Hoosier Huddle

Prior to Cignetti, ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Prior to Cignetti, Which Memory Makes You Rip Your Hair Out / Which Memory Is Most Heartbreaking?

Page 1 / 2
Evan Alvarez
(@evanalvarez8)
Staff Moderator

Two quickly come to mind for me (started following the Hoosiers in 2012/2013, mind you, so I missed a lot of heartbreak):

-Making the trek and attending the Indiana @ Iowa game when Penix was going to light up the world and Indiana was going to have their best season ever, only to lose 34-6. My heart was ripped out of my chest.

-Indiana just barely beating Akron in 4OT. That broke me. Felt like the final, final, final straw for me that finally broke my back. I was so angry.


Check out my latest at Hoosier Huddle here

ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 01/20/2026 4:13 pm
👍
1
HoosierDaddy's avatar
(@hoosierdaddy)
Noble Member

Micah getting ejected on BS targeting

Felt like that was the end of the slow build up we had the prior half decade.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/20/2026 5:21 pm
👍
2
Rattmouse's avatar
(@rattmouse)
Eminent Member

Heartbreaking:  Lorenzo White & MSU running all over the Hoosiers in 1987.  Also, the Ohio State game when Jordan Howard & Nate Sudfeld got hurt & we still almost won with Xander at QB.  IU was the better team that night.

Ripping My Hair Out:  The entire Antwaan Randle El era.  No one deserved to play in a bowl than him.


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/20/2026 7:13 pm
👍
3
Walt542's avatar
(@walt542)
Prominent Member

Rutgers coming from behind by 25 or so in the 4th qtr to win at IU. 

or maybe the lateral pass with Minnesota here that Coleman did not go after because he assumed it was a forward pass. 

or… please make it stop…


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/20/2026 7:13 pm
👍
2
Kelly_32
(@kelly_32)
Noble Member

Posted by: @walt542

Rutgers coming from behind by 25 or so in the 4th qtr to win at IU. 

or maybe the lateral pass with Minnesota here that Coleman did not go after because he assumed it was a forward pass. 

or… please make it stop…

I would pick the same two games. 

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 5:31 am
👍
1
OpenWheel's avatar
(@openwheel)
Noble Member

Asleep at the wheel for the onside kick in the Gator Bowl vs Tennessee, and losing.

The kick was good, Pinstripe Bowl .

Ernie Jones getting hurt late vs Auburn in the Peach Bowl. I think we would have won, they couldnt stop him.

There are many painful bad losses, where we were not close, but I remember the ones where we catch some crap as a program and then couldve won those games.

Games I cant remember, but the result of the play stays in my head:

Whatever game against Michigan under Wilson with the simultaneous grab that went to Michigan, because they were Michigan. I think we were moving in to score?

Phantom Holding when moving in to score at the BS House under Mallory. I know the result and effect on the season but I was unable to watch that day. I saw news clips on TV in Indiana where they were searching for the holding, lol.

,


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 6:31 am
👍
1
Sparky's avatar
(@sparky)
Active Member

Tennessee game. Masterclass in shitty coaching


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 11:05 am
👍
5
OpenWheel's avatar
(@openwheel)
Noble Member

Posted by: @sparky

Tennessee game. Masterclass in shitty coaching

I think that masterclass was vs Ole Miss.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 12:38 pm
👍
2
hooky
(@hooky)
Noble Member

The rip my hair out event would have to be paying 3 head coaches at the same time.  

Heartbreaking was Hoeppner's illness and death.  Losing to MSU and missing the Rose Bowl sucked.


Diligence is the mother of good luck. Plough deep while sluggards sleep and you shall have corn to sell and keep. Work as if you were to live 100 years. Pray as if you were to die tomorrow. All progress springs from work. Work has laid the foundation of every fortune in America. – Benjamin Franklin
POTFB

ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 1:25 pm
👍
1
Catherine Page-Vanore's avatar
(@lonestarhoosier1)
Active Member

I was a sophomore trumpet player in the Marching Hundred in 2004.  Late in the year, when we played Penn State, Indiana was down 22-18, but Matt LoVecchio managed to lead the team down the field, until a long pass to Travis Haney got the Hoosiers to a first down at the PSU 1. 

Four downs to get one yard.  And Penn State was dogshit that year, too.  How hard could it be?

Folks, me and the rest of the Hundred stood there with our shakos in our hands, ready to go down on the field for the postgame concert, but not putting our helmets on until we knew whether we'd won or lost (then as now: backwards for a win, forwards for a typical L).  And we watched each attempt, as DiNardo's Hoosiers ran and ran and ran and ran and were stopped each time.  Turnover on downs.  22-18 loss.

Penn State fans would look back on that goal-line stand as a turning point for their program, as 2005 was the beginning of a serious return to glory, until Sandusky's crimes were exposed. 

Indiana kept on being Indiana.  Those were the Hoosiers I knew.

 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 1:54 pm
😂
👍
2
jj_mcClure
(@jj_mcclure)
Estimable Member

The regular season opener at Iowa in 2021 takes the cake for me.  I’d never had as much anticipation for an IU football season before in my life.  I drank the LEO kool-aid and believed that we were going to have with Tom Allen what we have with Cignetti now.  And it was all destroyed in what seemed like a few minutes.  My subsequent meltdown on the old Rivals board was pretty ugly and embarrassing.  I’m just glad it can’t be looked up anymore….


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 3:40 pm
👍
2
Evan Alvarez
(@evanalvarez8)
Staff Moderator

Posted by: @lonestarhoosier1

I was a sophomore trumpet player in the Marching Hundred in 2004.  Late in the year, when we played Penn State, Indiana was down 22-18, but Matt LoVecchio managed to lead the team down the field, until a long pass to Travis Haney got the Hoosiers to a first down at the PSU 1. 

Four downs to get one yard.  And Penn State was dogshit that year, too.  How hard could it be?

Folks, me and the rest of the Hundred stood there with our shakos in our hands, ready to go down on the field for the postgame concert, but not putting our helmets on until we knew whether we'd won or lost (then as now: backwards for a win, forwards for a typical L).  And we watched each attempt, as DiNardo's Hoosiers ran and ran and ran and ran and were stopped each time.  Turnover on downs.  22-18 loss.

Penn State fans would look back on that goal-line stand as a turning point for their program, as 2005 was the beginning of a serious return to glory, until Sandusky's crimes were exposed. 

Indiana kept on being Indiana.  Those were the Hoosiers I knew.

 

Awesome story! Disappointing, of course, but awesome! Thanks for sharing!

 


Check out my latest at Hoosier Huddle here

ReplyQuote
Topic starter Posted : 01/21/2026 3:51 pm
YOTHN's avatar
(@yothn)
Prominent Member

Mine is ironically the point where even in the world of hopelessness we call IU football, we bottomed out into an even lower place.  IU was up 28-18 on Purdue in Nov of 2023, going into the 4th quarter.  We give up 17pts to give Purdue the game.  We were absolutely certain Tom Allen was never going to be the answer and we also knew he had a massive buyout (for what we assumed our administration would spend at that time).    That moment felt like the lowest of lows.  Most of the team went into the portal soon after the firing where we had no roster but in a twist of fate, 25 months later, we stand on top of the world.   But at that moment, I don't think I ever felt as little hope in IU football than that moment of the PU game. 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 4:47 pm
👍
2
Mrhighlife's avatar
(@mrhighlife)
Honorable Member

There is so many. I am sure there are others that pissed me off more at the time but for some reason these 2 stick out...

Damarlo Belchers(RIP) dropped pass in the end zone against Iowa on the final play. That would have been the game winner.

The Jordan Howard vs Michigan overtime game. Why in the fuck did they try and pass. GIVE THE FUCKING BALL TO JORDAN HOWARD!

There is so many more. I don't care about any of them anymore. 16-0 UNDEFEATED. UNDISPUTED. FLIPPING NATIONAL CHAMPIONS!!!!


 


ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/21/2026 5:00 pm
👍
4
Shooter
(@shooter)
Noble Member

Wisconsin hanging 80 on us was rock bottom for me.  I thought we'd never compete.


"You can't make someone listen to reason if they aren't willing to think"-- Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/23/2026 10:23 am
😂
1
Page 1 / 2
Share: