If a giant, booming voice appeared to all people on Earth at the same time and said "I am God. I can do anything. Ask and I will do it." And then it did exactly that, you don't think a scientist would be convinced in that entity's existence? If true, that person wouldn't be a scientist.Yes, because I didn’t mean “problem” as a pejorative or a criticism, only as a nominative standing for the conflict between the system of inquiry and the religious viewpoint McM was asking about.
Well, I'll disagree here. A scientist can start out with a belief there is no God, but if he is a scientist, could be convinced God exists with evidence. But there is none.
Alternatively, all sorts of religious belief has been disproven by science--like the Earth is not 6,000 years to bring it back to this thread--and religious people don't take account of it or operate with cognitive dissonance or move the goalposts.
Oh, wow. Yeah, we'll have to disagree here. A true scientist can never be convinced God exists, because God by definition isn't constrained by natural laws, and therefore cannot be studied scientifically.
A true scientist would observe that a voice said this and did that, and then try to explain it with natural explanations. As soon as it is outside natural law, science fails.
Who created the Creators? There has to be an original reality that gave rise to the original simulation.@bradstevens just for fun, there is a theory our universe is a simulation. IF that is true, doesn't that greatly open up the idea of a Creator. Someone/something is on the other side of the simulator.
As to 6000 years old, only some believe that.
Turtles all the way down.
Time seems to not be a fundamental property of our universe. So IF this is a simulation, we have no clue if the creation on the other side has a beginning or end. We can't really comprehend that, but we also can't really comprehend infinity (which the universe might be).
Though I see there is a physicist suggesting infinity does not exist, not even in numbers. Who knows.
But I have seen an interview with Brian Cox saying how the size of our universe is so big it is incomprehensible to humans. Who knows what a creating universe would be like.
It is all theory, I liked the simulation theory 10 years ago. But there is no way of proving it. The inside a black hole theory though answer dark energy and that makes it feel better.
Don't scientists say there been like 5 or 6 mass extinction events going back over 400 million years?
Who created the Creators? There has to be an original reality that gave rise to the original simulation.@bradstevens just for fun, there is a theory our universe is a simulation. IF that is true, doesn't that greatly open up the idea of a Creator. Someone/something is on the other side of the simulator.
As to 6000 years old, only some believe that.
How was there ever anything? Where did the very first thing that ever existed come from? I've never heard a good answer to that.
@bradstevens This is the root for my general faith. Every condition, beginnings theory, stories about Creation... Any and all of it... something had to create it, start it, get it rolling... And I don't think humans are wired to understand it. "We" certainly have many other limitations, why not this one?"
I got in to a heated conversation with a college physics professor that was belittling a fellow classmate for challenging his assertion that "something can come from nothing"...using elements of quantum physics as his main argument. For every point he made...I just responded, "what created that phenomena"... "what created the vaccum?"... He didn't like my endless challenges.
I personally think really smart physicists, are usually also incredibly narcissistic... and avoid the "next step", which is impossible for any of us to understand. Conversely, I think there are quite a lot of very narcassistic, religious people that hard line believe their own religions story of creation, without any regard to scientific evidence. I think quantum physics, spontaneous combustion, etc... is a very plausible way to describe some of the earliest stages of our existence. But it doesn't explain the actual start of it all.
@bradstevens This is the root for my general faith. Every condition, beginnings theory, stories about Creation... Any and all of it... something had to create it, start it, get it rolling... And I don't think humans are wired to understand it. "We" certainly have many other limitations, why not this one?"
I got in to a heated conversation with a college physics professor that was belittling a fellow classmate for challenging his assertion that "something can come from nothing"...using elements of quantum physics as his main argument. For every point he made...I just responded, "what created that phenomena"... "what created the vaccum?"... He didn't like my endless challenges.
I personally think really smart physicists, are usually also incredibly narcissistic... and avoid the "next step", which is impossible for any of us to understand. I think quantum physics, spontaneous combustion, etc... is a very plausible way to describe some of the earliest stages of our existence. But it doesn't explain the actual start of it all.
There is obviously an answer to those questions but as you said I don't think we as humans can possibly understand it. Doesn't matter if you're Einstein or Musk it is still well above your head. Maybe we'll find out after we die.
And you never will.Who created the Creators? There has to be an original reality that gave rise to the original simulation.@bradstevens just for fun, there is a theory our universe is a simulation. IF that is true, doesn't that greatly open up the idea of a Creator. Someone/something is on the other side of the simulator.
As to 6000 years old, only some believe that.
How was there ever anything? Where did the very first thing that ever existed come from? I've never heard a good answer to that.
Why does it have to have a start? People who believe in an all powerful God scoff at the question “but who created God” and say he doesn’t need a creator. Well, then why can’t you say the same for existence.@bradstevens This is the root for my general faith. Every condition, beginnings theory, stories about Creation... Any and all of it... something had to create it, start it, get it rolling... And I don't think humans are wired to understand it. "We" certainly have many other limitations, why not this one?"
I got in to a heated conversation with a college physics professor that was belittling a fellow classmate for challenging his assertion that "something can come from nothing"...using elements of quantum physics as his main argument. For every point he made...I just responded, "what created that phenomena"... "what created the vaccum?"... He didn't like my endless challenges.
I personally think really smart physicists, are usually also incredibly narcissistic... and avoid the "next step", which is impossible for any of us to understand. Conversely, I think there are quite a lot of very narcassistic, religious people that hard line believe their own religions story of creation, without any regard to scientific evidence. I think quantum physics, spontaneous combustion, etc... is a very plausible way to describe some of the earliest stages of our existence. But it doesn't explain the actual start of it all.
And you never will.Who created the Creators? There has to be an original reality that gave rise to the original simulation.@bradstevens just for fun, there is a theory our universe is a simulation. IF that is true, doesn't that greatly open up the idea of a Creator. Someone/something is on the other side of the simulator.
As to 6000 years old, only some believe that.
How was there ever anything? Where did the very first thing that ever existed come from? I've never heard a good answer to that.
The universe is one of those things that just tend to happen from time to time.
The universe is one of those things that just tend to happen from time to time.
interesting stuff. especially the genesis of it all and working in the good lord. i remember well being in grade school. well that's how it started. but who created god.
threads like this it would be nice to have someone properly educated who could contribute. a theologian. a man of the cloth. a bible scholar.
hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
interesting stuff. especially the genesis of it all and working in the good lord. i remember well being in grade school. well that's how it started. but who created god.
threads like this it would be nice to have someone properly educated who could contribute. a theologian. a man of the cloth. a bible scholar.
hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
Yeah, where is TMP?
.
@bulk-vh not sure. i wasn't aware of him attending one of hte bible colleges

