Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

One nation under . ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

One nation under . . . Christ? No mercy for our enemies?

Page 3 / 10
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

Posted by: @hooky
↑

If you honestly believe that our Rules of Engagement include executing troops who have surrendered instead of holding them as prisoners, then you're a bigger moron than I could have ever imagined.

I am sure that no General will have troops under his command follow such a blatantly unlawful order.

But why did the Secretary of War, in plain language, say precisely that our Rules of Engagement should include executing troops who have surrendered instead of holding them as prisoners?

Did he lie? Was he drunk? Does he now know what the words he chose actually mean?

If you honestly believe that our Secretary of Defense War should spew crap like that, then you're a much bigger moron than I could have ever imagined, and I have a very vivid imagination.

 

 

 

 

 


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 3:16 pm
snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑

@snarlcakes You can't help yourself, can you.  You disagree with a poster, you lose the argument, you get frustrated and you resort to insults. 

Who knows if a chaplain said the prayer initially. That's what Hegseth claimed, maybe in an effort to give it greater weight.  What we know for sure is that Hegseth said it.  But regardless, it's flawed and incompatible with the teachings of Christ and the LOAC. 

You're not worth my time. 

No, the issue is you started out the thread claiming to be a Christian and then ascribed the worst possible motive to a Chaplain and some of the best trained soldiers on the planet for zero reason.  A Christian would have done the opposite (as would anyone with a brain). You have no clue who the soldiers are and you should be embarrassed you treat them like f#cking ruthless savages because you don't like a political party or a person (that's a you issue).  Not to mention we also know the results of the mission, which showed plenty of mercy (Maduro was taken alive).  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 3:41 pm
😂
1
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑

@bradstevens The Golden Rule, which necessarily includes mercy, is hardly unique to Christianity. 

What religion are you?  How do you feel about the trend toward Jesus-specific references by some public officials as opposed to a more generic "God?" Are you ok with Hegseth's prayer?  

I'm an atheist. I don't care that much about people's prayers, one way or the other.  My morality is Christian infused--as is nearly everyone's in the modern world.  

Go look at the ancient Greeks, Romans, Carthaginians, Persians, Old Testament Jews, Scythians, etc. views on "mercy." Read some articles on the development of international law, "just" wars, etc.  It's interesting stuff:

Yes, international law's use of mercy is heavily influenced by Christian traditions, particularly through the development of just war theory, the concept of Christian charity, and the work of early international legal scholars. While mercy is a widely recognized concept, modern international humanitarian law (IHL) and human rights are deeply connected to the Christian emphasis on tempering justice with compassion, forgiving enemies, and protecting the vulnerable.

 

 

Cambridge University Press & AssessmentCambridge University Press & Assessment +4
Key influences and developments include:
  • Just War Theory and Mercy: The Christian tradition of "just war," developed by St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas, required that judgment and punishment be executed ex caritate (out of charity/love).
  • Early International Law Jurists: 16th and 17th-century scholars such as Hugo Grotius and Spanish Catholic theologians Francisco de Vitoria and Francisco Suárez, who are considered founders of modern international law, relied heavily on biblical sources to argue for the humane treatment of native peoples and, later, prisoners of war.
  • Protection of Vulnerable Groups: Christian charity was used to advocate for rights and protections for those outside the immediate sovereign, including the "New World" indigenous populations, which grew into modern human rights frameworks.
  • Humanization of Law: The influence of Christianity on Roman law included "humanizing" it by limiting abuse, protecting the poor, and injecting mercy into the strictness of legal codes.
  • Modern International Institutions: The emphasis on peacebuilding, compassion, and the prevention of suffering in institutions like the UN shares a legacy with Christian notions of humanity and care for the vulnerable.
    Cambridge University Press & AssessmentCambridge University Press & Assessment +4

 

I appreciate the thoughtful response. 

I'm very familiar with Just War theory and Thomas Aquinas, but am afraid you've missed my point.  I'm not talking about justification for the Iran War or any other.  I'm talking specifically about no mercy (which Hegseth has now repeatedly promoted) DURING war.  

Thomas Aquinas never wavered from his belief that violence was justified only to the extent that it was necessary, soldiers must refrain from cruelty, and a just war was limited by the conduct of just combatants. 

Hegseth's view is incompatible with Christianity and international law.  

And don't get me started on the drug-boat "war" which was always on shaky legal and moral ground, particularly the incident where a second tap took out two survivors (in the water, clinging to the wrecked boat) from the first hit.  Hegseth had reportedly given orders to "kill everyone" onboard.  Shortly thereafter, the Republican-led armed service committees of the House and Senate had promised to investigate.  I must have missed those hearings and the report.  

 

 

 

Yep, I know what you were referring to. The AI threw back another example of mercy in international law dealing with just wars, but it also cited Grotius and others that extends to actions during war. Both are related: it's the application of a type of morality hostile to violence to an inherently violent set of actions.  

Again, read up on the ancients views on mercy during war.  Read the Old Testament about the Jewish god's view of mercy during war.  Can also read up on Native Americans here, Sub-saharan Africans, Mongols, Incans, Mayans, Aztecs, etc.  The notion of mercy towards those one wars with is the exception to the rule historically, across cultures. It's no accident that the laws of war you're referring to were developed in the Christian West.  

Re our SOD, I don't care if Hegseth is a Christian or not. I do care if he is competently executing his duties and following the Constitution. If you want Hegseth investigated, wait for the Dems to take power of the House. Good bet they'll go after him. Pritzker would, too, I'd assume, or at least he's going to run on such a notion.  

 


This post was modified 8 months ago by BradStevens
ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 4:34 pm
Scam Likely's avatar
(@scam-likely)
Reputable Member

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @hurryinghoosiers
↑

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @shooter
↑

Everyone should all unequivocally reject Hegseth's approach, whether you are Christian or not. It's fundamentally immoral, and yes you can be moral and not be religious.

Morality is overrated. What's immoral is fighting with your hands tied while your enemy does whatever they can/want. 

 

Of course MAGA would think morality is overrated.  They sold their morals for Trump.

 

How many more pedophiles have you advocated for today?

 

 

He's not a Trump supporter. DERP!

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 4:46 pm
snarlcakes's avatar
(@snarlcakes)
Famed Member

Posted by: @hooky
↑

Posted by: @shooter
↑

Posted by: @hooky
↑

I don't believe for a moment that our ROE includes killing enemies who have surrendered. 

Hegseth disagrees, though, if you take him at his word. During a March 13, 2026, briefing on the Iran war, Hegseth said, "We will keep pressing, keep pushing, keep advancing, no quarter, no mercy for our enemies".

The phrase "no quarter" is widely understood to mean refusing to take prisoners and/or killing surrendering combatants, acts that are illegal under the Geneva Convention and U.S. Army laws-of-war.

Maybe he doesn't understand the meaning of the words he chooses to spew, or maybe he was drunk again.

 

If you honestly believe that our Rules of Engagement include executing troops who have surrendered instead of holding them as prisoners, then you're a bigger moron than I could have ever imagined, and I like to think I have a very vivid imagination.

 

Where is Murt or Ms. Washburn when you need them. Board ops can Murt or the always lovely Ms W. get one day a month to say mean shit to Shooter?  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 5:27 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

Posted by: @hooky
↑

Posted by: @shooter
↑

Posted by: @hooky
↑

I don't believe for a moment that our ROE includes killing enemies who have surrendered. 

Hegseth disagrees, though, if you take him at his word. During a March 13, 2026, briefing on the Iran war, Hegseth said, "We will keep pressing, keep pushing, keep advancing, no quarter, no mercy for our enemies".

The phrase "no quarter" is widely understood to mean refusing to take prisoners and/or killing surrendering combatants, acts that are illegal under the Geneva Convention and U.S. Army laws-of-war.

Maybe he doesn't understand the meaning of the words he chooses to spew, or maybe he was drunk again.

 

If you honestly believe that our Rules of Engagement include executing troops who have surrendered instead of holding them as prisoners, then you're a bigger moron than I could have ever imagined, and I like to think I have a very vivid imagination.

 

Where is Murt or Ms. Washburn when you need them. Board ops can Murt or the always lovely Ms W. get one day a month to say mean shit to Shooter?  

 

Itll be the board version of The Purge. 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 5:42 pm
😂
🔥
2
Spartans9312's avatar
(@spartans9312)
Noble Member

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑

First, I'm a Christian.  I believe in Jesus's divinity. 

I'm happy that "...one nation under God," "God bless America," "God bless our troops," "In God we trust," etc., are an important part of our American tradition, and frequently uttered in public.  However, the relatively recent shift by some political/government leaders to the specificity of Jesus Christ in public prayer and public statements strikes me as inappropriate.   Millions of Americans, myself included, embrace Christian beliefs, values and tradition.  Millions don't.  

I'm pretty sure there are people of a non-Christian faith (or no faith) who will read this, and it would be particularly beneficial to have your perspective.  

Next, Pete Hegseth read a prayer yesterday that he said was first given by a military chaplain to the troops who captured Maduro.  Here's the prayer:

"Let every round find its mark against the enemies of righteousness and our great nation.  Give them ["them" presumably refers to our troops] wisdom in every decision, endurance for the trial ahead, unbreakable unity, and overwhelming violence of action against those who deserve no mercy.”

The Law of Armed Conflict has standards that do, in fact, reflect mercy. For examples, soldiers don't harm enemies who have surrendered.  Soldiers don't kill or torture anyone in their custody. That's a crime under both international and domestic law. Soldiers collect and care for the wounded, whether friend or foe. 

Back to Christianity. What does Jesus say about mercy?  A lot.  "Blessed are the merciful, for they will be shown mercy." "Go and learn what this means: ‘I desire mercy, and not sacrifice. For I came not to call the righteous, but sinners.” "Be merciful, even as your Father is merciful." "For judgment is without mercy to one who has shown no mercy."

Seems that Hegseth's prayer, no matter where or when it's uttered, would benefit from revisions. 

I know that these are topics that elicit emotions, and the thread will inevitably move to a debate about the establishment clause, but please try to be civil in your replies. 

 

Where do you stand on the topic of abortion?

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 5:48 pm
JDB's avatar
 JDB
(@jdb)
Famed Member

Posted by: @scam-likely
↑

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @hurryinghoosiers
↑

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @shooter
↑

Everyone should all unequivocally reject Hegseth's approach, whether you are Christian or not. It's fundamentally immoral, and yes you can be moral and not be religious.

Morality is overrated. What's immoral is fighting with your hands tied while your enemy does whatever they can/want. 

 

Of course MAGA would think morality is overrated.  They sold their morals for Trump.

 

How many more pedophiles have you advocated for today?

 

 

He's not a Trump supporter. DERP!

 

he literally just supported a pedophile 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 5:52 pm
UncleMark
(@unclemark)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @jdb
↑

he literally just supported a pedophile 

No he didn't. You're better than this.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 7:19 pm
HurryingHoosiers
(@hurryinghoosiers)
Noble Member

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @hurryinghoosiers
↑

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @shooter
↑

Everyone should all unequivocally reject Hegseth's approach, whether you are Christian or not. It's fundamentally immoral, and yes you can be moral and not be religious.

Morality is overrated. What's immoral is fighting with your hands tied while your enemy does whatever they can/want. 

 

Of course MAGA would think morality is overrated.  They sold their morals for Trump.

 

How many more pedophiles have you advocated for today?

 

None.  Calling you out for voting for a pedo isn't advocating for a pedo.

 

How many pedos have you voted for?   Trump 3 times at least

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 7:29 pm
JDB's avatar
 JDB
(@jdb)
Famed Member

Posted by: @hurryinghoosiers
↑

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @hurryinghoosiers
↑

Posted by: @jdb
↑

Posted by: @shooter
↑

Everyone should all unequivocally reject Hegseth's approach, whether you are Christian or not. It's fundamentally immoral, and yes you can be moral and not be religious.

Morality is overrated. What's immoral is fighting with your hands tied while your enemy does whatever they can/want. 

 

Of course MAGA would think morality is overrated.  They sold their morals for Trump.

 

How many more pedophiles have you advocated for today?

 

None.  Calling you out for voting for a pedo isn't advocating for a pedo.

 

How many pedos have you voted for?   Trump 3 times at least

 

Shorter Hurrying...

"I defend pedos, so I decide to make shit up to feel better about my pedo acceptance"

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 8:49 pm
JDB's avatar
 JDB
(@jdb)
Famed Member

Posted by: @unclemark
↑

Posted by: @jdb
↑

he literally just supported a pedophile 

No he didn't. You're better than this.

Parroting a multi-offending pedo is sad. Do some introspection.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 8:55 pm
Butch Crawling's avatar
(@big-ryan)
Famed Member

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

Posted by: @big-ryan
↑

@snarlcakes You can't help yourself, can you.  You disagree with a poster, you lose the argument, you get frustrated and you resort to insults. 

Who knows if a chaplain said the prayer initially. That's what Hegseth claimed, maybe in an effort to give it greater weight.  What we know for sure is that Hegseth said it.  But regardless, it's flawed and incompatible with the teachings of Christ and the LOAC. 

You're not worth my time. 

No, the issue is you started out the thread claiming to be a Christian and then ascribed the worst possible motive to a Chaplain and some of the best trained soldiers on the planet for zero reason.  A Christian would have done the opposite (as would anyone with a brain). You have no clue who the soldiers are and you should be embarrassed you treat them like f#cking ruthless savages because you don't like a political party or a person (that's a you issue).  Not to mention we also know the results of the mission, which showed plenty of mercy (Maduro was taken alive).  

 

This is a blatant, pathetic and fucked-up distortion of what I argued.  If you're going to desperately resort to straw man fallacies, at least show some skill in the endeavor. 

 


ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 03/26/2026 10:21 pm
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

Where is Murt or Ms. Washburn when you need them. 

I roasted his/her ass so badly that he/she tucked tail and ran from this site TWICE. 

 


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/26/2026 11:51 pm
OneEyedUndertaker
(@oneeyedundertaker)
Noble Member

Posted by: @shooter
↑

Posted by: @snarlcakes
↑

Where is Murt or Ms. Washburn when you need them. 

I’m a giant pussy & got so butthurt that I told on him & got him banned from this site TWICE. 

 

fify

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 03/27/2026 7:03 am
👍
1
Page 3 / 10
Share: