Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

David Brooks: Why I...
 
Notifications
Clear all

David Brooks: Why I am not a liberal

Page 2 / 4
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@arthur-dent 

The problem with that study is that the increase in income and the better math and reading scores are probably a product of the same cause. 

here is another study specifically looking at free breakfast programs for the poor.

 A new study from the University of Iowa reinforces the connection between good nutrition and good grades, finding that free school breakfasts help students from low-income families perform better academically.

https://now.uiowa.edu/news/2015/03/better-breakfast-better-grades

 

Not sure that proves cause and effect but it makes sense.  

Brooks’s best point is that it isnt all about the money. It’s also about culture and instilling certain values.  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 09/21/2025 12:34 pm
👍
2
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Brooks’s best point is that it isnt all about the money. It’s also about culture and instilling certain values.  

That I believe to be a valid point, to an extent. Getting us to agree on what values will be tough. And getting school to teach any values parents/family do not share may/may not work.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 2:11 pm
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Brooks’s best point is that it isnt all about the money. It’s also about culture and instilling certain values.  

That I believe to be a valid point, to an extent. Getting us to agree on what values will be tough. And getting school to teach any values parents/family do not share may/may not work.

Especially when a segment of the population believes being on time, working hard, being modest and polite, and valuing a meritocracy is equivalent to white supremacy.  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 09/21/2025 4:13 pm
👍
3
Bulk VH
(@bulk-vh)
Member Moderator

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Brooks’s best point is that it isnt all about the money. It’s also about culture and instilling certain values.  

That I believe to be a valid point, to an extent. Getting us to agree on what values will be tough. And getting school to teach any values parents/family do not share may/may not work.

Especially when a segment of the population believes being on time, working hard, being modest and polite, and valuing a meritocracy is equivalent to white supremacy.  

 

And another segment believes that women, especially of color, don't belong in positions of leadership, gay people are an abomination, and the suppression and erosion of free speech is just fine if it's against the current POTUS.

 


.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 4:35 pm
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @bulk-vh
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Brooks’s best point is that it isnt all about the money. It’s also about culture and instilling certain values.  

That I believe to be a valid point, to an extent. Getting us to agree on what values will be tough. And getting school to teach any values parents/family do not share may/may not work.

Especially when a segment of the population believes being on time, working hard, being modest and polite, and valuing a meritocracy is equivalent to white supremacy.  

 

And another segment believes that women, especially of color, don't belong in positions of leadership, gay people are an abomination, and the suppression and erosion of free speech is just fine if it's against the current POTUS.

 

I brought up the ones I did because we are focusing on bringing people out of poverty.  I don't agree with the beliefs you list, but I don't think they keep people in poverty.  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 09/21/2025 4:48 pm
Bulk VH
(@bulk-vh)
Member Moderator

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @bulk-vh
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Brooks’s best point is that it isnt all about the money. It’s also about culture and instilling certain values.  

That I believe to be a valid point, to an extent. Getting us to agree on what values will be tough. And getting school to teach any values parents/family do not share may/may not work.

Especially when a segment of the population believes being on time, working hard, being modest and polite, and valuing a meritocracy is equivalent to white supremacy.  

 

And another segment believes that women, especially of color, don't belong in positions of leadership, gay people are an abomination, and the suppression and erosion of free speech is just fine if it's against the current POTUS.

 

I brought up the ones I did because we are focusing on bringing people out of poverty.  I don't agree with the beliefs you list, but I don't think they keep people in poverty.  

 

My apologies.

However, I was merely highlighting more examples of how hard it is to find common ground these days, especially where our school-aged children are concerned.

Carry on.

 


.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 4:51 pm
👍
1
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

I brought up the ones I did because we are focusing on bringing people out of poverty.  I don’t agree with the beliefs you list, but I don’t think they keep people in poverty.  

There are any number of types of poverty, from the homeless mentally ill to the single mother who can't afford to fix her car or go to the doctor and everything in between. Each require different approaches. Poverty will never be eradicated, but it can be ameliorated. Sometimes the best you can do is try and help someone get through the day. 

My wife used to pass a street beggar who had a spot on her drive to work. She would stop at McDs and get a couple McDoubles, and then get a couple tall boys from Big Red across the street and drop them off with him on her way home. Eventually, he quit showing up. No telling if she helped him enough to make a difference in his life, but there's no doubt she made a difference in his day.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 5:34 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Brooks’s best point is that it isnt all about the money. It’s also about culture and instilling certain values.  

That I believe to be a valid point, to an extent. Getting us to agree on what values will be tough. And getting school to teach any values parents/family do not share may/may not work.

Especially when a segment of the population believes being on time, working hard, being modest and polite, and valuing a meritocracy is equivalent to white supremacy.  

 

A segment of society also doesn't give a crap about modest and polite, working hard is living off a trust fund and being on time is for suckers because wealth and power means others bend to your time. Oh, and if great granpappy left you 100 million, that means you merited it.

Fortunately most of us are not in either description. 

I do think more than above feel the American dream no longer applies to their case, heck, I heard it often growing up white trash. Kids from our neighborhood don't make the basketball team, don't have a chance at good jobs, police harass them, and college is impossible because no one has that kind of money.

That is what concerns me. How do we eliminate that. Kids choose gangs because they believe there is no way out without a jump shot. Work like a dog for the dollar general isn't going to get you out, even if they hire you. 

I don't have a good answer to convince kids they can get out with hard work and no jump shot. In Appalachia they have the dream of mining, seems to at least give kids some hope of decent money. But other kids lack that example. Maybe tell kids from poor neighborhoods we will send them to a trade school free after HS. Hell, maybe instead of HS. Work hard, score enough to show you can read and write, we will teach you to weld, or be an electrician.

I had a brother-in-law from Tennessee, couldn't read or write his name, but he was a damn fine mechanic. Everything today is far more complex, you aren't becoming a successful auto mechanic without reading and writing. He would have been an example of someone with no real hope today 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 6:04 pm
snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

 @mcm666 the Covid spending spree made housing and food less affordable.  I'm arguing that we cannot lift people out of poverty without actually productivity growth. It happens when companies like Tesla figure out driverless cars and drive down the cost 90%.  Every time we take money from the private sector and redistribute it to the public sector you slow growth and prosperity a little.  If you keep it at a reasonable amount, it's not a huge deal.  The problem is people think if you just add one more redistribution program the poor people will magically become productive citizens (net producers and not takers is what I mean). I disagree with that and you'll also end up ruining the overall economy eventually like several European nations.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 6:16 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

A segment of society also doesn’t give a crap about modest and polite, working hard is living off a trust fund and being on time is for suckers because wealth and power means others bend to your time. Oh, and if great granpappy left you 100 million, that means you merited it.

You think those types of beliefs/values cause poverty?  

And you really think what you just listed is as big a problem right now in our society as a list of things a government run organization put out to "combat racism?"  Come on, Marv.  Just admit that yes, woke is bad and this particular type that comes from the left is not just stupid, but counterproductive:

https://www.newsweek.com/smithsonian-race-guidelines-rational-thinking-hard-work-are-white-values-1518333


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 09/21/2025 6:22 pm
IUCrazy2's avatar
(@iucrazy2)
Reputable Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Last May a study came out suggesting that merely giving people money doesn’t do much to lift them out of poverty. Families with at least one child received $333 a month. They had more money to spend, which is a good thing, but the children fared no better than similar children who didn’t get the cash. They were no more likely to develop language skills or demonstrate cognitive development. They were no more likely to avoid behavioral problems or developmental delays.

These results shouldn’t have been a big surprise. As Kelsey Piper noted in an essay for The Argument, a different study published last year gave families $500 a month for two years and found no big effects on the adult recipients’ psychological well-being and financial security. A study that gave $1,000 a month did not produce better health, career, education or sleep outcomes or even more time with their children.

Way back in 1997, Susan E. Mayer, a University of Chicago sociologist and behavioral economist, published “What Money Can’t Buy.” She began her research believing that cash transfers would make a big difference in people’s lives but was persuaded by the evidence that even if you doubled a family’s income, it would have a limited effect on their children’s dropout and teenage pregnancy rates or other outcomes. She stated her findings clearly: “The results in this book imply that once children’s basic material needs are met, characteristics of their parents become more important to how they turn out than anything additional money can buy.”

She added, “Parental income is not as important to children’s outcomes as many social scientists have thought.” Rising out of poverty also requires the nonmaterial qualities we now call human capital, such as skills, diligence, honesty, good health and reliability. Mayer concludes, “Children of parents with these attributes do well even when their parents do not have much income.”

As a society, we are pretty good at transferring money to the poor, but we’re not very good at nurturing the human capital they would need to get out of poverty. As a result, we do an OK job supporting people who are in long-term poverty but a poor job of helping them lift out of poverty. As Piper noted in a subsequent post, we spend more money combating poverty today than the entire U.S. G.D.P. from 1969, yet “the share of Americans whose pretransfer income places them in absolute poverty has barely fallen.”

Piper’s essay kicked up a bit of an internet storm. You might have thought the progressive reaction would have been: We need to keep giving poor people money, but we also need to focus on the human and behavioral factors that will enable them to build comfortable, independent lives. But that wasn’t the reaction. The progressives I saw doubled down on the thesis: Poor people just need money.

Matt Bruenig’s contention, also in The Argument, was typical. He scorned the very idea that focusing on human capital is a good way to improve social mobility. He wrote, “Cash is the key part of every welfare state in the developed world and absolutely critical for keeping poverty down.” We shouldn’t make fighting poverty overly complicated, he argued. “As a policy matter, these are mostly solved problems.” Just write people checks.

This is consistent with something I’ve noticed all my life — the materialist bent of progressive thought: the assumption that material conditions drive history, not cultural or moral ones. A couple of decades ago, Thomas Frank published “What’s the Matter With Kansas?” based on befuddlement that Kansans were apparently voting against their economic self-interest. Doesn’t economics drive voting behavior? Progressives have often argued that improving schools is mostly about spending more money, that crime is mostly the product of material deprivation.

Conservatism, as you know, is a complete mess in America right now. But reading conservative authors like Edmund Burke, Samuel Johnson, Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Gertrude Himmelfarb and James Q. Wilson does give you an adequate appreciation for the power of nonmaterial forces — culture, moral norms, traditions, religious ideals, personal responsibility and community cohesion. That body of work teaches you, as Burke wrote, that manners and morals are more important than laws. You should have limited expectations about politics because not everything can be solved with a policy.

Many years ago, I came across a study that neatly illustrated the power of culture. The researcher Nima Sanandaji calculated the poverty rate of Americans with Swedish ancestry. It was 6.7 percent. They also looked at the poverty rate in Sweden, using the American standard of poverty, and it was also 6.7 percent. Different political systems, same outcome.

Neoconservatism came along and took conservative insights and applied them to policymaking. During the Iraq war the word “neocon” came to mean the opposite of its real meaning, but originally it was a movement within the Democratic Party to correct the policy failures of the Great Society. Thinkers like Irving Kristol and Nathan Glazer had been poor immigrant kids. They were willing to spend money to fight poverty, but they wanted the programs to nurture the values that they had seen firsthand help people rise: hard work, family and community cohesion, reliability, a passionate commitment to education. These values tend to inhere in communities before they are transmitted to individuals.

Progressives, by contrast, are quick to talk about money but slow to talk about the values side of the equation. That’s in part for the best of reasons. They don’t want to blame the victims or contribute to the canard that people are poor because they are lazy.

But there’s something deeper. Progressivism emerges from a different lineage. Karl Marx influenced many people who are not Marxist, and he saw the world through a material-determinism lens — people’s consciousnesses are shaped by their material conditions.

Since the dawn of the Progressive movement over a century ago, the left has been more technocratic. Those early Progressives tried to make a science of society and govern according to scientific principles.

Today the social sciences are the narrow doorway all of human knowledge has to pass through if it’s going to influence policymaking. We want studies! The social sciences are great. I use them all the time. But when overly quantitative, they can misrepresent reality. They see only what can be quantified. They see only masses of people whose data can be tabulated, not unique individuals. As Christian Smith, a Notre Dame sociologist, has been arguing for decades, the social scientists obliterate the subjective experiences of the people they study. Human agency disappears if research subjects are reduced to a bunch of variables that can be correlated. People who overly rely on social science knowledge are going to tend to focus on money because it can be counted more easily than culture. People who rely on government to solve problems will tend to overemphasize the power of money because that’s the thing government most easily controls.

This materialistic bent leads to all sorts of bad judgments. For example, Joe Biden and his team had one job: to make sure Donald Trump never set foot in the White House again. They tried to accomplish that the only way they knew how: throw money at the problem. The vast bulk of the new Biden spending went to red states to employ workers without college degrees. Politically, the project was a complete failure. Populism is not primarily economic; it’s about respect, values, national identity and many other things. All that spending did not win anybody over.

Today most of our problems are moral, relational and spiritual more than they are economic. There is the crisis of disconnection, the collapse of social trust, the loss of faith in institutions, the destruction of moral norms in the White House, the rise of amoral gangsterism around the world.

I’ve been driven away from the right over the past decade, but I can’t join the left because I just don’t think that tradition of thought grasps reality in all its fullness. I wish both right and left could embrace the more complex truth that the neocon Democrat Daniel Patrick Moynihan expressed in his famous maxim: “The central conservative truth is that it is culture, not politics, that determines the success of a society. The central liberal truth is that politics can change culture and save it from itself.”

If you can find some lefties who are willing to spend money fighting poverty but also willing to promote the traditional values and practices that enable people to rise, you can sign me up for the revolution.

Your turn to the light continues.  Wink  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 6:25 pm
McM666's avatar
(@mcm666)
Famed Member

@snarlcakes Covid wasn’t means tested. It flooded the market and set fire to inflation. Means tested. Conditional. Dates certain for termination in lieu of certain programs not in addition to is what I’m saying. And would save a boatload on overhead payroll benes on and on 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 6:28 pm
👍
1
snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

@mcm666 I like the less spending part, but we're not going to agree.  If someone isn't productive enough to provide food and shelter for themselves, I don't see how giving them money fixes it.  

It's extremely easy for a healthy person with an IQ of 90+ to provide the basics for themselves.  The people we're discussing most likely have a major disability, mental illness, or very low IQ.  Giving stuff to them for free isn't going to fix it and suddenly make them more productive. The best way to help those people is for the rest of us to be as productive as possible. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 6:52 pm
McM666's avatar
(@mcm666)
Famed Member

@snarlcakes I hear ya. The way I look at it is we’re going to give them money anyway. So what method will give us the most bang for the buck.  It’s not programs in countless areas. Cash would be better. Fing outreach at the y in the hood no one attends and requires multiple grants to give social workers a job


ReplyQuote
Posted : 09/21/2025 6:57 pm
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

@mcm666 I like the less spending part, but we're not going to agree.  If someone isn't productive enough to provide food and shelter for themselves, I don't see how giving them money fixes it.  

It's extremely easy for a healthy person with an IQ of 90+ to provide the basics for themselves.  The people we're discussing most likely have a major disability, mental illness, or very low IQ.  Giving stuff to them for free isn't going to fix it and suddenly make them more productive. The best way to help those people is for the rest of us to be as productive as possible. 

I'm glad you recognize the IQ thing and how important it is in these discussions.  

Re your cutoff, I'd just note there are twice as many people in the US with IQs under 90 as there are people in poverty.  People should keep that in mind when they think more people than not in poverty deserve their lot.  

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 09/21/2025 7:08 pm
👍
4
Page 2 / 4
Share: