Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Retirement, Immigra...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Retirement, Immigration, & Ponzi Schemes

snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

https://twitter.com/onechancefreedm/status/1975307943068508530?s=46

A great explanation by Endgame on what is happening in the U.S. and around the world.  @larsiu this is why I continue to say social security is awful.  It's a Ponzi that just shifts wealth to one or two lucky generations before it crumbles.  

Also, @mapletom, yes, governments have been allowing much larger amounts of legal and illegal immigration to replace their declining populations. Replacement theory is correct, but the reason for doing it is to protect the current monetary system and governmental spending levels.  Mass immigration is just a bandaid and will only cause more problems.  Importing the third world in large swaths is a terrible policy.  It won't solve the issue. 

https://twitter.com/wallstreetmav/status/1975224349868388645?s=46

The left's response is Mamdami and socialism which will just make the problems worse and centralize more power.

https://twitter.com/kobeissiletter/status/1975358526034956665?s=46

The markets and foreign governments have smelled out the stress in the system and turned to gold and lesser degree Bitcoin.  @twenty I know you weren't a fan of gold and Bitcoin in the past, have you changed your perspective any? @jdb same question?

https://twitter.com/charliebilello/status/1974461342833680700?s=46

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 10/07/2025 7:23 am
larsIU
(@larsiu)
Noble Member

Snarl - we moved all our good paying middle class jobs to lower cost countries so we could maximize the almight profit driver for our capitalistic system. I understand your point but the genie's out of the bottle. Saying we can see the collapse is like being on the Titanic, spotting the iceberg, and screaming "full steam ahead."

 

We've not allowed (at least in the US) our populace any choice but to largely depend on Social Security for their retirement. I mean, unless you've got a fat pension funded by your employer. Oh, what's that? Nobody does? Well, there you go. 

 

it's not just that we tax and spend. It's why we HAVE to that will really get ya. We priorized profits (especially for those in the top 5%) over stability of work. 

Read Men Without Work and tell me how, wihtout reshoring all manufacturing alongside immigration reform, we get back to the Utopia of the 50's and 60's (economically) in the US? If those periods even were Utopian to begin with. We've dug our own grave and some of our people aren't getting out of the hole without social safety nets. Pulling the rug now is just mean or unfair or whatever we want to call it. 

 

To be sure, I don't fully agree with Eberstadt here but it is shining a light on a quesiton of why so many men don't work and have checked out. There was a pride to building cars or other manufacturing that doesn't exist with service work. It just doesn't. 

 

https://www.amazon.com/Men-Without-Work-audiobook/dp/B073K1FPT1/ref=sr_1_2?crid=3UPJBKTRFQ0H1&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.FHlRfffG37q3nhTwk6YjJxs9-LKkUn36qb7rMqjsXdj0perOHSnkUSgx4ytJhcKEnBmM3llVmeBJV6Pq6SEO8a3Pew1T4laTHxuvQskEqvk.Hy3dN3uDqO3F64eLoOGSZbIR808m5EDe7g4jrbM6tEo&dib_tag=se&keywords=men+without+work+nicholas+eberstadt&qid=1759845446&sprefix=men+without+work%2Caps%2C170&sr=8-2

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 10/07/2025 8:59 am
👍
5
Unknown's avatar
(@Anonymous)

Posted by: @larsiu
↑

Snarl - we moved all our good paying middle class jobs to lower cost countries so we could maximize the almight profit driver for our capitalistic system. I understand your point but the genie's out of the bottle. Saying we can see the collapse is like being on the Titanic, spotting the iceberg, and screaming "full steam ahead."

 

We've not allowed (at least in the US) our populace any choice but to largely depend on Social Security for their retirement. I mean, unless you've got a fat pension funded by your employer. Oh, what's that? Nobody does? Well, there you go. 

 

it's not just that we tax and spend. It's why we HAVE to that will really get ya. We priorized profits (especially for those in the top 5%) over stability of work. 

Read Men Without Work and tell me how, wihtout reshoring all manufacturing alongside immigration reform, we get back to the Utopia of the 50's and 60's (economically) in the US? If those periods even were Utopian to begin with. We've dug our own grave and some of our people aren't getting out of the hole with social safety nets. Pulling the rug now is just mean or unfair or whatever we want to call it. 

 

To be sure, I don't fully agree with Eberstadt here but it is shining a light on a quesiton of why so many men don't work and have checked out. There was a pride to building cars or other manufacturing that doesn't exist with service work. It just doesn't. 

 

https://www.amazon.com/Men-Without-Work-audiobook/dp/B073K1FPT1/ref=sr_1_2?crid=3UPJBKTRFQ0H1&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.FHlRfffG37q3nhTwk6YjJxs9-LKkUn36qb7rMqjsXdj0perOHSnkUSgx4ytJhcKEnBmM3llVmeBJV6Pq6SEO8a3Pew1T4laTHxuvQskEqvk.Hy3dN3uDqO3F64eLoOGSZbIR808m5EDe7g4jrbM6tEo&dib_tag=se&keywords=men+without+work+nicholas+eberstadt&qid=1759845446&sprefix=men+without+work%2Caps%2C170&sr=8-2

 

 

I have pushed everyone of my small business clients to set up SimpleIras. We have educated employees on contributing at least 3% of their pay because the employer can and will match 3%. You’d be surprised how many workers start with deferring 3% of their pay and then increase the deferral. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 10/07/2025 9:51 am
👍
1
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

When I started my first "real" job as an adult, 34 years ago, there was tons of talk even then about the potential future insolvency of SS. I made two things a priority, tiered as follows: 1) save money for education for my 3 kids; 2) save money for my retirement, assuming I'd never get a dime off SS.

Accomplishing both required some sacrifices.  I would baby along an automobile for 10-20 years rather than buying the latest model. Same with home appliances. All-inclusive vacations? Nah. Plan a trip based on the cheapest flight you can find to somewhere nice. Better yet, drive.

Moving? I would laugh at what a  lender estimated I could pay in a mortgage, cut that way back, and  live frugally to pay it off well in advance.

Granted, I was lucky in not being "blue collar" like some others in my family, who even doing such things would not have saved enough. But I'm no tycoon. Many others can do it. Wants are not necessities and keeping up with the Joneses is a dumb priority.


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 10/07/2025 10:08 am
👍
2
larsIU
(@larsiu)
Noble Member

Posted by: @Anonymous
↑

Posted by: @larsiu
↑

Snarl - we moved all our good paying middle class jobs to lower cost countries so we could maximize the almight profit driver for our capitalistic system. I understand your point but the genie's out of the bottle. Saying we can see the collapse is like being on the Titanic, spotting the iceberg, and screaming "full steam ahead."

 

We've not allowed (at least in the US) our populace any choice but to largely depend on Social Security for their retirement. I mean, unless you've got a fat pension funded by your employer. Oh, what's that? Nobody does? Well, there you go. 

 

it's not just that we tax and spend. It's why we HAVE to that will really get ya. We priorized profits (especially for those in the top 5%) over stability of work. 

Read Men Without Work and tell me how, wihtout reshoring all manufacturing alongside immigration reform, we get back to the Utopia of the 50's and 60's (economically) in the US? If those periods even were Utopian to begin with. We've dug our own grave and some of our people aren't getting out of the hole with social safety nets. Pulling the rug now is just mean or unfair or whatever we want to call it. 

 

To be sure, I don't fully agree with Eberstadt here but it is shining a light on a quesiton of why so many men don't work and have checked out. There was a pride to building cars or other manufacturing that doesn't exist with service work. It just doesn't. 

 

https://www.amazon.com/Men-Without-Work-audiobook/dp/B073K1FPT1/ref=sr_1_2?crid=3UPJBKTRFQ0H1&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.FHlRfffG37q3nhTwk6YjJxs9-LKkUn36qb7rMqjsXdj0perOHSnkUSgx4ytJhcKEnBmM3llVmeBJV6Pq6SEO8a3Pew1T4laTHxuvQskEqvk.Hy3dN3uDqO3F64eLoOGSZbIR808m5EDe7g4jrbM6tEo&dib_tag=se&keywords=men+without+work+nicholas+eberstadt&qid=1759845446&sprefix=men+without+work%2Caps%2C170&sr=8-2

 

 

I have pushed everyone of my small business clients to set up SimpleIras. We have educated employees on contributing at least 3% of their pay because the employer can and will match 3%. You’d be surprised how many workers start with deferring 3% of their pay and then increase the deferral. 

 

Sure but many don't or can't defer much if any income. A lot (far too many) people in this country cannot make ends meet in the dead end service jobs we've created as stop gap. And believe me, it's a stop gap. AI will end most service industry work. Then what? Deferring 3-6% of nothing is still nothing. Pensions are gone. Why? b/c they ate into the current and future profits of large corps? Should we make pensions mandatory and get people off the government teat? I'm all for it. When do we start?

 

also, i do applaud what you're doing for financial literacy Stoll. I just don't see a future where good jobs exist for vast swaths of our population. AI should be treated like offshoring. It's essentially the same thing. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 10/07/2025 10:14 am
👍
2
sig
 sig
(@sig)
Reputable Member

I'm all for the mandatory paycheck deductions and company matching of Social Security payments. To bad the evil Federal govt. was in charge of the money.  The US Federal govt. has proved to be a bunch corrupt idiots over my lifetime. Would of been nice to have been able to make my own choices on who gets to manage that money.  It certainly would not be the Federal govt. They probably use the Medicare and SS money to fund regime changes.   


