their QB playing his first game.
And an A&M that seems like they’re going to be in the playoff who would’ve lost to ND if the refs didn’t blow a massive holding call.
We either want the playoff to be the 12 best teams or we don’t. If we want the 12 best then Notre Dame can’t be left out.
@kelly_32 what is a “good team”.
They’re going to beat plenty of bowl teams. Usually that qualifies as good.
It looks like they lost to the ACC champion on the road with their QB playing his first game.
And an A&M that seems like they’re going to be in the playoff who would’ve lost to ND if the refs didn’t blow a massive holding call.
We either want the playoff to be the 12 best teams or we don’t. If we want the 12 best then Notre Dame can’t be left out.
10-2 with no wins against teams in the top 25 should not get you in. I'll take a 3 loss SEC or BIG team over that.People were trying to keep 11-1 IU with that line of thinking and then they would have been out with 2 losses. They're schedule the rest of the way is a joke and mostly home games. ND schedules the tough games at the beginning of the season so people will forget if they lose and then roll off 10 wins against cupcakes. Maybe they lose one of those anyway ala Northern Illinois last year and it's all moot.