Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

The Constitution as...
 
Notifications
Clear all

The Constitution as The Bible

Page 1 / 2
Leal Deal's avatar
(@the-leal-deal)
Eminent Member

https://twitter.com/billmaher/status/1987013497432289593?s=46&t=RqAzYMWPzX-OinhMiXHkng

Good topic


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 11/08/2025 6:48 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @the-leal-deal
↑

https://twitter.com/billmaher/status/1987013497432289593?s=46&t=RqAzYMWPzX-OinhMiXHkng

Good topic

Terrible legal analysis in the opening summary. Horrible logic in the metaphor given Maher’s and my beliefs.

Don’t rely on comedians for your constitutional analysis.

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 9:36 am
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Don’t rely on comedians for your constitutional analysis.

I try not to, but it appears everyone else relies on the Supreme Court, so comedians are obviously en vogue when it comes to rulings.

I still don't get why the Constitution requires Congress to decide spending, but a president can in effect veto without risk of override. "Sure, I will sign the bill earmarking $X for this initiative but I have no plans whatsoever to do it" makes no sense in a checks and balances viewpoint. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 9:48 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Don’t rely on comedians for your constitutional analysis.

I try not to, but it appears everyone else relies on the Supreme Court, so comedians are obviously en vogue when it comes to rulings.

I still don't get why the Constitution requires Congress to decide spending, but a president can in effect veto without risk of override. "Sure, I will sign the bill earmarking $X for this initiative but I have no plans whatsoever to do it" makes no sense in a checks and balances viewpoint. 

 

Im not sure your summary of the conundrum is correct. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 10:16 am
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

@bradstevens 

In what way? Am I wrong that spending bills come from Congress? Am I wrong a president can veto a bill they do not like? Am I correct that the Supreme Court struck down the line item veto on spending bills?

Describe how choosing not to spend appropriated money differs from a line item veto.

We will see how tariffs plays out. We know in the student loan case that the president had emergency powers to amend the program. For that reason I thought it was a closer call than most but agreed amend did not mean cancel.

So, in tariffs, does regulate mean "add tariffs". If it does, why give the power to Congress in the Constitution when a president fully has the power to add, or it would follow, subtract tariffs? I am not a lawyer, simple logic dictates the Founders would not give Congress powers that a president can ignore at will. These men had fought against a king, are we really arguing a president should have the same powers than a king?

The Tea Act was wildly unpopular in the US. It actually reduced the price of tea in the US, but it was viewed by Americans of creating a precedent that taxes could be added to the colonies. Fast forward to today. Tariffs are very much what the Tea Act was. It is a way to allow a president to increase taxes on Americans without Congress having any input. That is exactly why the Boston Tea Party happened 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 11:11 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

@bradstevens 

In what way? Am I wrong that spending bills come from Congress? Am I wrong a president can veto a bill they do not like? Am I correct that the Supreme Court struck down the line item veto on spending bills?

Describe how choosing not to spend appropriated money differs from a line item veto.

We will see how tariffs plays out. We know in the student loan case that the president had emergency powers to amend the program. For that reason I thought it was a closer call than most but agreed amend did not mean cancel.

So, in tariffs, does regulate mean "add tariffs". If it does, why give the power to Congress in the Constitution when a president fully has the power to add, or it would follow, subtract tariffs? I am not a lawyer, simple logic dictates the Founders would not give Congress powers that a president can ignore at will. These men had fought against a king, are we really arguing a president should have the same powers than a king?

The Tea Act was wildly unpopular in the US. It actually reduced the price of tea in the US, but it was viewed by Americans of creating a precedent that taxes could be added to the colonies. Fast forward to today. Tariffs are very much what the Tea Act was. It is a way to allow a president to increase taxes on Americans without Congress having any input. That is exactly why the Boston Tea Party happened 

I'll do my best.  Link the SCt case you take issue with.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 11:50 am
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

@bradstevens when the tariff one happens, we can discuss it. Here is one of the others.

https://www.scotusblog.com/2025/09/supreme-court-allows-trump-administration-to-withhold-billions-in-foreign-aid-funding/

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 12:19 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Describe how choosing not to spend appropriated money differs from a line item veto.

When the appropriation includes a delegation of authority to the executive about how to spend the money.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 1:58 pm
👍
3
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

Posted by: @the-leal-deal
↑

https://twitter.com/billmaher/status/1987013497432289593?s=46&t=RqAzYMWPzX-OinhMiXHkng

Good topic

Maher doesn’t understand . . .

The extent of separation of powers

Article II authority

The scope and limits of judicial review under Article III and M v. M.

The nature and scope of discretion exclusively within the authority of President

That judges have no authority to overturn an executive  decision solely because a judge thinks the decision is unreasonable or the evidence would lead the judge to a different decision.

 

other than these issues, Maher is spot on.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 2:05 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

When the appropriation includes a delegation of authority to the executive about how to spend the money.

Can you describe the difference between "how to spend the money" and "weather to spend the money". Those are not identical, feel free to state the case they are.

It is like the student loan issue. The president was granted power to alter loans. I agreed that did not include cancel loans. Exact same point . 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 3:58 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@arthur-dent 

I don’t follow. Just  cuz an agency has money doesn’t mean they must spend it.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 4:56 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

@bradstevens when the tariff one happens, we can discuss it. Here is one of the others.

https://www.scotusblog.com/2025/09/supreme-court-allows-trump-administration-to-withhold-billions-in-foreign-aid-funding/

 

The linked article discusses an order that stayed the enforcement of a lower corut order. That's it. It's not a merit-based decision.  So I think you're overstating what the court has decided.  

Maher and others need to keep some things in mind when talking about the Supreme Court and what it does:  (1) issues that reach the Court are, in the vast majority of instances, complex and deal with important and conflicting interests which means either side could win and it would still be in the realm of a reasonable outcome; and (2) the people on the SCt and their clerks are smart people.

If they kept these things in mind, people wouldn't make outlandish statements like "the SCt just authorized the President to use Seal Team 6 to take out his political rivals." 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 5:54 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@arthur-dent 

I don’t follow. Just  cuz an agency has money doesn’t mean they must spend it.  

So Congress includes funding for a program and the prez can say, "nope"?

In the case of USAid, we actually refused to pay contracts for work completed.

 

The Supreme Court considered the impoundment question in Train v. City of New York (1975) after the ICA was passed. The city sued after it did not receive funds allocated to it under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act Amendments. President Nixon had vetoed the bill, but Congress overrode the veto. Nixon then reduced program spending. In his unanimous opinion, Justice Byron White wrote that “the sole issue before us is whether the 1972 Act permits the Administrator to allot to the States under § 205(a) less than the entire amounts authorized to be appropriated by § 207. We hold that the Act does not permit such action, and affirm the Court of Appeals.”

https://www.constitutioncenter.org/blog/can-a-president-refuse-to-spend-funds-approved-by-congress

We know Reagan wanted a line item veto on budget bills Logically, why would a president need a line item if they can just ignore the passed budget? In your scenario Reagan had it but was surrounded be people too stupid to realize it?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 5:57 pm
👍
2
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@arthur-dent 

There is no one size fits all. Some appropriations are mandatory and others are within the discretion of the executive branch. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/08/2025 9:17 pm
😂
👍
2
Joe_Hoopsier
(@barry_seal)
Noble Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

When the appropriation includes a delegation of authority to the executive about how to spend the money.

Can you describe the difference between "how to spend the money" and "weather to spend the money". Those are not identical, feel free to state the case they are.

It is like the student loan issue. The president was granted power to alter loans. I agreed that did not include cancel loans. Exact same point . 

On Reddit, there was a gal celebrating her completion of her MA in English and Creative writing. I simply said that now she can find a creative way to say "do you want fries with that". And that's how the fight started. 

 


Tantrums don't change outcomes
Losing is part of life. Sometimes the answer is simply NO.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 11/14/2025 10:39 am
Page 1 / 2
Share: