Skip to main content

Hoosier Huddle

Let’s go on the rec...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Let’s go on the record.

Page 6 / 14
Goat
 Goat
(@goat)
Famed Member

Posted by: @dbmhoosier
↑

Posted by: @goat
↑

Posted by: @dbmhoosier
↑

Posted by: @aloha-hoosier
↑

If orders were given in the Chain of command from CinC to operation commander to kill any survivors from the initial attack, is that a crime? Yes or no?

https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/5627546-lawmakers-demand-answers-trump-venezuela-boat-strikes/

https://twitter.com/RyanSaavedra/status/1995708735256433056?t=f1r4jINJc_hpBPTqPiDNyw&s=19

 

So what's the story then? You agree we committed a war crime, but it was Admiral Bradley that did it and not Hegseth?

 

We don't know the full truth yet but if the NY Times is saying Hegseth didn't give that order it's probably safe to say he didn't.

 

They aren't just saying Hegseth didn't give the order. They are confirming that Bradley did.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 10:09 am
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

We can look back to this case for context.

After sinking the Greek steamer Peleus in the South Atlantic in 1944, the captain of the U-boat U-852 ordered his crew to attack the survivors with gunfire and grenades. Amazingly, three sailors survived the ordeal and eventually faced their attackers in a historic war crime trial. Three Uboat officers  were convicted and executed by firing squad on 30 November 1945  (Eck, Hoffmann, and Weisspfennig). Two lesser officers received jail sentences.

https://www.usni.org/magazines/naval-history-magazine/1997/february/peleus-war-crimes-trial

https://www.justsecurity.org/125998/boat-strikes-shipwrecked-servicemembers/


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 10:33 am
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @shooter
↑

We can look back to this case for context.

After sinking the Greek steamer Peleus in the South Atlantic in 1944, the captain of the U-boat U-852 ordered his crew to attack the survivors with gunfire and grenades. Amazingly, three sailors survived the ordeal and eventually faced their attackers in a historic war crime trial. Three Uboat officers  were convicted and executed by firing squad on 30 November 1945  (Eck, Hoffmann, and Weisspfennig). Two lesser officers received jail sentences.

https://www.usni.org/magazines/naval-history-magazine/1997/february/peleus-war-crimes-trial

https://www.justsecurity.org/125998/boat-strikes-shipwrecked-servicemembers/

Counter analogy/Devil's advocate:

We see Al-Queda members building a bomb in Yemen via drones.  We have good intel that that bomb is going to be transported to a U.S. army base to blow people up, or civilians somewhere in U.S. control.  We order a strike to kill the bomb makers and the building and bomb where they are located.  First missile hits and blows up the bomb and building, but the drone footage shows two Al-Queda members crawling out of the wreckage.  Can the drone operator fire another missile/bomb to kill the two remaining survivors?  

Tougher situation.  How do you decide?  Based on the perceived evilness of the targets? Based on perceived danger of bombs v. drugs? Who gets to make that call and who can disobey the order?  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 12:08 pm
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

It seems that it depends on whether the survivors still pose a legitimate security threat and are enemy combatants in a declared war.

Two guys clinging to splintered wood, bobbing in the ocean, in an undefined conflict would seem to be an illegal target. Two surviving bomb makers, on land, at the bomb making facility that is still to an extent in tact, is indeed a much more gray area, if they are indeed enemy combatants in a declared war.  


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 12:24 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Counter analogy/Devil's advocate:

 

We see Al-Queda members building a bomb in Yemen via drones.  We have good intel that that bomb is going to be transported to a U.S. army base to blow people up, or civilians somewhere in U.S. control.  We order a strike to kill the bomb makers and the building and bomb where they are located.  First missile hits and blows up the bomb and building, but the drone footage shows two Al-Queda members crawling out of the wreckage.  Can the drone operator fire another missile/bomb to kill the two remaining survivors?  

Tougher situation.  How do you decide?  Based on the perceived evilness of the targets? Based on perceived danger of bombs v. drugs? Who gets to make that call and who can disobey the order?  

I am not sure that is tougher. Move the scenario to a war zone. You blow up a bunker in WW2, 2 German soldiers escape the destroyed bunker. I believe they are still fair game.

The scenarios of being on flotsam or dangling from a parachute come from the concept of a defenseless combatant. If they are on ground and conscious, it may not fit the idea of defenseless. Now if they are pulled unconscious from rubble and are still unconscious on the ground, yes, that would probably be a war crime.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 12:42 pm
dbmhoosier
(@dbmhoosier)
Famed Member
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

He doesn't seem to mention that the fishing boats targeted, even if equipped with the largest possible fuel tanks, could not possibly reach US soil without refueling 10 or more times. He also doesn't seem to mention  any evidence whatsoever that these fishing boats were trafficking fentanyl (as widely alleged), which doesn't come from Venezuela in the first place, or any other drug. 

One would like to assume that we have capable intelligence, but the plan of operations seems to be to claim whatever the King demands that you claim, facts be damned.


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 1:08 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

Counter analogy/Devil's advocate:

 

We see Al-Queda members building a bomb in Yemen via drones.  We have good intel that that bomb is going to be transported to a U.S. army base to blow people up, or civilians somewhere in U.S. control.  We order a strike to kill the bomb makers and the building and bomb where they are located.  First missile hits and blows up the bomb and building, but the drone footage shows two Al-Queda members crawling out of the wreckage.  Can the drone operator fire another missile/bomb to kill the two remaining survivors?  

Tougher situation.  How do you decide?  Based on the perceived evilness of the targets? Based on perceived danger of bombs v. drugs? Who gets to make that call and who can disobey the order?  

I am not sure that is tougher. Move the scenario to a war zone. You blow up a bunker in WW2, 2 German soldiers escape the destroyed bunker. I believe they are still fair game.

The scenarios of being on flotsam or dangling from a parachute come from the concept of a defenseless combatant. If they are on ground and conscious, it may not fit the idea of defenseless. Now if they are pulled unconscious from rubble and are still unconscious on the ground, yes, that would probably be a war crime.

 

No, do not move the scenario to a war zone. We aren't at war with Venezuela; we've declared a particular group of people are terrorists, just like Al-Queda. That's a real difference. Keep it in place.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 1:53 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @shooter
↑

It seems that it depends on whether the survivors still pose a legitimate security threat and are enemy combatants in a declared war.

Two guys clinging to splintered wood, bobbing in the ocean, in an undefined conflict would seem to be an illegal target. Two surviving bomb makers, on land, at the bomb making facility that is still to an extent in tact, is indeed a much more gray area, if they are indeed enemy combatants in a declared war.  

You can't even be honest about dealing with a hypothetical. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 1:58 pm
👍
1
Spartans9312's avatar
(@spartans9312)
Noble Member

Posted by: @aloha-hoosier
↑

If orders were given in the Chain of command from CinC to operation commander to kill any survivors from the initial attack, is that a crime? Yes or no?

https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/5627546-lawmakers-demand-answers-trump-venezuela-boat-strikes/

 

If the second strike was about eliminating survivors then that is a big problem. If it was to destroy the rest of the boat then that is different 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 2:13 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

@bradstevens the Geneva Convention applies to all armed conflict. So how would this not being a war change anything? 

Look it up, Geneva applies to all armed conflict. Both WW2 and whatever this is qualifies. I am unaware of anything in Geneva that says,"oh, the attacking country can say this isn't a war and nothing below applies."

 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 2:13 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

@bradstevens to add, even domestic police are covered by the terms of Geneva 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 2:15 pm
BradStevens
(@bradstevens)
Illustrious Member

Posted by: @arthur-dent
↑

@bradstevens the Geneva Convention applies to all armed conflict. So how would this not being a war change anything? 

Look it up, Geneva applies to all armed conflict. Both WW2 and whatever this is qualifies. I am unaware of anything in Geneva that says,"oh, the attacking country can say this isn't a war and nothing below applies."

 

 

It matters for our own law and it matters in terms of practicalities.

I'm not saying it makes it better; I'm just saying it's a real difference.  

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 2:16 pm
Arthur Dent's avatar
(@arthur-dent)
Noble Member

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

matters

Posted by: @bradstevens
↑

It matters for our own law and it matters in terms of practicalities.

 

I'm not saying it makes it better; I'm just saying it's a real difference.  

 

Our own law, sure, it might. Though I suspect the UCMJ doesn't differentiate a peacetime action from a war. 

But as to whether or not this is a war crime, it makes no difference at all. If an enemy is helpless, they aren't to be targeted. Which is why a boat still afloat matters to me. I think Geneva still recognizes a vessel as a legitimate target.

I cannot figure out how your scenario matters to Geneva. Aloha can answer about the code of military justice but I suspect it too won't matter. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 2:32 pm
CO. Hoosier
(@co-hoosier)
Famed Member

@arthur-dent 

Politics matters the most. There are a dozens of nuances about self defense, legit military targets, helplessness and more. All of that only strengthens political debates.  It doesn’t answer any hard questions.  Biden (and other Dems) said Trump killing Soleimani was a war crime.  Was he correct?  


ReplyQuote
Posted : 12/02/2025 2:57 pm
👍
1
Page 6 / 14
Share: