Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

The Constitution as...
 
Notifications
Clear all

The Constitution as The Bible

Page 2 / 2
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @the-leal-deal
↑

https://twitter.com/billmaher/status/1987013497432289593?s=46&t=RqAzYMWPzX-OinhMiXHkng

Good topic

Terrible legal analysis in the opening summary. Horrible logic in the metaphor given Maher’s and my beliefs.

Don’t rely on comedians for your constitutional analysis.

 

 

There wasn't really a whole lot of legal analysis at all in that clip. I think the Seal Team 6 bit just got your feathers ruffled.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/14/2025 7:19 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @the-leal-deal
↑

https://twitter.com/billmaher/status/1987013497432289593?s=46&t=RqAzYMWPzX-OinhMiXHkng

Good topic

Terrible legal analysis in the opening summary. Horrible logic in the metaphor given Maher’s and my beliefs.

Don’t rely on comedians for your constitutional analysis.

 

 

There wasn't really a whole lot of legal analysis at all in that clip. I think the Seal Team 6 bit just got your feathers ruffled.

 

Entire first minute, 40 seconds. Very first sentence accuses SCt of being partisan hacks.  That requires reading their opinion and analyzing what's going on. He then says the upcoming case will "definitively" tell us if the SCt is an independent branch of govt. He then talks about the results of cases from May and June.  

So yes, it's stupid analysis.  But it is analysis.  

And the analogy with the Bible is contradictory to his stance (unstated here, but discussed at length in other episodes and rants) against originalism--in fact, he unknowingly highlights that by making a big deal out of the ability to amend the Constitution (the best argument against a broad Living Constitution intepretative method). Note how this contradicts how he is saying the Bible should be interpreted--via a more originalist method (i.e., the moral teachings and parable meanings cannot evolve with the times and advancement of knowledge), which means he is also unknowingly arguing the Constitution should be interpreted that way by arguing we should not let the Constitution fall to the status of the current Enlightenment version of the Living Bible. 

So his logic is a mess. I still like Maher, but again, the way people get their political opinions--and more worrisome, constitutional analysis-- from comedians these days (started with John Stewart and the Daily Show, which I admit I regularly watched 20 years ago) is troubling (even if they are podcasters--hey there Joe Rogan).  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/16/2025 10:24 am
👍
1
Page 2 / 2
Share: