Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

The Letter From Bir...
 
Notifications
Clear all

The Letter From Birmingham Jail v. CR 65

Page 1 / 2
MyTeamIsOnTheFloor's avatar
(@myteamisonthefloor)
Honorable Member

Victor Davis Hanson used to be better. Post-Trump he has suffered from the same sickness of the 24/7 news cycle media - he must vomit out an hour a day or perish. But he occasionally returns to his intellectual roots, and this video is of those moments.

tl/dw version - “what does ‘execute the laws’ mean?” - doing nothing but litigating injunctions (Rule 65) prevents the public and permits SCOTUS from ever really resolving an issue, with “when can a President use national guard troops” being the latest example. 

The video is high-end legal riddle analysis wrapped in history of republics surrounded by social justice divided and multiplied bu US politics and folded into Trump dough. But is worth a listen and made my go back and read MLK’s Letter From Birmingham Jail - which is worth the ponder.

 

not saying I agree with everything Hanson says, but I am saying it makes smart fellers think deep thoughts.

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 12/27/2025 10:57 pm
👍
1
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @myteamisonthefloor
↑

not saying I agree with everything Hanson says, but I am saying it makes smart fellers think deep thoughts.

Leaves me out...


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 9:36 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @myteamisonthefloor
↑

Victor Davis Hanson used to be better. Post-Trump he has suffered from the same sickness of the 24/7 news cycle media - he must vomit out an hour a day or perish. But he occasionally returns to his intellectual roots, and this video is of those moments.

tl/dw version - “what does ‘execute the laws’ mean?” - doing nothing but litigating injunctions (Rule 65) prevents the public and permits SCOTUS from ever really resolving an issue, with “when can a President use national guard troops” being the latest example. 

The video is high-end legal riddle analysis wrapped in history of republics surrounded by social justice divided and multiplied bu US politics and folded into Trump dough. But is worth a listen and made my go back and read MLK’s Letter From Birmingham Jail - which is worth the ponder.

 

not saying I agree with everything Hanson says, but I am saying it makes smart fellers think deep thoughts.

 

Why does he keep randomly saying "Supreme Court dot gov?"  Is this AI generated?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 11:55 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

OK, I listened.  Hanson generally has this weird style in these oral essays he does.  He slings together a lot of historical and theoretical facts about government, republics, etc. that I think are spot on.  But his connections of those things is usually very winding, and in many cases, I think contradictory to other things he argues for, or at least not supported.  

Here, he correctly identifies that the dissent and majority are both addressing real issues that we should be concerned with.  He links all of this to things he's seen other republics face and which led to their downfall.  But I don't think any other republic has ever been so restrained by judicial power, so I'm not sure reference to the past is very helpful here. And I can't tell what he wants the SCt to have done. I wonder if there is a transcript of this since he quickly pivots from one issue to the next and it's difficult to nail down the logical links.  

Anyway, on the general point, he's right--the way in which the political parties swing back and forth, justifying or attacking judicial behavior and the constitution based on whether or not it benefits their short-term political interests--has greatly weakened US citizens trust in authority and the courts.  That crisis of legitimacy has a huge risk associated with it, and a hard-to-measure, but I believe very real, cost in the here and now.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 12:23 pm
👍
1
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@myteamisonthefloor 

I think the answer here is found in basic con law, and is only complicated because of the tendency of courts to issue Trump- centric rulings without regard to basic principles that pertain to any executive in the same or similar circumstances.

We start with understanding the differences between Article II and Article III of the constitution.  We need to keep in mind that not all presidential decisions are subject to judicial review. To hold otherwise would violate the separation of powers clearly stated in the Constitution.

In this case, Congress delegated to the president certain decision- making authority concerning the ability to use federalized troops when federal law can’t be enforced by regular means.

In order to use the statute the President is required to make certain determinations.  Whether the President met these threshold requirements is a proper subject of judicial review.  In this case one of the threshold decisions is a factual one concerning the effectiveness of regular law enforcement.  Trump decided that fact in favor of deploying the guard.  Chicago disputes that finding.  Ergo, the court must decide whether that requirement is satisfied. 

What standard should the court use?  Certainly not de novo since that would be the court substituting its judgment for the President’s judgment and a violation of separation of powers.  The standard should be similar to what an appellate court uses when it  reviews the findings of fact in a trial court, to wit:  If there is any evidence in the record to support the finding, the finding must be upheld.  The appellate court must not weigh the evidence nor consider conflicting evidence.

Similarly here. The president made a decision.  There is evidence to support his decision.  Further inquiry violates separation of powers.  Case over.  Trump wins.

Dont like the result?  That’s why we have elections.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 12:42 pm
👍
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@myteamisonthefloor 

I think the answer here is found in basic con law, and is only complicated because of the tendency of courts to issue Trump- centric rulings without regard to basic principles that pertain to any executive in the same or similar circumstances.

We start with understanding the differences between Article II and Article III of the constitution.  We need to keep in mind that not all presidential decisions are subject to judicial review. To hold otherwise would violate the separation of powers clearly stated in the Constitution.

In this case, Congress delegated to the president certain decision- making authority concerning the ability to use federalized troops when federal law can’t be enforced by regular means.

In order to use the statute the President is required to make certain determinations.  Whether the President met these threshold requirements is a proper subject of judicial review.  In this case one of the threshold decisions is a factual one concerning the effectiveness of regular law enforcement.  Trump decided that fact in favor of deploying the guard.  Chicago disputes that finding.  Ergo, the court must decide whether that requirement is satisfied. 

What standard should the court use?  Certainly not de novo since that would be the court substituting its judgment for the President’s judgment and a violation of separation of powers.  The standard should be similar to what an appellate court uses when it  reviews the findings of fact in a trial court, to wit:  If there is any evidence in the record to support the finding, the finding must be upheld.  The appellate court must not weigh the evidence nor consider conflicting evidence.

Similarly here. The president made a decision.  There is evidence to support his decision.  Further inquiry violates separation of powers.  Case over.  Trump wins.

Dont like the result?  That’s why we have elections.  

The threshold issue is what is required by the statute to invoke federal troops.  That's not a fact issue, it's a legal one and it doesn't involve "enforced by regular means," as you've argued, according to the Court. Read the order.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 12:59 pm
MyTeamIsOnTheFloor's avatar
(@myteamisonthefloor)
Honorable Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @myteamisonthefloor
↑

Victor Davis Hanson used to be better. Post-Trump he has suffered from the same sickness of the 24/7 news cycle media - he must vomit out an hour a day or perish. But he occasionally returns to his intellectual roots, and this video is of those moments.

tl/dw version - “what does ‘execute the laws’ mean?” - doing nothing but litigating injunctions (Rule 65) prevents the public and permits SCOTUS from ever really resolving an issue, with “when can a President use national guard troops” being the latest example. 

The video is high-end legal riddle analysis wrapped in history of republics surrounded by social justice divided and multiplied bu US politics and folded into Trump dough. But is worth a listen and made my go back and read MLK’s Letter From Birmingham Jail - which is worth the ponder.

 

not saying I agree with everything Hanson says, but I am saying it makes smart fellers think deep thoughts.

 

Why does he keep randomly saying "Supreme Court dot gov?"  Is this AI generated?

 

 

I think it was a verbal cite to the Supreme Court website where he was reading the Court opinion.

 

Truthfully, I felt like he was reading a script and this was maybe a draft video! But I think i got the points he was making.

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 12/28/2025 1:22 pm
👍
1
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@bradstevens 

I don’t buy the conclusion that “regular forces” means military.  That makes no sense.  It must mean civil enforcement if you mesh the statute with federal law enforcement authority.  This is all about federal criminal law, not state law.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 1:40 pm
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@bradstevens 

I don’t buy the conclusion that “regular forces” means military.  That makes no sense.  It must mean civil enforcement if you mesh the statute with federal law enforcement authority.  This is all about federal criminal law, not state law.  

Didn't the Court determine that it meant just that?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 1:48 pm
MyTeamIsOnTheFloor's avatar
(@myteamisonthefloor)
Honorable Member

@co-hoosier 
@bradstevens 

you both got to more complete conclusions I had not pondered out yet - i.e. did no research 

my first thought was about the level of public dissent/protests involved/required which led to my mind wandering late night to MLK’s non-judicial thoughts 

I also thought of Eisenhower’s publicly-stated justifications for sending troops to Little Rock.

 

I do not recall if/when/how Ike’s move was challenged - if at all. The facts were more developed. SCOTUS had addressed in “final” form whether “separate but equal” schools were permissible, said no, and ordered lower federal courts to oversee integration of schools “with all deliberate speed.” The Arkansas courts had done that. Ike had demanded/requested state and local officials take actions to stop local protests which opposed/were preventing some, but not all, local schools from complying with the SCOTUS/District Court decisions and local school board integration plans. Ike concluded that when local/state authorities would not/could not take nearly-immediate state/local action, “it was left to the federal executive” to step in and secure compliance with federal law vis-a-vis federal rights to equal protection/education rights.

Guess I’ll go read some law now … 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 12/28/2025 1:52 pm
👍
3
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@myteamisonthefloor 

I was thinking Ike and Little Rock as I wrote my post. I didn’t cite to that because I didn’t take the time to research it.  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 1:55 pm
👍
1
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@myteamisonthefloor 

Hanson’s implied point is that we are involved in this discussion because of the increasingly acerbic politics found in Democrat Chicago and Republican Washington.  I don’t think we would have this with Mayor Daley. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 2:02 pm
👍
3
MyTeamIsOnTheFloor's avatar
(@myteamisonthefloor)
Honorable Member

@co-hoosier i just came back to add that another potentially meaningful difference is that Trump currently challenges a CR 65 order, but Ike was past that and enforcing full and final decisions - which I guess was the beginning of Hanson’s ultimate beef. 

 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 12/28/2025 2:05 pm
MyTeamIsOnTheFloor's avatar
(@myteamisonthefloor)
Honorable Member

Posted by: @co-hoosier
↑

@bradstevens 

I don’t buy the conclusion that “regular forces” means military.  That makes no sense.  It must mean civil enforcement if you mesh the statute with federal law enforcement authority.  This is all about federal criminal law, not state law.  

 

at least initially, I also thought the court was saying “until you can’t restore compliance with regular federal military, you can’t federalize state national guard.” Which seems backasswards. (Also the 101st Airborne needing help from the Illinois National Guard seems unlikely!)

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 12/28/2025 2:11 pm
👍
2
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@myteamisonthefloor 

Irreparable harm would be an important /discussion. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/28/2025 2:19 pm
Page 1 / 2
Share: