
On the fourth play of the game, Demond Williams Jr. took it 65 yards to the house for Washington. It was uncharacteristic of an otherwise elite Bryant Haines-led Indiana defense. This would kick-start a day of head-scratching mistakes from Indiana that would eventually lead to their demise.
Indiana has played in five intense one-score games and won four of them. They came in 9-1, in full control of a trip to Indianapolis to compete for a Big Ten Championship, but this time Indiana couldn’t shake their misfortune, and the Hoosiers’ end-of-game magic ran out.
Indiana went into its third overtime game of the season. In the first two, Indiana scored a touchdown within two plays. In this game, the Hoosiers drew up an outside run to Khobie Martin, but Alex McLaughlin blew up the play for a loss of a yard. On second down, Josh Hoover targeted Indiana’s third receiver, Shazz Preston, and that pass fell to the ground. On third down, Hoover forced a ball short of the line to gain to tight end Brock Schott. Indiana settled for three to tie the game and force a second overtime, but kicking struggles showed up again, and Indiana’s Paddy McAteer missed a 37-yard field goal.
“We ran a play that we thought had a chance in the final first down,” Cignetti said postgame. “Second down… we tried to throw the double-move… Third down… We were thinking it would go down the field, down the middle, or to the field dig and end up going to the tight end, and came up short. Now you got to kick the field goal.”
Washington fans stormed the field as they took down No. 8 Indiana 27-24 in overtime.
Indiana has been mistake-prone all season long, an uncharacteristic feature in Curt Cignetti teams, and while these mistakes had only bitten them once earlier this year, today, the Hoosiers’ mistakes may have cost them the season.
Indiana started the game giving up 14 points and 192 yards in the first quarter. A bunch of sloppy tackling went into this, but so did Indiana’s inability to bring down Williams. He is a very talented quarterback and was able to torture Indiana’s defense today.
“They did a good job of extending plays, and we didn’t do a good job of containing him (Williams)… it was just a lack of execution,” Indiana safety Preston Zachman said postgame.
In IU’s last game, a win over USC, Grant Wilson seemingly locked up the quarterback position for the Hoosiers. In this game, after throwing 8-for-16 for 119 yards and a touchdown, and specifically after almost throwing an interception, Wilson was benched for Hoover.
“I went in fully hoping, believing that Grant (Wilson) would do well and make it through the whole game,” Cignetti said. “We just got a little shaky there, something I sensed, and so Josh (Hoover) came in and made a few plays.”
Hoover lit a spark for Indiana, but the drive ended in a field goal attempt. This attempt would be good, but it was kicked by backup kicker Paddy McAteer, as Nico Radicic was benched after a blocked kick on the prior drive.
Indiana had a lot of sloppy play, but despite all of this, found themselves in a fourth-quarter game, up by seven points after a Hoover pass to Nick Marsh on a double-move.
The defense then gave up a touchdown after holding Washington out of the end zone for two quarters, and Washington tied it. Indiana would fail to score again in the game, despite having the ball with 3:34 left in the game.
“We scored a touchdown to go up seven, had an opportunity, and couldn’t close it out,” Cignetti said. “I give the guys a lot of credit for the way they competed.”
Mistakes bit Indiana; whether it was fouls, missed tackles, errant throws or missed kicks, there were too many mistakes, and it led to the loss. Indiana has been able to pull out victories despite these mistakes all season, but today it wasn’t able to.
“Every team’s identity is going to be different,” Indiana offensive tackle Carter Smith said postgame. “I feel like the team this year’s identity is just to find a way, and I think we tried our best to do that and fell short today.
A lot of stakes were on the line in this game, as Indiana had controlled it path to Indianapolis and the playoffs, but now they need some luck to make it in.
“It’s stressful as far as the CFP goes. That’s something that we can’t control; it’s full steam ahead on the bucket.”
Indiana’s next game will be senior night, at home, under the lights for the Bucket game. Indiana no longer controls its destiny, but they could still finish 10-2 and beat their rivals.
Discover more from Hoosier Huddle
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.