@aloha-hoosier what rfk says is of absolutely no moment to this lawsuit
I didn’t say it was. I’m merely wondering why COH was so quick to claim RFK didn’t say what RFK said.@aloha-hoosier what rfk says is of absolutely no moment to this lawsuit
@mcm666 False advertisement? Concealment? If there is no direct evidence, what was concealed? For a long time pregnant women have been urged to use it under doctor's supervision, is that false advertising?
RFK spoke in terms of causation and Art posted in terms of correlation.
I think correlation can be established under the burden of proof applicable to civil cases. But causation is required.
How much of a correlation greater than random would you want to be warned about?
I said above that causation is the required standard of proof. I need to modify that. In a duty to warn case, causation is not required.
@co-hoosier sure it is coh. much of this turns on what the state stat requires for elements etc. i have no idea how those cases play out under tx law and what showing is reqd.
here's the prayer
PRAYER
189.
The State prays that the Court enter judgment in its favor and, among other things:
a. Enjoin Defendants from engaging in any deceptive or unfair trade practice related to
the manufacturing, distributing, advertising, or selling of Tylenol in Texas;
b. Order Defendants to destroy any marketing or advertising materials in their possession
that represent, directly or indirectly, that Tylenol is safe for pregnant women and
children or that Tylenol does not cause ASD/ADHD in children whose mothers take
the drug during pregnancy or in young children who take the drug;
c. Order Defendants to pay civil penalties to the State in the amount of $10,000 per
DTPA violation;
d. Order disgorgement of Defendants’ assets, as provided by law and equity;
e. Attach the assets of Johnson & Johnson equivalent to the value of the fraudulent
transfer of its assets to Kenvue;
f.
Enjoin Defendants from disposing of other corporate assets;
47
g. Order Defendants to pay pre-judgment and post-judgment interest on all monetary
awards, as provided by law;
h. Order Defendants to pay all court costs, investigatory costs, and the State’s attorneys’
fees, as provided by law; and
i.
Grant the State such other relief which is proper and just.
@arthur-dent here's what they are alleging
@mcm666 looks like a statutory consumer protection claim.
I thought a failed duty to warn about a low probability risk doesn’t require proof of causation in the a particular case before the court. But I’ve been out of that game for decades.
I didn’t say it was. I’m merely wondering why COH was so quick to claim RFK didn’t say what RFK said.@aloha-hoosier what rfk says is of absolutely no moment to this lawsuit
You know why.
@co-hoosier That didn't answer the question. You said RFK didn't say what he said and I'm wondering why you were so quick to do that. I found it interesting because it was a direct quote from the article and I assumed you would have read it rather than jump to a conclusion like that.
I agree with you on the lawsuit, but that wasn't my question.
@hurryinghoosiers yes this is who real dems prefer to guide our health. fat trannies
No clue who that is but can't be any worse than the unqualified spineless conspiracy loving ass hats that Trump appoints
At minimum we need someone who follows the science and data. Definitely not what we have now
I suppose Texas is about to go after antibiotic manufacturers. 1) antibiotics first became available to the public in 1945, but over prescription became a thing in the 50s. Those kids reached adulthood in the 70s, look at when obesity took off in America.
2) ranchers give antibiotics to cows because it fattens them. Some of those antibiotics leach into humans eating beef. Europe outlawed this use, the US tried but repealed after ranchers mobilized.
3) a study of English children showed a correlation:
The researchers looked at data collected from more than 11,000 children born in Avon, U.K., in 1991 and 1992. Those who had been treated with antibiotics in the first 6 months of their lives had a higher chance of being overweight at 10, 20, and 38 months of age.
https://www.science.org/content/article/do-antibiotics-make-us-fat
So, is that proof? Are we ready to destroy antibiotic manufacturers? This data is every bit as compelling as the Tylenol data.
Again, correlation is NOT causation. It isn't in either case. We are entering a dangerous cycle if we equate the two.
RFK spoke in terms of proof of causation. I think the studies show an association greater than random, which is correlation. But not causation. The writers of the article don’t understand what they’ve said.
Simply amazing.RFK spoke in terms of proof of causation. I think the studies show an association greater than random, which is correlation. But not causation. The writers of the article don’t understand what they’ve said.
