-
Sexual Overtones:Many social media users felt the ad's language and content were overtly sexualized and uncomfortable.
-
Eugenics and Nazi Propaganda:A significant portion of the criticism centered on the pun "good jeans" (a play on "good genes"), which some online users and news outlets linked to the language of eugenics and even Nazism, especially given the context of a seemingly conventionally attractive, white, blond-haired, blue-eyed model.
-
Ignoring Political Climate:Some progressive critics argued that the ad was out of touch and ignored the current political climate, particularly efforts to eliminate DEI initiatives and the history of eugenic rhetoric.
-
"Woke" Backlash:Conservatives seized on the progressive criticism, labeling it "woke" and a sign of "cancel culture run amok".
-
Traditional Advertising:Many on the right celebrated the campaign as a refreshing departure from what they saw as the overly diverse or "politically correct" advertising that came before, viewing it as a return to a more "traditional" approach that highlighted conventionally attractive women.
-
CulturalBacklash:
.
The controversy became a focal point for a broader cultural backlash against progressive social movements and politics, which some observers believe has been gaining momentum.
so according to AI the left started it and the right responded with typical woke cult. AI isn't the end all. best to use our own common sense still. why would the right initiate a response to a cute chick? they wouldn't. they would respond to it, which is precisely what happened in this case
American Eagle needs to keep this going by doing the same advertisement with a hot black chick and then one with a hot Asian chick. Exact same ads. That puts it right back in the wokesters overreaction and lets us all get to see more hot chicks! 😉
AI OverviewYes, the Sydney Sweeney American Eagle ad campaign controversy was fueled by progressives who criticized its sexual overtones and perceived eugenic messaging, while conservatives framed the backlash as "woke" overreaction and celebrated the ad as a return to traditional advertising. Some online users on platforms like TikTok and X suggested the campaign's "good jeans" pun, combined with Sweeney's blond, blue-eyed appearance, echoed eugenic ideas of genetic superiority.
Progressive Criticisms
Sexual Overtones:Many social media users felt the ad's language and content were overtly sexualized and uncomfortable.
Eugenics and Nazi Propaganda:A significant portion of the criticism centered on the pun "good jeans" (a play on "good genes"), which some online users and news outlets linked to the language of eugenics and even Nazism, especially given the context of a seemingly conventionally attractive, white, blond-haired, blue-eyed model.
Ignoring Political Climate:Some progressive critics argued that the ad was out of touch and ignored the current political climate, particularly efforts to eliminate DEI initiatives and the history of eugenic rhetoric.
Conservative Reactions
"Woke" Backlash:Conservatives seized on the progressive criticism, labeling it "woke" and a sign of "cancel culture run amok".
Traditional Advertising:Many on the right celebrated the campaign as a refreshing departure from what they saw as the overly diverse or "politically correct" advertising that came before, viewing it as a return to a more "traditional" approach that highlighted conventionally attractive women.
CulturalBacklash:.
The controversy became a focal point for a broader cultural backlash against progressive social movements and politics, which some observers believe has been gaining momentum.so according to AI the left started it and the right responded with typical woke cult. AI isn't the end all. best to use our own common sense still. why would the right initiate a response to a cute chick? they wouldn't. they would respond to it, which is precisely what happened in this case
You're smarter than that. They amplified it because it fits their culture war narrative. A fringe bit of the left got mad about something and then the entire (slight exag) right hopped on it to grossly misrepresent reality and try to portray the entire left side of the political aisle as woke and outraged.
@gros-louis lmao there's no reason for hte right to start it and they didn't. your premise was bs. it was started by the left, not the fringe, the typical left now, and responded to by the right. had it been a trannie in the ad the polar would have occurred and the right would have initiated the backlash to the ad and the left would have responded.
this isn't difficult ot follow. we have years of it now
@gros-louis lmao there's no reason for hte right to start it and they didn't. your premise was bs. it was started by the left, not the fringe, the typical left now, and responded to by the right. had it been a trannie in the ad the polar would have occurred and the right would have initiated the backlash to the ad and the left would have responded.
this isn't difficult ot follow. we have years of it now
The fringe left reacted to it, yes. Then MAGA portrayed it as the entire left and blew it way out of proportion. You're apparently just too stubborn. I've noticed that trait.
@gros-louis I’ve noticed the grating way in which you communicate. @oneeyedundertaker saw it with your discussions here too. I have a pretty good idea of your former handle
and there is no fringe left. That’s the party.
@bradstevens You’ll never convince me that the extreme left is CLOSE to the power or the craziness of the extreme right, let alone the obvious fact that there is no question that Trumpers are now the Republican Party.
@zeke4ahs appointed Harris Walz. AOC is the mouthpiece. The largest city in America they’ve chosen a socialist. Defund. Bail projects. Open borders. Socialism. Minor gender reassignments. The left is a fringe party and there is nothing crazier than the cult it has become. If allowed to run the country and cities they would destroy it in a decade.
@zeke4ahs appointed Harris Walz. AOC is the mouthpiece. The largest city in America they’ve chosen a socialist. Defund. Bail projects. Open borders. Socialism. Minor gender reassignments. The left is a fringe party and there is nothing crazier than the cult it has become. If allowed to run the country and cities they would destroy it in a decade.
I'd have no chance, Zeke. You're an unabashed partisan.@bradstevens You’ll never convince me that the extreme left is CLOSE to the power or the craziness of the extreme right, let alone the obvious fact that there is no question that Trumpers are now the Republican Party.
You don't live in an area that the progressive left controls. Instead, you see the worst of MAGA everyday. I'm in the opposite situation.
But in the pundit class, I've seen a remarkable asymmetry over the last 10 years or so. Mainstream Dems and Dem pundit hardly ever call out the wacky policy and opinions--instead gaslighting that it even exists, then accuse the right of a sinister conspiracy to create something out of nothing, changing the goalposts, etc. We've seen it right here in this thread, and back on the Water Cooler. Meanwhile, I hear hardcore conservatives pushing back on, and challenging Trump all the time, albeit in a rational way.
And more importantly to me, the inaneness of the progressives directly affects me in a way near and dear to my heart--my kids' education.
The problem is that the sane left doesn't get out ahead of this stuff and denounce it as stupid. They either support it or they believe they will lose electoral power by denouncing it. Either way, your premises are wrong. Or maybe the sane left is just severely miscalculating the power of the woke fringe of their party?@gros-louis lmao there's no reason for hte right to start it and they didn't. your premise was bs. it was started by the left, not the fringe, the typical left now, and responded to by the right. had it been a trannie in the ad the polar would have occurred and the right would have initiated the backlash to the ad and the left would have responded.
this isn't difficult ot follow. we have years of it now
The fringe left reacted to it, yes. Then MAGA portrayed it as the entire left and blew it way out of proportion. You're apparently just too stubborn. I've noticed that trait.
By the way, is MSNBC the "fringe" left?
...I hear hardcore conservatives pushing back on, and challenging Trump all the time...
Hardcore conservatives want free trade, until Trump orders them to LOVE tariffs.
They bend over say "Thank you sir, may I have another"
Hardcore conservatives want to follow the rule of law, until Trump orders them to LOVE detention centers and masked un-uniformed no-ID thugs pushing people (including citizens and green card holders) into unmarked cars.
They bend over say "Thank you sir, may I have another"
I could go on.
Nobody in his party has the stomach to stand up to Trump on absolutely anything, with the possible exception of the Epstein files.
"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451
@bradstevens this is a perfect summation. it also explains why academics in college towns don't get it; hollywood folks, wealthy celebs, on and on. theyre removed from teh daily impact of progressive policies so it's reduced to nothing more than a virtue signal devoid of consequence
