Ryan Day has resembled John Cooper when it comes to beating Michigan, although Michigan had engaged in unprecedented cheating by engaging in advanced, on-site, scouting of Ohio State and others during the 2021, 2022, and part of the 2023 season. For sure in 21' and 22' they knew what offensive and defensive plays we were running on every play before the ball was snapped. So I don't hold Day's proverbial "feet to the fire" for those two losses. However, last year's loss at home as a 3 TD favorite was an absolute abomination and without a doubt the low point of his career at OSU. I'm sure if you asked Day he'd tell you that he did a HORRIBLE job before and during that game. Fortunately, Day and OSU got a mulligan and ran off four straight playoff wins to claim the natty. All was forgiven - but not forgotten.
This year OSU travels to Ann Arbor. Michigan is solid, but not spectacular. Buckeye fans are confident but also apprehensive that Day and staff will again tighten up and lose again to that team up north. However, I believe the Buckeyes are going to beat them by multiple scores, or at least they should.
Why the dissertation on OSU-Michigan? Because if Day again craps the bed, you'll likely be playing Michigan in Indy instead of us.
Ohio State hasn't faced a good passing attack all season. Arch Manning was awful in his debut against us. Illinois' QB is probably the best we've faced but I wouldn't call their passing attack anything dynamic, unlike yours. And I say this because I believe that you'll be able to throw with success against OSU. I think our pass rush is mediocre and part of that is because we don't have a great edge. Opposing QB's have had plenty of time to throw. What they didn't have was a good scheme or WR's good enough to get separation or perhaps even with time the QB's weren't good enough to deliver the ball on target.
I believe your biggest challenge will be DC Matt Patricia. He will quite possibly show you looks that you won't find on film. It will be a schematic chess match, so to speak. However, I absolutely believe that the IU offense has the ability to move the ball against our D. Our corners are good, but not great. Both starters are projected as round 6-7 picks, if at all. Obviously the guy in the secondary that can hurt you is safety Caleb Downs. He is smart and is like having a coach in the backfield. He is probably the greatest safety to ever play at OSU.
Our run D is really good! Straight handoffs up the middle will yield little, nothing or TFL. Attacking the edge is preferable but the D's lateral speed is really good. Dump-off passes to the backs will probably garner more yardage. Obviously you need to be productive in getting some yardage to set up 3rd and makeable. I believe your OL will give Mendoza time to hit short passes to extend drives. I also believe that you can have success throwing down the field.
Our OL is solid but not great. They can be had at times on pass rushes. Julian Sayin, however, has incredible pocket awareness and is masterful with the ball. He will cause the IU D fits if he's allowed time to throw.
Our best RB is true freshman Bo Jackson. He's not a power runner but he doesn't go down easily. Just when it looks like he's stopped for a 2-yard gain he manages to squirm for 3 more. He's also not a speed demon. What he has is great vision and an unwillingness to go down. With that said, our running game is actually mediocre. OSU will obviously prefer to be able to run the ball like everyone else. Assuming that IU limits OSU on the ground, you can put OSU in 3rd +5 and make Sayin complete passes to move the chains. It should go without saying (no pun) that OSU will KILL you deep if your secondary gives them the opportunity. When you see Sayin with time and drops back to throw deep, start praying. Nobody does the deep ball like OSU. I'm sure that Cignetti will NOT allow IU to get beat deep.
Our FG kicker is solid under 40. Beyond that he's iffy and Day is more likely to go for it on 4th down. Our punter is disappointing; fortunately his services are infrequently required. Our return games are solid but not spectacular.
So there you have it. I hope we meet in Indy as undefeated 1 & 2. The whole state of Indiana will be in a frenzy! And if you pull off the upset?!!! It's crazy to think that we could potentially meet for a second time in the playoff!
From what I'm seeing with Indiana, this might become an annual affair!
Thanks for sharing your information. Intersting to see your thoughts. It would be fun to play in Indy and then again in Miami. Let’s both beat us some SEC on the way!
I'm just impressed there's a Buckeye who is thoughtful and admits to some respect for IU! I think we're a much better team this year than last. I'm a little concerned after watching our lines vs PSU and projecting to OSU, but Oregon had the same advantage and we really controlled that game far more than the score indicated. Guessing WI is the 3rd-4th best D line we've faced so it will be interesting to see if our OL holds up or is getting tired or depleted. Hoping with it being senior day, that it's just a celebration for these guys and what they've done. Then a week of rest and Purdue and then we can start to think about an OSU matchup.
I think with a better team, we'll have closed the gap on OSU, but it also sounds like this is a better version of OSU than last year. If it happens that we are 1 v 2, we'll rightfully be an underdog but I give us a punchers chance or better, especially if we can get a couple breaks. I agree that our gameplan will be to try and get pressure on Sayin with your receivers being what they are. Best pass defense is pressure on the QB. Hope it happens!
I think with a better team, we’ll have closed the gap on OSU, but it also sounds like this is a better version of OSU than last year.
From afar I believe that IU is a level better than last year's version. As well, I do believe that this Buckeye team is better than the 24' version.
Drew Evans, according to the measurable Oline stats, is IUs best lineman. The guys who have stepped in for him have done an admirable job but His absence is glaring. He needs to be back and healthy for the BIG championship and the playoff run. Couple that with Benson playing while hobbled and it's no wonder why our line has been struggling a bit as of late. On the defense front, losing Wyatt was huge. Not insurmountable but still huge. The bye week and the extra day rest before the BIG should be very welcomed to this squad. If this team is somewhat fully healthy they can beat anyone. Including OSU. I believe IU is the only team in the country that ranks in the top 10 in all 3 phases. Offense, defense and Special teams.I'm just impressed there's a Buckeye who is thoughtful and admits to some respect for IU! I think we're a much better team this year than last. I'm a little concerned after watching our lines vs PSU and projecting to OSU, but Oregon had the same advantage and we really controlled that game far more than the score indicated. Guessing WI is the 3rd-4th best D line we've faced so it will be interesting to see if our OL holds up or is getting tired or depleted. Hoping with it being senior day, that it's just a celebration for these guys and what they've done. Then a week of rest and Purdue and then we can start to think about an OSU matchup.
I think with a better team, we'll have closed the gap on OSU, but it also sounds like this is a better version of OSU than last year. If it happens that we are 1 v 2, we'll rightfully be an underdog but I give us a punchers chance or better, especially if we can get a couple breaks. I agree that our gameplan will be to try and get pressure on Sayin with your receivers being what they are. Best pass defense is pressure on the QB. Hope it happens!
As for OSU. They are extremely talented at all facets. Save maybe special teams. This OSU guy is downplaying them. I respect the reverse jinx play. It just means they are worried. Lol. I'm worried about their receivers. Especially out of the slot and over the middle. IU defends the boundaries maybe better then anyone. But the middle of the field has been a struggle. The LBs and DBs like Sharpe will need to play the best games of their lives in pass coverage.
I'm a little concerned after watching our lines vs PSU and projecting to OSU, but Oregon had the same advantage and we really controlled that game far more than the score indicated.
We need to remember that OG Drew Evans was out. We lost Drew Evans for the season last year during the week of the Ohio State game. We then went on to lose 2 of our next 3 (both on the road). The line wasn't the same as it had been all year.
Fast forward to this year and we again are on a roll, line looks great, then we again lose Drew Evans 2 weeks ago. Suddenly the line doesn't look as cohesive in loud hostile environments. With Drew Evans, IU is undefeated the last 2 years. Without him, IU is 4-2. I seriously doubt he plays vs. Purdue but am hoping he is back for the B1G championship.
Ryan Day has resembled John Cooper when it comes to beating Michigan, although Michigan had engaged in unprecedented cheating by engaging in advanced, on-site, scouting of Ohio State and others during the 2021, 2022, and part of the 2023 season. He is probably the greatest safety to ever play at OSU.
From what I'm seeing with Indiana, this might become an annual affair!
Nice post.
Since we've never been very good at football, I have difficulty processing what I see on the field since Cig arrived. Class of 1984.
My feeling is OSU is the Gold Standard at the moment. Until someone beats you guys, you're it.
I'm not convinced we match up w OSU very well. I do think we have a chance if our D can keep us around. We got cooked pretty good at the shoe last year so I need to see we can hang up front. Couldn't last year. Best possible outcome is Indy for both of us. I really want to play OSU and see if we're getting better.
Happy Thanksgiving.
- Parents had a buckeye tree in front yard in southern Indiana. They fired hard from under the lawnmower.
![]()
@yothn Going to be that guy and give a correction, we lost Evans the practice before we played Michigan, not the OSU week. Its partially why our OL struggled so much against UM, we had to start Stephens with basically zero first team reps
@littlebitchbuckeye gave me a chuckle seeing a whole paragraph about those dang cheaters up north on an IU board.
I dont think we match up well with OSU defensively - our defense might be the best in the country at stopping the run, but OSU doesn't run the ball much. Our defense has been good against the pass, because we put teams in uncomfortable 3rd downs from our run D, and because we are good at getting pressure on the QB - but against an elite passing offense like OSU we could get exposed over the middle.
We seem to have soft coverage in the gap between our LBs and DBs, which several teams have taken advantage of this year (Iowa, PSU etc). Our safeties have been prone to being out of position all year (albeit, they have been playing better recently), and recently our CB2 has started playing poorly the past few games, allowing several huge gains. If we play like that against OSU, Smith and Tate are going to feast. IU's DL is going to need to play its best game of the season to hold OSU.
I do like how we match up with OSU offensively though. I dont think OSU has played a single good offense outside of Illinois, and I thought Illinois did a good job moving the ball even if the score doesnt reflect that. I especially like how IU's WR match up with your DB's on the outside. The problem for us is that our OC likes to playcall big games similar to how Day playcalls against Michigan. We will probably try and run it against the teeth of your defense over and over (which is your strongpoint) and put ourselves in bad 3rd down spots.
1. This post tells me we better start recruiting some more depth at O-line.
2. OSU has the best player on the football field in Jeremiah Smith, his name hasn't even been mentioned specifically. He cause us fits. Because if we have a weakness defensively it would be to a route runner like him.
3. We are a better team than last year. I think they are on par with their team last year, perhaps a skosh less talented but nonetheless really good. Playing them will be a challenge but one I think we can win.
2. OSU has the best player on the football field in Jeremiah Smith, his name hasn't even been mentioned specifically. He cause us fits. Because if we have a weakness defensively it would be to a route runner like him.
Ponds shut Smith down last year, as he did Denzel Boston (who is projected to be a top 15-20 pick). Smith being the best player doesn’t scare me at all, people not giving Ponds the respect he’s earned as the best CB in the nation is what it is.
If Sharpe and the safety trio don’t start playing a lot better (and honestly, Jones and Fisher need to be better in coverage) we could be in trouble though. Ponds can’t cover everyone.
This OSU guy is downplaying them. I respect the reverse jinx play.
Ah you got me! 😉
I'm not trying to pull a Lou Hotz here, who was famous for doing exactly as you described. I am being genuine. Ohio State does NOT walk on water. They are an excellent team but they also haven't faced a team with a legitimate passing attack, such as IU's, or Bama's, or A&M's.
A team that can avoid getting beat deep by OSU (easier said than done) and who doesn't beat themselves (penalties, turnovers, dumb plays) can beat OSU. Yes, it can be done. That's all I'm saying.
But first things first for us is that we have to beat Iran, er, Michigan.
I’m not convinced we match up w OSU very well. I do think we have a chance if our D can keep us around.
Gotta keep Smith and Tate in front of the D. Limit the run and force OSU to have to convert multiple third downs in order to score. That's what the D has to do, in my opinion, to have a chance to win the game.
I dont think OSU has played a single good offense outside of Illinois, and I thought Illinois did a good job moving the ball even if the score doesnt reflect that.
Illinois did a LOT to beat themselves against us. I know Beleima wishes he had that one to do over.
avoid getting beat deep
That is the exact issue we have. Thats the only flaw on the team for IU.
I guess Cignetti will be forced to keep a safety deep to try and prevent deep completions. Gotta make OSU earn yards and points.