@tammany One would think... But if the committee doesn't correct IU's position tomorrow night a little bit... they could have painted themselves in a tight corner on all this.
I guess they could bump Notre Dame out of the bye, in the end. But if Utah wins out, and Miami wins out, what would the justification be in IU bumping either of them? Both would have very solid championship game wins (BYU or Texas Tech, and Wake Forest).
I'm sure it'll all work out in the end that IU is safely a bye team, if they win out, and beat UCLA. But if getting a bye is hugely important, IU should be cheering very strongly for B12 teams not named Utah, ACC teams not named Miami, AND for UCLA to beat Michigan and USC. And none of this is factoring the drum beat ESPN, and pundits will have for the 2nd and 3rd ranked SEC teams, that will each have "tons of ranked wins", under their belt.
The CFP rankings aren't always consistent from week to week. They supposedly reevaluate all 25 teams each week based on wins, losses, SOS, SOR, head-to-head, and optics/performance metrics.
Not saying I agree with it, but that reevaluation was their justification for our big drop following the bye week. There are other examples of unexpected movement (and questionable timing) of their rankings, including their last-minute flip of Notre Dame and Miami last season despite neither team having played the previous weekend.
My take is that their application of the "rules" sometimes appears uneven and subject to shifting national narratives. They're adept at getting themselves out of any corner they may have seemingly painted themselves into.
As @tammany suggested, there's little chance the committee would keep a 12-1 B1G champ out of the Top 4.
But in reality it was them catching a ton of shit for putting us 4th that made the drop so large.that reevaluation was their justification for our big drop following the bye week.
@tammany One would think... But if the committee doesn't correct IU's position tomorrow night a little bit... they could have painted themselves in a tight corner on all this.
I guess they could bump Notre Dame out of the bye, in the end. But if Utah wins out, and Miami wins out, what would the justification be in IU bumping either of them? Both would have very solid championship game wins (BYU or Texas Tech, and Wake Forest).
I'm sure it'll all work out in the end that IU is safely a bye team, if they win out, and beat UCLA. But if getting a bye is hugely important, IU should be cheering very strongly for B12 teams not named Utah, ACC teams not named Miami, AND for UCLA to beat Michigan and USC. And none of this is factoring the drum beat ESPN, and pundits will have for the 2nd and 3rd ranked SEC teams, that will each have "tons of ranked wins", under their belt.
Who runs the CFP?
I’m not worried. The committee will just jump a 12-1 P2 team to a bye. They can do whatever they want, painted corners be damned.
Now we actually have to get to 12-1. A lot more uncertainty there.
But in reality it was them catching a ton of shit for putting us 4th that made the drop so large.that reevaluation was their justification for our big drop following the bye week.
My take is that their application of the "rules" sometimes appears uneven and subject to shifting national narratives.
@tammany I get it. And enough things above IU will happen, that I'm sure all of this is pointless conjecture, if IU wins out. But if "chalk" happens, I'm not nearly as certain as you are about it. Why put UCLA and IU where they are now, if the B10 is one of 2 main drivers in all this? I guess it is all generating clicks. I'd hate to know that interest and exposure is any sort of motivating factor, for the committee. But I'm also not too naive to not consider it.
Anything could happen. The last two weeks is when it gets the craziest with all the rivalry games. It wouldn't surprise me to see both Texas and Alabama lose. Albeit I'm a little biased 😉 😉 😉
Best thing that can happen is both IU and UCLA win out with IU beating UCLA in the B1G championship. And hope for some SEC upsets.
Impossible to get a SEC upset. They are all great teams afterall
If they get up to four good losses though, we can squeak in ahead of them, sometimes even if they have only three good losses.Impossible to get a SEC upset. They are all great teams afterall
Alabama gets a bye notwithstanding how many losses. Getting smashed by us last year was unfair, so ESPN wants to make up for that injustice.
,