ReplyQuote
Posted : 10/07/2025 10:21 am
👍
1
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

Posted by: @sig
↑

Would of been nice to have been able to make my own choices on who gets to manage that money.  It certainly would not be the Federal govt. 

True.

Can you imagine if everyone's SS payroll deduction, ever, was invested in an whole-market index fund? Your SS upon retirement would be 10x bigger.

Such personal control of investing has been proposed many times, but groups of dumb politicians on both sides of the aisle, IIRC, kept calling it "gambling on the market with your future".

 


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 10/07/2025 10:36 am
👍
1
snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

Posted by: @larsiu
↑

Snarl - we moved all our good paying middle class jobs to lower cost countries so we could maximize the almight profit driver for our capitalistic system. I understand your point but the genie's out of the bottle. Saying we can see the collapse is like being on the Titanic, spotting the iceberg, and screaming "full steam ahead."

 

We've not allowed (at least in the US) our populace any choice but to largely depend on Social Security for their retirement. I mean, unless you've got a fat pension funded by your employer. Oh, what's that? Nobody does? Well, there you go. 

 

it's not just that we tax and spend. It's why we HAVE to that will really get ya. We priorized profits (especially for those in the top 5%) over stability of work. 

Read Men Without Work and tell me how, wihtout reshoring all manufacturing alongside immigration reform, we get back to the Utopia of the 50's and 60's (economically) in the US? If those periods even were Utopian to begin with. We've dug our own grave and some of our people aren't getting out of the hole with social safety nets. Pulling the rug now is just mean or unfair or whatever we want to call it. 

 

To be sure, I don't fully agree with Eberstadt here but it is shining a light on a quesiton of why so many men don't work and have checked out. There was a pride to building cars or other manufacturing that doesn't exist with service work. It just doesn't. 

 

https://www.amazon.com/Men-Without-Work-audiobook/dp/B073K1FPT1/ref=sr_1_2?crid=3UPJBKTRFQ0H1&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.FHlRfffG37q3nhTwk6YjJxs9-LKkUn36qb7rMqjsXdj0perOHSnkUSgx4ytJhcKEnBmM3llVmeBJV6Pq6SEO8a3Pew1T4laTHxuvQskEqvk.Hy3dN3uDqO3F64eLoOGSZbIR808m5EDe7g4jrbM6tEo&dib_tag=se&keywords=men+without+work+nicholas+eberstadt&qid=1759845446&sprefix=men+without+work%2Caps%2C170&sr=8-2

 

 

I actually agree with most of what you say.  The problem I see with Democrats is their polices are geared toward the bottom end of society at the expense of the middle classes (that's how it plays out).  Republican policies have been more focused on corporate growth, which has also negatively impacted the middle classes.  Both parties neglected the middle class, which explains the rise of Trump and now possibly Mamdami types.  

I do think some of Trump's policies are a better step in the right direction, but I'm not sure the issue can be fixed.  I think the current control system (monetary system) is the underlining issue.  I don't think we can escape these 80-100 year boom bust cycles without changing it.  I open to ideas, but everything seems to lead to the same result. 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 10/07/2025 11:14 am
👍
1
JDB's avatar
 JDB
(@jdb)
Famed Member

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

https://twitter.com/onechancefreedm/status/1975307943068508530?s=46

A great explanation by Endgame on what is happening in the U.S. and around the world.  @larsiu this is why I continue to say social security is awful.  It's a Ponzi that just shifts wealth to one or two lucky generations before it crumbles.  

Also, @mapletom, yes, governments have been allowing much larger amounts of legal and illegal immigration to replace their declining populations. Replacement theory is correct, but the reason for doing it is to protect the current monetary system and governmental spending levels.  Mass immigration is just a bandaid and will only cause more problems.  Importing the third world in large swaths is a terrible policy.  It won't solve the issue. 

https://twitter.com/wallstreetmav/status/1975224349868388645?s=46

The left's response is Mamdami and socialism which will just make the problems worse and centralize more power.

https://twitter.com/kobeissiletter/status/1975358526034956665?s=46

The markets and foreign governments have smelled out the stress in the system and turned to gold and lesser degree Bitcoin.  @twenty I know you weren't a fan of gold and Bitcoin in the past, have you changed your perspective any? @jdb same question?

https://twitter.com/charliebilello/status/1974461342833680700?s=46

 

A collapse is probably coming. Feels bubblicious af right now. Protestors everywhere are crippling economic output and bleeding reserves dry.

The most significant part of the issue is the lack of reproduction in developed and emerging countries (see Asia). But, the lack of common sense and misaligned expectations in Europe, among the eldery and American left wing are also part of the problem as it relates to sustainability. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 10/07/2025 11:24 am
👍
2
Share: