California adopted an Independent Redistricting Commission by popular referendum some time back. The Dem majority isn’t going to be able to redistrict before 2026 without getting that overturned.
Per my link above this one...
The two state leaders are now considering a special election in November to ask voters to approve a proposal to temporarily give the power to redraw district lines back to the Democratic-led Legislature to try to send more Democrats to Congress. Sources told KCRA 3 that other Democratic leaders appear to be on board with the measure.
@receipt-keeper Actually, I don't think the top-two primary system is antidemocratic, and I'd say the same thing if heavily Republican states implemented it. Sometimes, a polity really does want to choose between two liberals or two conservatives. That's how these things work. If anything, forcing the final contest to be between one conservative and one liberal, even when the electorate doesn't want it, is antidemocratic.
I'm not sure I agree with you, but I respect the point of view. I see it through the lens of the tyranny of the majority. Not much different from what you referenced in Wisconsin.
Hope is not optimism, which expects things to turn out well, but something rooted in the conviction that there is good worth working for. - Seamus Heaney, Irish poet and likely Hoosier basketball fan.
POTFB
@receipt-keeper Actually, I don't think the top-two primary system is antidemocratic, and I'd say the same thing if heavily Republican states implemented it. Sometimes, a polity really does want to choose between two liberals or two conservatives. That's how these things work. If anything, forcing the final contest to be between one conservative and one liberal, even when the electorate doesn't want it, is antidemocratic.
I'm not sure I agree with you, but I respect the point of view. I see it through the lens of the tyranny of the majority. Not much different from what you referenced in Wisconsin.
Any district in which the final two are both from the same party is a district that party is going to win anyway. So one-party rule is a problem, but jungle primaries aren't the cause.
socialism
defund
open borders
that's a very real threat to our country. and period goes inside quotes
We're now the hunters.
https://twitter.com/EricLDaugh/status/1953446840688378064?t=6rTuF348AD1MgFzgeH_wGQ&s=19
@unclemark lmao, you’re working really hard to not talk about the dem states doing this crap. The height of hypocrisy is the Texas dems hiding in Illinois. Just admit it.
Yeah, that would be bad if it was true.
🎯
https://twitter.com/mattdizwhitlock/status/1952896857283146202?t=jkH0PB4Tlgmk5E6lzvwoQw&s=19
I don't think you want to go that route. Yes, the dem states are set up in Democrats favor, but if you take a state-by state look there are going to be a bunch of rep states where Democrats have a 40%+ population but are underrepresented by in the House.
Just from a quick look:
Ohio - Dems have about 45%, but only 5 of 15 seats
Pennsylvania - Dems have about 49%, but only 7 of 17 seats
Indiana - Dems have about 40%, but only 2 of 9 seats
Wisconsin - Dems have about 48%, but only 2 of 8 seats
Kentucky - Dems have about 34%, but only have 1 of 6 seats
Arizona - Dems have about 47%, but only have 3 of 9
Michigan is the only state I looked at where the representation is right (48% of the vote, 6 of 13 seats).
Point being: Both sides do it. Pretty much equally.
@unclemark Illinois doesn’t abuse gerrymandering?
They aren't redistributing mid decade. That's unprecedented outside court intervention. It's not supposed to be done at a whim for immediate political gain.
both sides do it about equally. And when I say "both sides" I mean people in power on both sides do it equally. They do it so they, the politicians, can stay in power. They, the politicians, aren't doing it for regular folks benefit. Not even remotely. When polled, regular folks from all over the political spectrum, uniformly agree that gerrymandering is bad. No one likes it.@unclemark Illinois doesn’t abuse gerrymandering?
We agree on so much but just can't get past the "well, Your side does it too." Who's side? I haven't gerrymandered shit.
@unclemark come on Mark, the Democrats have perfected the art of gerrymandering and its all politics. The republicans need to abuse it just like the Democrats.
Democrats haven't done a redistricting in mid decade. That's the issue.
Democrats haven't done a redistricting in mid decade. That's the issue.
So gerrymandering is OK as long as it's done every 10 years?
It's wrong either way. Yes it should be pointed out.
But being up in arms about it because it is happening mid-decade is kinda a weak argument.
Democrats haven't done a redistricting in mid decade. That's the issue.
So gerrymandering is OK as long as it's done every 10 years?
It's wrong either way. Yes it should be pointed out.
But being up in arms about it because it is happening mid-decade is kinda a weak argument.
Gerrymandering and redistricting are two different things. Redistricting mid decade is breaking yet another norm. It's a craven political gambit, much like what was done with the Garland nomination.
@unclemark Illinois doesn’t abuse gerrymandering?
They aren't redistributing mid decade. That's unprecedented outside court intervention. It's not supposed to be done at a whim for immediate political gain.
Texas is drawing the new map based on a lawsuit filed by Democrats and a letter from the DOJ stating 4 seats were racially gerrymandered